Civil Procedure
Discussion
I'm after some advice from those in the know, please.
This is a hypothetical situation but similar to actual events.
I took somebody to county court and lost the case. I went to appeal and won part of it but half way through the trial, I discovered that the respondent had committed an illegality when entering the contract. I raised this with the Judge and was told that this issue cannot be used during the appeal. The case was then adjourned to a later date.
What is the best course of action? Request second appeal? Request retrial?
Thanks in advance
This is a hypothetical situation but similar to actual events.
I took somebody to county court and lost the case. I went to appeal and won part of it but half way through the trial, I discovered that the respondent had committed an illegality when entering the contract. I raised this with the Judge and was told that this issue cannot be used during the appeal. The case was then adjourned to a later date.
What is the best course of action? Request second appeal? Request retrial?
Thanks in advance
I am not a solicitor, but have been involved in a claim where the party amends their paperwork.
Is this not an option? I believe that you have to ask the court's permission to do so, and the other party has the right to object, however, if it's seen in the best interests of justice then it is usually allowed.
From my own experience in bringing a claim, a junk defence was filed, effectively admitting the claim, so I pushed for summary judgment. Then, two weeks before the hearing the Defendant gets a barrister to add 100% again on top of the Defence and fundamentally change some of the previous statements.
The Judge decided that this would be allowed, and my case had to go back to the drawing board!
In your situation if the matter fundamentally changes the case, and indeed simplifies it, I can't see why it would not be in the interests of justice to do so.
What the Judge may be alluding to is that if the issue is not part of your claim, you can't just add it in as the Defendant will not be able to formally defend the issue. However, that may be able to be done formally if agreed.
Again, that's just my non-professional experience, the procedure may be more complex in practice, but that would be the way I would investigate first.
Is this not an option? I believe that you have to ask the court's permission to do so, and the other party has the right to object, however, if it's seen in the best interests of justice then it is usually allowed.
From my own experience in bringing a claim, a junk defence was filed, effectively admitting the claim, so I pushed for summary judgment. Then, two weeks before the hearing the Defendant gets a barrister to add 100% again on top of the Defence and fundamentally change some of the previous statements.
The Judge decided that this would be allowed, and my case had to go back to the drawing board!
In your situation if the matter fundamentally changes the case, and indeed simplifies it, I can't see why it would not be in the interests of justice to do so.
What the Judge may be alluding to is that if the issue is not part of your claim, you can't just add it in as the Defendant will not be able to formally defend the issue. However, that may be able to be done formally if agreed.
Again, that's just my non-professional experience, the procedure may be more complex in practice, but that would be the way I would investigate first.
Edited by JustinP1 on Wednesday 12th March 15:54
Thanks Justin P1. That's very interesting.
Do you know if there is a procedure for this or would it be a simple letter to the Judge?
It would certainly save a lot of time and money for both parties if it could be dealt with without a retrial/second appeal.
If the respondent was allowed to benefit from what is, in this case, a criminal act then it would be against public policy.
Do you know if there is a procedure for this or would it be a simple letter to the Judge?
It would certainly save a lot of time and money for both parties if it could be dealt with without a retrial/second appeal.
If the respondent was allowed to benefit from what is, in this case, a criminal act then it would be against public policy.
You have to ask the court to let you amend your claim. At such a late stage you ewill only be allowed to amend if your amended claim does not prejudice the other party or the administration of justice. For instance if new evidence is required to deal with the point you want to raise you will probably not be allowed to amend. The other party has prepared and gone to trial on the case you chose to present and you have had your "portion" of court time. The idea is that parties have to bring all their case to court at once and are not, in the usual course of events, permitted multiple bites at the cherry, even if they have missed a good case out as a result of accident or oversight.
All you can do is ask. If you are allowed to amend it will be on terms that you have to pay all the costs associated with the amendment and any costs the other party incurs in having to change his case to meet your new point. You will also not recover the costs you expend on the amendment even if you win and get awarded your costs.
All you can do is ask. If you are allowed to amend it will be on terms that you have to pay all the costs associated with the amendment and any costs the other party incurs in having to change his case to meet your new point. You will also not recover the costs you expend on the amendment even if you win and get awarded your costs.
Qcarchoo said:
So, hypothetically, I have permission to amend my claim.
The defendant is now worried about a possible criminal conviction for tax evasion and losing a substantial amount of money so wants to negotiate a settlement.
Am I allowed to accept an out of court settlement?
Yes you may withdraw your claim at any time and notify the court you have done so. The defendant is now worried about a possible criminal conviction for tax evasion and losing a substantial amount of money so wants to negotiate a settlement.
Am I allowed to accept an out of court settlement?
Any agreement with the other side to withdraw your claim would also require an undertaking that they would make no application for costs (belts and braces really but still).
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


