European Law - enforceable in the UK ?
European Law - enforceable in the UK ?
Author
Discussion

red997

Original Poster:

1,304 posts

240 months

Thursday 13th March 2014
quotequote all
simplifying and cutting a long story short, what is the likelihood of a company enforcing Law from an EU company in England ?

I've had a bill from a hotel I stayed in (within the EU) with additional costs due to alleged room damage;

The bill itself is disproportionate to the amount of alleged damage, and I have contested it in writing.
The response from the hotel is that if I don't settle their un substantiated estimated bill in full they will start legal action against me to recover the costs !

I have also discovered today that the hotel in question has taken 75% of their 'additional bill for room damage' from my credit card, after I had left the country, obviously without my authorisation.

Where do I stand?

David



red997

Original Poster:

1,304 posts

240 months

Thursday 13th March 2014
quotequote all
The initial message was deleted from this topic on 14 March 2014 at 15:14

kiethton

14,668 posts

211 months

Thursday 13th March 2014
quotequote all
Firstly did you damage the room? You'd be surprised how much things cost, especially when you add the costs of fitting. (£150 part cost for a designer bog seat isn't unheard of). Assuming not or if they truly are disproportionate:

I'd start by initiating a claim back via the CC as an unauthorised transaction.

I'd then continue to discuss this issue with the hotel and refuse to do anything until the actual cost had been substantiated (and independently verified) to be a real pain in the backside.

red997

Original Poster:

1,304 posts

240 months

Thursday 13th March 2014
quotequote all
thanks for the response;
I managed to cut my finger (quite badly on a corkscrew) and used a towel to mop up the blood, before sticking an elastoplast on it !
this gets a mention in the damage list; but other than that no, there was no damage.
will get onto CC co now

question of the law worries me more though

Neonblau

875 posts

164 months

Thursday 13th March 2014
quotequote all
You might want to check your agreement with the hotel before speaking to your card issuer. It's likely the agreement will have a clause stating that the hotel may charge costs such as damage etc to your account in much that same way that a car rental company can.

If that is the case expect to see the amount being recharged as the bank that handles the hotels card transactions may simply fall back to that agreement which you will have signed/agreed to.

caziques

2,849 posts

199 months

Thursday 13th March 2014
quotequote all
First of all chargeback the unauthorized use of your credit card.

Then sit back and wait.

Unless the damage is in the thousands I doubt anyone is going to try and instigate court action, preparing and filing documents would probably be in the thousands.

Invariably those who make lots of noise do nothing, it's all about scare tactics.

I'm Rick james

250 posts

184 months

Thursday 13th March 2014
quotequote all
May I enquire curiously as to what the alleged damage is?
Rj

SV8Predator

2,102 posts

196 months

Thursday 13th March 2014
quotequote all
I'm Rick james said:
May I enquire curiously as to what the alleged damage is?
Rj
The OP doesn't say, but going by his username I imagine it's something along the lines of catching his dick in his zip and gushing blood all over the carpet?


anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 13th March 2014
quotequote all
red997 said:
simplifying and cutting a long story short, what is the likelihood of a company enforcing Law from an EU company in England ?

...
The question as formulated is unclear, and the topic appear to have nothing to do with any substantive element of EU law, but with the enforcement of an obligation incurred under the law of a EU State other than the UK. Such an obligation would in principle be enforceable. There are various rules about jurisdiction and judgments, which I need not go into here. As noted above, the real issue may be whether the claimant can be bothered to pursue the OP for the damages.

TooMany2cvs

29,008 posts

157 months

Thursday 13th March 2014
quotequote all
red997 said:
simplifying and cutting a long story short, what is the likelihood of a company enforcing Law from an EU company in England ?
I have also discovered today that the hotel in question has taken 75% of their 'additional bill for room damage' from my credit card, after I had left the country, obviously without my authorisation.
Apart from the subtle detail that nothing's being "enforced" in the UK, go and read the hotel's Ts & Cs. I'll bet you did agree to damage being charged to your card, albeit without realising.

Martin4x4

6,506 posts

163 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
red997 said:
I have also discovered today that the hotel in question has taken 75% of their 'additional bill for room damage' from my credit card, after I had left the country, obviously without my authorisation.
That is easy, call the credit card company and cancel with a charge back.

Martin4x4

6,506 posts

163 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
Neonblau said:
You might want to check your agreement with the hotel before speaking to your card issuer. It's likely the agreement will have a clause stating that the hotel may charge costs such as damage etc to your account in much that same way that a car rental company can.

If that is the case expect to see the amount being recharged as the bank that handles the hotels card transactions may simply fall back to that agreement which you will have signed/agreed to.
Wrong, contract law like the agreement doesn't override statute law like consumer credit act.

Neonblau

875 posts

164 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
Martin4x4 said:
Wrong, contract law like the agreement doesn't override statute law like consumer credit act.
I have no idea what you mean you mean by this.

red997

Original Poster:

1,304 posts

240 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
me neither..
probably makes a difference as it's a debit card anyway, not credit .. my mistake in the original post
I think I will contest the charge, as I have received no evidence of the alleged damage.
my concern is that I will rightly deny the damage, the hotel will try and apply the charges they have cited in their email and if they are unable to do so will then instigate legal action against me to recover their alleged costs.
but how would they do this ?

As I'm not in the country, I can hardly turn up and say show me the damage - which I would do if it was in the UK
if it makes a difference, I left the hotel monday lunchtime , and was not notified until wednesday afternoon about the alleged damage and the associated repair estimates- my card was debited on the thursday (shown as cleared)

randlemarcus

13,646 posts

262 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
Ask for photos of the damage (and check the date of taking etc). You might want to ask them for details of their public liability insurer so you can talk to them about providing unsafe corkscrews etc wink

red997

Original Poster:

1,304 posts

240 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
for some reason there is a double pot on this - will try and fix;

the alleged damage is:
damage to the bed head
broken legs on chairs
Damage to Bose surround system
blood soiled carpet
blood soiled bed linen
blood soiled towels
the repair estimate is 6000 Euro

There was some blood on the carpet, towels and bed linen - I would not dispute this, as I cut my finger open on a corkscrew (bloody painful it was / is too)
but the bed head, chairs and Bose - not a chance

and thanks for the character assassination regards my username... :0

mikeveal

5,141 posts

281 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
Debit cards do not come with the statutory cover provided by section 75 of the consumer credit act.

However most debit card suppliers offer a similar scheme and you should be able to get them to do the chargeback.

http://www.money.co.uk/article/1004510-is-debit-ca...

I think you will need to contact your debit card supplier and state that the charge is disputed as there was no damage to the room. Ask them for a chargeback. You will need to be persistent, not all of the front line staff seem to know that this is possible.

Neonblau

875 posts

164 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
mikeveal said:
Debit cards do not come with the statutory cover provided by section 75 of the consumer credit act.

However most debit card suppliers offer a similar scheme and you should be able to get them to do the chargeback.

http://www.money.co.uk/article/1004510-is-debit-ca...

I think you will need to contact your debit card supplier and state that the charge is disputed as there was no damage to the room. Ask them for a chargeback. You will need to be persistent, not all of the front line staff seem to know that this is possible.
Absolutely agree, but I think the OP really needs to address the validity of the charge first and use the card route depending on what he gets back. Sounds as though the hotel are pushing their luck hoping he won't contest it.

jesta1865

3,453 posts

240 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
Neonblau said:
mikeveal said:
Debit cards do not come with the statutory cover provided by section 75 of the consumer credit act.

However most debit card suppliers offer a similar scheme and you should be able to get them to do the chargeback.

http://www.money.co.uk/article/1004510-is-debit-ca...

I think you will need to contact your debit card supplier and state that the charge is disputed as there was no damage to the room. Ask them for a chargeback. You will need to be persistent, not all of the front line staff seem to know that this is possible.
Absolutely agree, but I think the OP really needs to address the validity of the charge first and use the card route depending on what he gets back. Sounds as though the hotel are pushing their luck hoping he won't contest it.
i don't agree, start the proceedings to get the money back and contact the hotel for proof of damage, then they can argue, but start the ball rolling with the debit card company as the longer you leave it the harder it will be to say you are contesting it, i would have thought

Neonblau

875 posts

164 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
jesta1865 said:
i don't agree, start the proceedings to get the money back and contact the hotel for proof of damage, then they can argue, but start the ball rolling with the debit card company as the longer you leave it the harder it will be to say you are contesting it, i would have thought
There is a 120 day time frame on chargeback rights. Starting the process sooner won't give the OP any advantage if the hotel are on a solid footing (which I admit is doubtful. If he can go to his card issuer with solid proof - or lack of it from the hotel - he'll be in a stronger position. Remember he has to convince his own card issuer to do the chargeback, if they charged back every time a customer asked they'd do nothing else.