Bluemotion fuel consumption, is it that much better?
Bluemotion fuel consumption, is it that much better?
Author
Discussion

islander

Original Poster:

371 posts

277 months

Wednesday 12th March 2014
quotequote all
Looking at getting a golf/a3/scirocco diesel as a work hack and was wondering if the stated fuel economy improvements of the Bluemotion system was worth stretching the budget for?

Recently has a volvo with start stop technology and the fuel consumption improvements we no where near what they should have been, if you looked at the stated figures!

Anybody any idea if the Bluemotion system can really increase fuel consumption by 10mpg as they seem to state for similar performance engines?

Is there any additional maintenance/ wear and tear issues I should be aware of as a result of Bluemotion, ie starter motor replacement?

cptsideways

13,902 posts

283 months

Wednesday 12th March 2014
quotequote all
If you want to save money just buy an early Polo Bluemotion, they are getting cheap & I cant see them dropping in value a lot more so depreciation will be next to nothing which would normally be your biggest cost. They are very good on fuel 60-70 on a run with ease.

SteBrown91

3,168 posts

160 months

Wednesday 12th March 2014
quotequote all
It stick to the scirocco/golf 140, its an engine that even thrashed will do mid 40s to the gallon. A colleague has a scirocco bmotion and the mpg is about the same as a normal 140 tdi

dbfan

183 posts

154 months

Thursday 13th March 2014
quotequote all
I have a Mk5 Golf Bluemotion and it actually uses more diesel than the Mk4 estate (100BHP engine) did - 51.89 compared to the Mk4's 53 or 54! There again, if I believed the display, it was doing 59.odd MPG!

It is still working out it's MPG on the new engine at the moment, it went up from 51.1 to 53.odd today - it was 17MPG when I collected it after having the engine fitted (and had done 17 miles since the engine had been fitted)!

If buying, avoid the 1.9 BLS engine - they seem to have problems (as I found out when I was looking for a used one in January!).

The big advantage of my BM is that it's £30 a year to tax: the Mk4 was £115 - £120 or so).

Stevemr

964 posts

187 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
18 months ago went from a 2.0 tdi 105 bhp passat to a blue motion 1.6 tdi passat. The new one is less economical without a shadow of doubt.

james_tigerwoods

16,347 posts

228 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
Stevemr said:
18 months ago went from a 2.0 tdi 105 bhp passat to a blue motion 1.6 tdi passat. The new one is less economical without a shadow of doubt.
Wasn't the 2.0tdi 105 just a stop gap to the 1.6 - They weren't sold for very long from what I recall and seemed to just pay lip service to the 100 odd bhp engine option.

I was never convinced that the 1.6 diesel was powerful enough to haul around a Passat...

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
They didn't make a 2.0 TDI 105, I guess he means either the CR 110 or the 1.9 PD 105

SteBrown91

3,168 posts

160 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
va1o said:
They didn't make a 2.0 TDI 105, I guess he means either the CR 110 or the 1.9 PD 105
They did do a 2.0 110 though, as above was a 100hp stop gap til the 1.6 arrived

mikiesb

89 posts

183 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
correct me if i am wrong if u do a lot miles and "boot" it about surely a bigger engine is better than a small engine as the bigger engine has to work less harder than the little engine to get you from 0-60 etc. etc.

Stevemr

964 posts

187 months

Tuesday 18th March 2014
quotequote all
Hi Yes sorry it was 110 bhp.

There seems little difference in performance between that and the 1.6.

But despite the 6 speed gear box and all the stop start stuff, it is not as economical.

Part of the problem I think is like all the passats I have had it takes a long time to warm up, and this hurts the fuel consumption in winter.

P-Jay

11,425 posts

222 months

Tuesday 18th March 2014
quotequote all
We had a Passat Bluemotion in work for a bit in my old place - a few people had a go and none of us thought it was going to change the world in terms of economy.

The general feeling was that it had the potential for great mpg, but it was bloody painful progress, if you drove it like any other diesel repmobile the savings were pretty slim, but if you wanted it to actually go at the same pace at it's standard diesel counterpart it was worse.

I've always assumed they were more for company car tax savings rather than fuel savings, which it backed up by the fact whenever I see them, they're being raped about.

Still not as bad at the i40s some of my friends have, the ECU is so overbearing on those you simply cannot thrash them, even if you drop a gear or two and floor it to pass a tractor or something it goes for a tiny moment, then the computer cuts the ignition (or however diesels work) it doesn't have a power range per-se, just a series of tiny blips of acceleration between the emissions test points.