Test drive of a Golf GT Tdi PD 150, have a question
Test drive of a Golf GT Tdi PD 150, have a question
Author
Discussion

junglist

Original Poster:

73 posts

291 months

Sunday 9th March 2014
quotequote all
Evening,
I test drove a 2002 Golf GT Tdi (150bhp version). It's had a recent replacement camshaft, cambelt, clutch, flywheel and injectors. It drives ok but upon start up (with warm engine as I didn't get to see it from cold) there is a very brief metallic rattle from the engine that goes away about a second after start. Hard to place it but any ideas or is this common? Car seemed to pull and boost ok during the drive.
Thanks

Barryboyni

179 posts

156 months

Sunday 9th March 2014
quotequote all
The starters rattle a bit on them sometimes

Glosphil

4,907 posts

265 months

Monday 10th March 2014
quotequote all
junglist said:
Evening,
I test drove a 2002 Golf GT Tdi (150bhp version). It's had a recent replacement camshaft, cambelt, clutch, flywheel and injectors. It drives ok but upon start up (with warm engine as I didn't get to see it from cold) there is a very brief metallic rattle from the engine that goes away about a second after start. Hard to place it but any ideas or is this common? Car seemed to pull and boost ok during the drive.
Thanks
Isn't it 140bhp (actually 140ps)?

Maracus

4,553 posts

199 months

Monday 10th March 2014
quotequote all
Glosphil said:
Isn't it 140bhp (actually 140ps)?
At that age, it's either 130 or 150.

Pentoman

4,838 posts

294 months

Monday 10th March 2014
quotequote all
Maracus said:
At that age, it's either 130 or 150.
Indeed. Because it's the 1.9 not the 2.0.

Is the 150bhp still known for being unreliable (camshafts)? I'm currently using a borrowed 130bhp on 160,000 miles and am very impressed.

phumy

5,829 posts

268 months

Monday 10th March 2014
quotequote all
Pentoman said:
Maracus said:
At that age, it's either 130 or 150.
Indeed. Because it's the 1.9 not the 2.0.

Is the 150bhp still known for being unreliable (camshafts)? I'm currently using a borrowed 130bhp on 160,000 miles and am very impressed.
Yes they are known for dodgy camshafts (ERL engine), I had one go on my 150 pd at around 60k miles, they tend to go before 100k miles so if you have one that is well over that mileage its either had the cam changed or its not going to go now if it hasn't already.

Maracus

4,553 posts

199 months

Monday 10th March 2014
quotequote all
Iirc the problem is with the cam lobes, they wear.

I ran a 150 for a year and didn't have a problem with it. 100k at 4 years old. Not saying the bloke who bought it off me wouldn't.

I looked at them again about a year ago, and quite a few had new camshafts on auto trader. So one of these would be the car to go for.

a4cabrio

933 posts

190 months

Monday 10th March 2014
quotequote all
I had a mk4 gt tdi 130bhp, sold it with 179,000 miles on it, great car, i bought it on 111,000 and 3 years old, I changed shocks and bushes when I got it and that car never let me down, frequent servicing and they will go for ever.

I wanted a 150bhp model at the time but was recommended to go for a 130bhp model due to the potential problems already mentioned, I'm glad I listened.

chris285

812 posts

163 months

Tuesday 11th March 2014
quotequote all
The early pd150 lumps were prone to wear on the cam lobe's as stated, i've got a 05 plate leon fr done 78k and always been serviced regular with the right oil and i've been told later engines are better and as long as they are looked after they should be fine


BGarside

1,568 posts

168 months

Tuesday 11th March 2014
quotequote all
Got a Leon FR TDI 150hp and no rattles on start-up, though used to rattle on idle when I bought it. The cause was the alternator clutch pulley having seized - this caused the alternator drive belt tensioner to jump around at idle so can be visually checked easily enough.

I'm on 68k miles and no sign of cam issues yet, but I perform regular oil changes and the correct, PD-specific oil (VW spec. 505.01 or 507.00) is essential.

The 150hp engine suffers from more lag than the 130hp, which I understand is due to a slightly larger turbo (and more voluminous intercooler / pipework) than the 130hp model. In retrospect I'd go for the 130hp version, but if you're thinking of tuning for big power (200+ hp) then the 150 is a better basis (stronger head bolts, larger turbo, FMIC).