Wind knocks new walls down is builder responsible
Wind knocks new walls down is builder responsible
Author
Discussion

hunton69

Original Poster:

674 posts

168 months

Friday 7th March 2014
quotequote all
The brickie that I have employed to build an outbuilding had one of his walls fall down at Christmas I let my feelings known that I was not happy but paid for it to be rebuilt. In the last set of storms 4 pillar walls have fallen down. The roofer who was working on the other part of the building had said to him are you not going to shore those up. His answer was he put a piece of wood across the top of the pillars not fixed just the weight of the wood and should be ok.
He is not taking any responsibility for this and blames the weather.
He was on a day rate and was more than happy for him to spend a couple of hours shoring the pillars.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 7th March 2014
quotequote all
You need the advice of a builder before that of a lawyer. Was the work done to a competent standard? Did the wall fail because of the extreme weather, or because of bad work? If the latter, you can claim. If the former, you can't. Test it this way: would a well built wall have failed in the extreme weather? Big Bad Wolf huffed and puffed.

Mobsy

80 posts

254 months

Friday 7th March 2014
quotequote all
I think the mistake is that he was on a day rate. Are you sure he wasn't sneaking back in the middle of the night and pushing them over? wink

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Friday 7th March 2014
quotequote all
Speaking for bigger contracts, it's the contractor's responsibility to protect the works from damage until the finished item is handed over to the client.

It's in every construction contract I've ever been involved in.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Friday 7th March 2014
quotequote all
hunton69 said:
He was on a day rate and was more than happy for him to spend a couple of hours shoring the pillars.
He was on a day rate and was more than happy to get paid more by keeping re-doing the job.

Busa mav

2,848 posts

185 months

Friday 7th March 2014
quotequote all
Builders responsibility all day long, no excuse at all.

High winds haven't exactly bee a surprise of late .

Personally , I think he should be embarrassed at having cocked up so badly , just shows how green he is.

Is there a dpc in the fallen walls ?

hunton69

Original Poster:

674 posts

168 months

Friday 7th March 2014
quotequote all
Its at the dpc level that it broke.

All the corners and the pillars with extra blocks for the roof supports have stayed up.

The xmas one was worse as there is an internal block wall that links into it that he did not build.
When he rebuilt that wall he linked in the internal wall and the winds that knocked the others down that wall stayed up.
I was happy to compromise with him but he says it's not his fault.

Not sure what options I have. Don't want him back with that attitude.


Qcarchoo

471 posts

224 months

Friday 7th March 2014
quotequote all
Single skin block walls are particularly vulnerable before they are tied in with the roof/floor. It's common sense, if it's windy, to shore the walls up. Some people aren't paid to think though.

AlonzoHarris

122 posts

155 months

Friday 7th March 2014
quotequote all
I am having an issue with a piece of scaffolding that came loose in the bad weather and damaged my car. I think insurance companies are taking the line that any damage during the spell of bad weather is unpreventable and an "Act of God", despite circumstance or even that Acts of God aren't recognised in this country!

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Friday 7th March 2014
quotequote all
hunton69 said:
Its at the dpc level that it broke.
a known slip plane- any brickie worth a damn knows it.

hunton69 said:
I was happy to compromise with him but he says it's not his fault.
If he's worked for any decent firm he'll know protection of the works during construction is HIS responsibility not yours.

hunton69 said:
Not sure what options I have.
Fat chance getting any money back. Any money owing to him can be allocated to the rebuild.
In future, tell him or his replacement the final 15% of anything to be paid will be paid at the end of the job, not PAYG.

Rude-boy

22,227 posts

264 months

Friday 7th March 2014
quotequote all
Rovinghawk said:
Fat chance getting any money back. Any money owing to him can be allocated to the rebuild.
In future, tell him or his replacement the final 15% of anything to be paid will be paid at the end of the job, not PAYG.
yes

Biggest mistake I have ever made when paying tradespeople was agreeing to PAYG.

Second worst was agreeing an hourly rate, although that one didn't cost me too much as I asked for the first invoice after he'd been there for 2 4 hour days and sure enough his bill was for nearly 16 hours. I had been there both days the entire time. There were no other workers and half the time he was there he was either drinking the tea i had made, eating the bacon butty i had made or talking on his mobile in the van...

TorqueVR

1,981 posts

230 months

Friday 7th March 2014
quotequote all
Sorry Breadvan but I think you are wrong. He needs advice but getting another builder in will be little help as hE will most likely have no qualifications and be highly unlikely to be able to prepare a report. He needs a chartered surveyor.

Vaud

60,004 posts

186 months

Friday 7th March 2014
quotequote all
Rovinghawk said:
Fat chance getting any money back. Any money owing to him can be allocated to the rebuild.
In future, tell him or his replacement the final 15% of anything to be paid will be paid at the end of the job, not PAYG.
15% is not likely to motivate completion... more likely for them to write it off on a small job.

thetrash

1,860 posts

237 months

Friday 7th March 2014
quotequote all
hunton69 said:
I was happy to compromise with him but he says it's not his fault.
If he's worked for any decent firm he'll know protection of the works during construction is HIS responsibility not yours.

Yea, defiantly the bricklayers responsibility until it's up to roof plate/ final height.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 7th March 2014
quotequote all
TorqueVR said:
Sorry Breadvan but I think you are wrong. He needs advice but getting another builder in will be little help as hE will most likely have no qualifications and be highly unlikely to be able to prepare a report. He needs a chartered surveyor.
OK, I'll go with that. The issue is still whether the work was done badly or was carelessly left without the protection that a careful builder would give it, or was the collapse something that would have happened anyway because of the high winds.

b0rk

2,412 posts

177 months

Friday 7th March 2014
quotequote all
hunton69 said:
Its at the dpc level that it broke.

All the corners and the pillars with extra blocks for the roof supports have stayed up.

The xmas one was worse as there is an internal block wall that links into it that he did not build.
When he rebuilt that wall he linked in the internal wall and the winds that knocked the others down that wall stayed up.
I was happy to compromise with him but he says it's not his fault.

Not sure what options I have. Don't want him back with that attitude.
Was the bricklayer professionally trained e.g. NVQ 1/2/3 to work on a commercial building site as a bricklayer he would need a CSCS operative card in bricklaying which requires an appropriate professional qualification. A cavity wall that is not tied between the leafs does not comply with building regulations.

A competent bricklayer would have temporary shored a single leaf wall during construction until the wall plate and roof trusses where fitted. Collapse due to even normal wind during construction is a well known and understood problem

I'd guess your brickie is an unskilled labourer that can lay bricks (sort of) and is really, really cheap. Kick him off and get proper qualified brickie to do it on piece work valued weekly / bi-weekly.

hunton69

Original Poster:

674 posts

168 months

Saturday 8th March 2014
quotequote all
b0rk said:
Was the bricklayer professionally trained e.g. NVQ 1/2/3 to work on a commercial building site as a bricklayer he would need a CSCS operative card in bricklaying which requires an appropriate professional qualification. A cavity wall that is not tied between the leafs does not comply with building regulations.

A competent bricklayer would have temporary shored a single leaf wall during construction until the wall plate and roof trusses where fitted. Collapse due to even normal wind during construction is a well known and understood problem

I'd guess your brickie is an unskilled labourer that can lay bricks (sort of) and is really, really cheap. Kick him off and get proper qualified brickie to do it on piece work valued weekly / bi-weekly.
Not sure of his qualifications but he was very methodical and he came highly recommended and had proven work with reclaimed bricks which we were using. He worked as a 1 and 1 gang during the week but bought 2 extra brickies in at the weekend. Was slow but that was what I was happy with as I was more interested in quality.
Certainly wasnot cheap.




Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Saturday 8th March 2014
quotequote all
Vaud said:
Rovinghawk said:
Fat chance getting any money back. Any money owing to him can be allocated to the rebuild.
In future, tell him or his replacement the final 15% of anything to be paid will be paid at the end of the job, not PAYG.
15% is not likely to motivate completion... more likely for them to write it off on a small job.
You'll rarely get them to agree to a higher figure.

Qcarchoo

471 posts

224 months

Saturday 8th March 2014
quotequote all
If the bricklayer is self employed then his public liability insurance should cover this, assuming he is insured.
You might find that he is operating illegally if he has no insurance to cover his employees.


Edited by Qcarchoo on Saturday 8th March 08:00

hedgefinder

3,418 posts

201 months

Saturday 8th March 2014
quotequote all
paying people on day rate is usually a nightmare...
I had a brickie work for me 2 years ago, he gave a set price for soem of the work then when I added an additional piece of brickwork 1/4of the size he had completed he asked for day rate and I quote "as it would work out cheaper for me"
after the small additonal work taking virtually as long as the whole buiding project previously he was kiced off the job when a couple of neighbours told me that everyday after I left for work he packed up his van and left after doing an hours work.