Inquiry into undercover policing announced
Discussion
Theresa May has announced that there will be a judge led public inquiry into undercover policing following the news that the Met spied on the family of Stephen Lawrence.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-26474009
The public inquiry has been prompted by the findings of Mark Ellison QC. A link to a .pdf of a summary of his report can be found in the BBC story.
It would seem, not that this is really news, that some aspects of undercover policing have been rather dodgy.
Carinaman/Rovinghawk - keep it on topic pls. This is about undercover policing and the Ellison report, not a repository of any and every screw-up by a police officer
Police officers/groupies - this is not intended to be an "anti-police" post, there are real problems to be dealt with.
Edit - I messed-up the thread title. Mods alerted.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-26474009
The public inquiry has been prompted by the findings of Mark Ellison QC. A link to a .pdf of a summary of his report can be found in the BBC story.
It would seem, not that this is really news, that some aspects of undercover policing have been rather dodgy.
Carinaman/Rovinghawk - keep it on topic pls. This is about undercover policing and the Ellison report, not a repository of any and every screw-up by a police officer
Police officers/groupies - this is not intended to be an "anti-police" post, there are real problems to be dealt with.
Edit - I messed-up the thread title. Mods alerted.
Edited by rohrl on Thursday 6th March 18:51
Love the messages to certain regulars, who can be seen in action on the Mitchell thread.
The difficulty I see with your admonition to Carinaman and Rovinghawk is that things like this continue to pop out of the woodwork on such a regular basis, that it is difficult to believe anything other than that police forces in this country are incapable of maintaining the standards of behaviour that the public is entitled to expect. Cue examples large and small.
While I have no doubt that under-cover policing is necessary to deal with serious crime and national intelligence matters; I am also in no doubt that it needs to be very tightly overseen to prevent abuses such as have caused this enquiry.
The difficulty I see with your admonition to Carinaman and Rovinghawk is that things like this continue to pop out of the woodwork on such a regular basis, that it is difficult to believe anything other than that police forces in this country are incapable of maintaining the standards of behaviour that the public is entitled to expect. Cue examples large and small.
While I have no doubt that under-cover policing is necessary to deal with serious crime and national intelligence matters; I am also in no doubt that it needs to be very tightly overseen to prevent abuses such as have caused this enquiry.
jensenhealey2 said:
The difficulty I see with your admonition to Carinaman and Rovinghawk is that things like this continue to pop out of the woodwork on such a regular basis, that it is difficult to believe anything other than that police forces in this country are incapable of maintaining the standards of behaviour that the public is entitled to expect. Cue examples large and small.
.
This. .
jensenhealey2 said:
Love the messages to certain regulars, who can be seen in action on the Mitchell thread.
The difficulty I see with your admonition to Carinaman and Rovinghawk is that things like this continue to pop out of the woodwork on such a regular basis, that it is difficult to believe anything other than that police forces in this country are incapable of maintaining the standards of behaviour that the public is entitled to expect. Cue examples large and small.
While I have no doubt that under-cover policing is necessary to deal with serious crime and national intelligence matters; I am also in no doubt that it needs to be very tightly overseen to prevent abuses such as have caused this enquiry.
I sometimes think some members of the public set their expectations too high.The difficulty I see with your admonition to Carinaman and Rovinghawk is that things like this continue to pop out of the woodwork on such a regular basis, that it is difficult to believe anything other than that police forces in this country are incapable of maintaining the standards of behaviour that the public is entitled to expect. Cue examples large and small.
While I have no doubt that under-cover policing is necessary to deal with serious crime and national intelligence matters; I am also in no doubt that it needs to be very tightly overseen to prevent abuses such as have caused this enquiry.
I also find it quite sad how many people blame the police rather than the criminals.
rohrl said:
Rovinghawk - keep it on topic pls. This is about undercover policing and the Ellison report, not a repository of any and every screw-up by a police officer
The apologists will point out that screw-ups are incredibly rare & all in the past. My position on this is that investigations take a long time in order to consider all the evidence fully, and therefore any discussion will inevitably lag behind actual events. My further position is that institutional change is extremely slow, so any conclusions drawn will apply to the present day as much as to the past.I look forward to a meaningful debate on this subject; I'd be delighted to keep it on topic & would request that certain other posters use facts rather than the personal insults which typifies their response to any criticism of poor behaviour.
La Liga said:
hat undermines this is that most discoveries of breach of standards are from the police themselves. So an alternative view is that they are good at maintaining standards and dedicated, on the whole, to dealing with those who don't maintain standards.
That's like saying most engine faults are discovered by mechanics- it's hardly surprising.The issue isn't with the good ones, though; I'd hope we're all in favour of them.
The issue is with the bad ones and those not-so-bad who close ranks with their colleagues.
jensenhealey2 said:
The difficulty I see with your admonition to Carinaman and Rovinghawk is that things like this continue to pop out of the woodwork on such a regular basis, that it is difficult to believe anything other than that police forces in this country are incapable of maintaining the standards of behaviour that the public is entitled to expect. Cue examples large and small.
What undermines this is that most discoveries of breach of standards are from the police themselves. So an alternative view is that they are good at maintaining standards and dedicated, on the whole, to dealing with those who don't maintain standards.Report 3.2.3 said:
If the criminal standard of proof is applied to this allegation, as it was applied by the Stephen Lawrence Inquiry to allegations of corruption, we find it unlikely that any future Public Inquiry would be able to reach a firm conclusion that it was sure that the allegation was true.
Report 4.0 said:
We acknowledge that for decades the SDS provided effective warning to enable the parts of the MPS dealing with the policing of public disorder to plan and allocate appropriate resources to meet the risks. Intelligence provided by the SDS thereby enabled a tighter management of the MPS resources. Valuable intelligence was also provided to the Security Service.
There were also many examples of SDS undercover officers running great risks to themselves in order to gain very valuable intelligence.
So for decades one of the most risky (in many senses) areas of policing did its job. Is this just a bad example? It seems that way. Funny how the media haven't picked up on this bit, but of one person deployed inappropriately within the decades and thousands of deployments where things apparently worked fine. There were also many examples of SDS undercover officers running great risks to themselves in order to gain very valuable intelligence.
Rovinghawk said:
My further position is that institutional change is extremely slow, so any conclusions drawn will apply to the present day as much as to the past.
The report suggests that the institution was "for decades" providing effective warning. Would we want to change from that? Rovinghawk said:
La Liga said:
hat undermines this is that most discoveries of breach of standards are from the police themselves. So an alternative view is that they are good at maintaining standards and dedicated, on the whole, to dealing with those who don't maintain standards.
That's like saying most engine faults are discovered by mechanics- it's hardly surprising.The issue isn't with the good ones, though; I'd hope we're all in favour of them.
The issue is with the bad ones and those not-so-bad who close ranks with their colleagues.
It's not the same since people are implying the police are corrupt and cover-up. The police policing themselves on the whole doesn't really support this, does it?
La Liga said:
Rovinghawk said:
My further position is that institutional change is extremely slow, so any conclusions drawn will apply to the present day as much as to the past.
The report suggests that the institution was "for decades" providing effective warning. Would we want to change from that? La Liga said:
It's not the same since people are implying the police are corrupt and cover-up. The police policing themselves on the whole doesn't really support this, does it?
Good police discover bad police therefore the police are good? I'm not convinced of the logic there.Edited by Rovinghawk on Friday 7th March 08:08
Rovinghawk said:
La Liga said:
Rovinghawk said:
My further position is that institutional change is extremely slow, so any conclusions drawn will apply to the present day as much as to the past.
The report suggests that the institution was "for decades" providing effective warning. Would we want to change from that? "If aeroplanes are safe, then why do some crash?"
Air travel can be, ON THE WHOLE, safe, just as undercover policing can be, ON THE WHOLE, effective for decades. That doesn't mean air travel is perfect, just as uncovering policing isn't perfect. Just as nothing is perfect.
Rovinghawk said:
La Liga said:
It's not the same since people are implying the police are corrupt and cover-up. The police policing themselves on the whole doesn't really support this, does it?
Good police discover bad police therefore the police are good? I'm not convinced of the logic there.Mostly rather than completely effective, then.
I'd still suggest that a culture of cover-up exists, even if not ubiquitous.
La Liga said:
ecause an institutionally / culturally corrupt organisation wouldn't deal with the corrupt individuals, would it? Which would be BAD. The fact it does is GOOD.
I told Rohrl I wouldn't bring up extraneous topics, but may I point out that examples exist of moderately large scale cover-ups & excuse-making?I'd still suggest that a culture of cover-up exists, even if not ubiquitous.
I believe the problem with inquiries such as this one, and Hillsborough, is this; the facts have taken so long to come out, that even if it is actually the whole sordid truth, there will always be a large chuck on people believe there is still yet more to come.
A little like 911 and JFK you can publish all the data and evidence you want, but people will always think the worst. At what point do you accept this and stop chucking good money after bad.
A little like 911 and JFK you can publish all the data and evidence you want, but people will always think the worst. At what point do you accept this and stop chucking good money after bad.
Rovinghawk said:
Mostly rather than completely effective, then.
No one said completely. Rovinghawk said:
I told Rohrl I wouldn't bring up extraneous topics, but may I point out that examples exist of moderately large scale cover-ups & excuse-making?
I'd still suggest that a culture of cover-up exists, even if not ubiquitous.
Things like Hillsborough exist, yes, but then they stand out so much because of how far from the norm they are. Especially in modern times. I don't think there's a culture today of covering-up. The risk is too high and the appetite too large to see it not happening. Corruption is nearly always down to individuals, occasionally more than one. I'd still suggest that a culture of cover-up exists, even if not ubiquitous.
We're talking here about an officer deployed over 20 years ago. That doesn't excuse any wrong-doing, but I'd be cautious of applying that discovery to how today works.
La Liga said:
Corruption is nearly always down to individuals, occasionally more than one.
We're talking here about an officer deployed over 20 years ago. That doesn't excuse any wrong-doing, but I'd be cautious of applying that discovery to how today works.
Plebgate (sorry, Rohrl) is a recent example of how it's from the very bottom to the very top- not actual conspiracy but individuals working in unison towards a common (corrupt) goal.We're talking here about an officer deployed over 20 years ago. That doesn't excuse any wrong-doing, but I'd be cautious of applying that discovery to how today works.
As per my original post, change is slow.
Which resulted in one person being sent to prison and another dismissed for their part in it. You may not like the internal wranglings of internal disciplinary procedures, but all organisations have some leeway and discretion on how they mange their own internal matters.
Again, no one is trying to argue things don't happen which shouldn't. You can't take the position against one no one is taking.
Again, no one is trying to argue things don't happen which shouldn't. You can't take the position against one no one is taking.
Report 4.0 said:
We acknowledge that for decades the SDS provided effective warning to enable the parts of the MPS dealing with the policing of public disorder to plan and allocate appropriate resources to meet the risks. Intelligence provided by the SDS thereby enabled a tighter management of the MPS resources. Valuable intelligence was also provided to the Security Service.
There were also many examples of SDS undercover officers running great risks to themselves in order to gain very valuable intelligence.
I wonder when the media, in the interest of balance, will mention the "many examples" of officers running "great risks", which are highly likely to be above and beyond and expectation to keep the public safe. There were also many examples of SDS undercover officers running great risks to themselves in order to gain very valuable intelligence.
You're talking about changes in human nature, not organisations. People will always do bad things. People will always be police officers. Police officers will always do bad things.
That stands separate to how an organisation changes. The two events mentioned are over 20 years ago. There's been much organisational change in the police for the better around this subject area. Even if it were a reasonable slow pace, that would still amount to a lot of that time frame. Some is fast, like the reaction to Hillsborough in terms of crowd management. I hear stories and practices from that sort of era from those who were there and are here now. It's a different world to what we have now. For the better in most part.
Naming a recent example of corruption doesn't prove that organisational change has been slow, it proves people will, on occasion, do bad things.
That stands separate to how an organisation changes. The two events mentioned are over 20 years ago. There's been much organisational change in the police for the better around this subject area. Even if it were a reasonable slow pace, that would still amount to a lot of that time frame. Some is fast, like the reaction to Hillsborough in terms of crowd management. I hear stories and practices from that sort of era from those who were there and are here now. It's a different world to what we have now. For the better in most part.
Naming a recent example of corruption doesn't prove that organisational change has been slow, it proves people will, on occasion, do bad things.
My thoughts were more to do with cultural change than organisational.
If you tell me cultural change is quick then I will agree to disagree.
Just a reminder for everyone debating here: Some of the Standard Excuses:
4 The Munich Agreement excuse It occurred before important facts were known, and cannot happen again (The important facts in question were that Hitler wanted to conquer Europe. This was actually known; but not to the Foreign Office, of course)
5 The Charge of the Light Brigade excuse It was an unfortunate lapse by an individual which has now been dealt with under internal disciplinary procedures
If you tell me cultural change is quick then I will agree to disagree.
Just a reminder for everyone debating here: Some of the Standard Excuses:
4 The Munich Agreement excuse It occurred before important facts were known, and cannot happen again (The important facts in question were that Hitler wanted to conquer Europe. This was actually known; but not to the Foreign Office, of course)
5 The Charge of the Light Brigade excuse It was an unfortunate lapse by an individual which has now been dealt with under internal disciplinary procedures
Edited by Rovinghawk on Friday 7th March 12:09
Rovinghawk said:
My thoughts were more to do with cultural change than organisational.
If you tell me cultural change is quick then I will agree to disagree.
No, it's not quick. But the reference point and source of this topic is an incident that which was nearly 21 years ago. The majority of police officers who served then will not be serving now. The culture, behaviour and attitudes which led to such a sham of an investigation have changed. Perhaps this is best demonstrated by the hard work put in to finally obtain convictions against the murderers of Stephen Lawrence. If you tell me cultural change is quick then I will agree to disagree.
La Liga said:
I wonder when the media, in the interest of balance, will mention the "many examples" of officers running "great risks", which are highly likely to be above and beyond and expectation to keep the public safe.
Fair play to the BBC: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-26485664BBC said:
In his report, Mark Ellison QC said there were many examples of SDS undercover officers running great risks to themselves in order to gain very valuable intelligence.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



te, rotten to the core ones that spread to and infect all the good ones....