Taxable benefit query
Taxable benefit query
Author
Discussion

Countdown

Original Poster:

49,561 posts

227 months

Sunday 9th March 2014
quotequote all
Hi all

One of our employees is currently doing a 3 hour commute each way to her main office. She says that it's a struggle doing this 2/3 times per week (the other days she works from home) and has asked if she can stay overnight one night per week close to the office.

Does anybody know if this is classed as a taxable benefit?

TIA

Eric Mc

125,928 posts

296 months

Sunday 9th March 2014
quotequote all
Yes.

Countdown

Original Poster:

49,561 posts

227 months

Sunday 9th March 2014
quotequote all
Thanks Eric smile

Eric Mc

125,928 posts

296 months

Sunday 9th March 2014
quotequote all
Employer provided accommodation is always looked on as a BIK UNLESS the accommodation is an intrinsic part of the duties of the employee - like a shop manager having to live over a shop, or a fire chief having to live over the fire station.

Teachers who teach at boarding schools and who live on site are also not taxed under the "Employer Provided Accommodation BIK" rules.

POORCARDEALER

8,670 posts

272 months

Sunday 9th March 2014
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
Yes.
You 100% sure Eric?

Would this not be dictated by where her "normal place of work is"?

Ie If she was asked to work at another site for a few months and stayed in a hotel rather than commute then this wouldnt be classed as a BIK?

Eric Mc

125,928 posts

296 months

Sunday 9th March 2014
quotequote all
You can always argue a case with HMRC but the rules are quite restricted regarding accommodation supplied by an employer. In the circumstances outlined by the OP I wouldn't see that the provision of accommodation could be construed by HMRC as being essential to the job the employee carries out.

The alternative is for the employer to NOT declare the accommodation on the employees P11D and then run the risk of having to pay X number of years backlog on underpaid PAYE plus fines and penalties for failure to submit a correct P11D for the employee.

98elise

32,878 posts

192 months

Sunday 9th March 2014
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
You can always argue a case with HMRC but the rules are quite restricted regarding accommodation supplied by an employer. In the circumstances outlined by the OP I wouldn't see that the provision of accommodation could be construed by HMRC as being essential to the job the employee carries out.

The alternative is for the employer to NOT declare the accommodation on the employees P11D and then run the risk of having to pay X number of years backlog on underpaid PAYE plus fines and penalties for failure to submit a correct P11D for the employee.
At what point does a hotel become essential?

I'm working in Exeter over this weekend, and my employer is providing a hotel. I live in Kent so its clearly not possible for me to commute here when I'm needed working shifts the other side of the country.

Eric Mc

125,928 posts

296 months

Sunday 9th March 2014
quotequote all
If you have to stay in a hotel or bed & breakfast or rent a property just to be near to your MAIN PLACE OF WORK and the employer is paying for it, then HMRC will look on that as a BIK.

If you are sent away on a one off or temporary basis to work off-site, then that accommodation can be paid for by HMRC without a BIK being incurred.

Obviously, on occasions, there may be blurring of some of these distinctions but, if an employer is in doubt as to the BIK position of something they are paying for on behalf of an employee, the employer should contact HMRC for clarification IN WRITING.

If they "take a flyer" and assume no BIK will arise, then they may face a hefty tax bill and related penalties at a later date. And the employee may also be chased for underpaid PAYE - for which they will not be thankful.

Countdown

Original Poster:

49,561 posts

227 months

Sunday 9th March 2014
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
If you have to stay in a hotel or bed & breakfast or rent a property just to be near to your MAIN PLACE OF WORK and the employer is paying for it, then HMRC will look on that as a BIK.
yep - its her main place of work (as a result of organisational redundancy/restructure). It looks like she'll have to submit her expenses and we'll need to gross them up for Tax and NI and then process them via Payroll.

Eric Mc

125,928 posts

296 months

Sunday 9th March 2014
quotequote all
Does she plan to relocate nearer to her employment?

Countdown

Original Poster:

49,561 posts

227 months

Sunday 9th March 2014
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
Does she plan to relocate nearer to her employment?
Its still up in the air. We might be leasing a small office for 3-5 years and then look at how things are. The problem is that she's based in the South West and although we only have a relatively few clients in that region they are spread out over a large area so wherever the permanent office is finally situated there will be some winners and some losers.

Temporarily a lot of people are working from home most days and just meeting up 1-2 days per week..

Eric Mc

125,928 posts

296 months

Monday 10th March 2014
quotequote all
If she relocates, the employer CAN pay her relocation expenses to cover her moving costs. But once permanently installed in her new place of residence (whatever it is) the employer can't really pay those accommodation costs without BIK coming into play.