eBay Threats and Terror...
Discussion
Hi
Quick question, advice appreciated...
I have a friend who put a vehicle up for sale on eBay.
They got the usual barrage of "BEST PRICE MATE!?" offers, as I warned them they would. And they then exchanged some messages wit a reasonable sounding bloke who offered near the reserve price.
They told him, and I quote: "At that price I would end the auction and hold the car for you if you pay a non refundable deposit" - that was it.
The bloke then kept asking where to send the money, whilst they sorted a PayPal account.
No deposit was paid.
Then they changed their mind and told the bloke it wasn't for sale (I think more because of the tone of the bloke to be honest). And delisted the item and told him it wasn't for sale anymore.
Bloke is now threatening solicitors because "a contract was in place".
I have no idea.
Sounds spurious to me.
Help?
Quick question, advice appreciated...
I have a friend who put a vehicle up for sale on eBay.
They got the usual barrage of "BEST PRICE MATE!?" offers, as I warned them they would. And they then exchanged some messages wit a reasonable sounding bloke who offered near the reserve price.
They told him, and I quote: "At that price I would end the auction and hold the car for you if you pay a non refundable deposit" - that was it.
The bloke then kept asking where to send the money, whilst they sorted a PayPal account.
No deposit was paid.
Then they changed their mind and told the bloke it wasn't for sale (I think more because of the tone of the bloke to be honest). And delisted the item and told him it wasn't for sale anymore.
Bloke is now threatening solicitors because "a contract was in place".
I have no idea.
Sounds spurious to me.
Help?
This is pretty much what I was thinking... I just didn't want to give bad advice simply because it's exactly what I would do in the same situation.
Why would I need to tell them to close or change their eBay accounts?
(no PayPal was used at all and they ended the listing and have decided to sell it locally).
JustinP1 said:
No deposit - no contract. Even if he paid a deposit, he'd still have no chance in claiming losses.
Not true at all, verbal agreements are contracts in law and no formal written agreement is needed, nor is any action required by either party unless stipulated during negotiations. IE
If you said, "I will hold the car until Friday for you to pay the deposit". Then on Saturday you are free to do as you please, as the counter-party has not performed the action required. If you just said "Okay, I'll sell you the car for £1200" then a contract has been formed and the counter-party has an unspecified amount of time to complete their side of the bargin. In reality, you would be expected to keep it for a reasonable time and then attempt to contact the buyer before re-selling it. If someone came along 15 mins later and offered £2000 you cant just go and sell it to him because he offered better money. Technically you have a contract when you accepted the £1200 in return for the car.
You soon learn to be VERY careful about your use of words!

Condi said:
JustinP1 said:
No deposit - no contract. Even if he paid a deposit, he'd still have no chance in claiming losses.
Not true at all, verbal agreements are contracts in law and no formal written agreement is needed, nor is any action required by either party unless stipulated during negotiations. IE
If you said, "I will hold the car until Friday for you to pay the deposit". Then on Saturday you are free to do as you please, as the counter-party has not performed the action required. If you just said "Okay, I'll sell you the car for £1200" then a contract has been formed and the counter-party has an unspecified amount of time to complete their side of the bargin. In reality, you would be expected to keep it for a reasonable time and then attempt to contact the buyer before re-selling it. If someone came along 15 mins later and offered £2000 you cant just go and sell it to him because he offered better money. Technically you have a contract when you accepted the £1200 in return for the car.
You soon learn to be VERY careful about your use of words!

I think you are referring to a contract formed orally. All contracts involving words including written ones are 'verbal' contracts.2) Re-read the OP:
Gorvid said:
They told him, and I quote: "At that price I would end the auction and hold the car for you if you pay a non refundable deposit" - that was it.
The agreement was that the OP would end the auction and hold the car when a non-refundable deposit was paid.No deposit was paid. So, I reiterate, no contract has been formed.
3) Even if that were not the case, what is the action under law that the 'buyer' could sue for? And is that realistic?
Edited by JustinP1 on Friday 7th March 19:49
JustinP1 said:
The agreement was that the OP would end the auction and hold the car when a non-refundable deposit was paid.
No deposit was paid. So, I reiterate, no contract has been formed.
But no time limit was agreed, and the buyer obviously had intended to pay the deposit, as he kept asking where to pay it. If he wanted to pay, but was unable due to by the sellers actions (ie not providing a bank account or paypal details) then the buyer is not in the wrong. No deposit was paid. So, I reiterate, no contract has been formed.
The exact exchange was:
"I'd end the auction and make a deal at £2000."
"if you are a serious buyer and you can make a deposit, I'm willing to stop the auction and hold it for you."
Then an exchange of other questions about the car.
Then the bloke asking where to send the deposit.
Then my friend saying, I need to have a think about it, I will get back to you.
Then the bloke going a bit angry and shouty.
Then my friend saying, ok, you're being weird, not for sale anymore.
Riveting stuff.
Condi said:
JustinP1 said:
The agreement was that the OP would end the auction and hold the car when a non-refundable deposit was paid.
No deposit was paid. So, I reiterate, no contract has been formed.
But no time limit was agreed, and the buyer obviously had intended to pay the deposit, as he kept asking where to pay it. If he wanted to pay, but was unable due to by the sellers actions (ie not providing a bank account or paypal details) then the buyer is not in the wrong. No deposit was paid. So, I reiterate, no contract has been formed.
Intent to form a contract does not form a contract.
The buyer knew that the car was to be sold by auction.
Whether he intended to send a deposit or not is irrelevant. Don't get me wrong - if the deposit was received things would be very different in principle but still almost impossible to enforce anyway.
Gorvid said:
I'm extremely sceptical of there being anything lawfully binding about deciding you don't want to sell something you own to someone, even if you've already said you would.
Also...
Surely the bloke is in the wrong for going on eBay and asking to buy outside eBay?
It depends.Also...
Surely the bloke is in the wrong for going on eBay and asking to buy outside eBay?
If you've made an offer and that offer is accepted, then yes, contractually, you are bound in law. However, the issue is then enforcing that. If the breach has caused a commercial loss that needs to be proven. Otherwise, there's nothing to sue for and judgment for specific performance is very rare.
In this situation it can be interpreted that your mate has made an offer based on a condition. That was a non-refundable deposit being received.
Should that deposit not be received, then the conditions of the offer has not been made. Furthermore, before it is accepted, your mate is within his rights to let the other party now that his offer is no longer 'on the table'.
That's the key point here, not the former point.
JustinP1 said:
Furthermore, before it is accepted, your mate is within his rights to let the other party now that his offer is no longer 'on the table'.
Ah, that's pretty clear - is that definite? (they are stressing about it a bit).I mean, they deliberately didn't let him send a deposit because they weren't certain they wanted to sell to him, then they decided definitely not and said so.
They aren't going to be hanged?
JustinP1 said:
The agreement was that the OP would end the auction and hold the car when a non-refundable deposit was paid.
No deposit was paid. So, I reiterate, no contract has been formed.
Justin, you are contradicting yourself and appear to be confusing two different concepts. You refer to an agreement and then say that there was no contract. You appear to be mixing up contract formation and contract performance. No deposit was paid. So, I reiterate, no contract has been formed.
Based on the OP's longer narrative, I am not sure that the parties reached agreement, but to advise properly I would need to see the full exchange of emails.
An offer that has not yet been accepted can be withdrawn. If the offer is accepted then there is a contract (assuming the other ingredients of a contract are present). It is not yet clear to me whether the offer to sell the car if a deposit was paid was accepted before that offer was withdrawn (or purportedly so). The actual payment may not be the issue, as if the buyer said yes to the terms offered that could be sufficient to make a deal.
I reiterate that I would need to see the actual emails before advising with confidence.
I reiterate that I would need to see the actual emails before advising with confidence.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



k up any thing they try and sell in the future