Help!! - problem with customer, what to do?
Help!! - problem with customer, what to do?
Author
Discussion

archie456

Original Poster:

526 posts

253 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
I am posting this for a friend of mine.

My friend supplies flooring, typically stone, for kitchens, garden rooms etc. She supplies the flooring and sub-contracts a tiler to fit the floor, proving a turnkey solution. She only provides this service where the floor has been prepared to an adequate standard, i.e. clean, dry and level.

She supplied a stone floor for a customer, who needed preparation carrying out before it could be laid. She suggested that the customer could use the tiler who would be fitting the floor, but would need to contract directly with the tiler for the preparation.

The customer did this and contracted my friend for the supply and fit of the stone flooring only.

Subsequently there has been an issue, which has been identified as being down to the floor preparation, specifically that a product used has failed. She knows what the product is and has heard of other failures, it was purchased and supplied by the tiler as part of the floor prep.

The tiler has since emigrated, and the customer is now pursuing my friend for repairs as she recommended the now absent tiler.

The customer has said that he wants a full refund of the money he paid her for the stone and fitting, or he will take her to court for the (much) larger amount needed to remove the floor, kitchen, and fit new floor, and refit the kitchen.

Can anyone help please, she is understandably worried about this. Incidentally she got recommended for the job by an interior designer who was working for the customer.

Thanks in anticipation.

Alan





TheEnd

15,370 posts

219 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
He's chancing it, a recommendation doesn't make you liable for anything.

In fact, he's a bit of a scumbag for trying it on.

Jasandjules

72,686 posts

260 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
What to do? Depends on what she wants to do. She could do the following if she were so inclined:

Tell her she is mistaken in her belief that your friend is liable in any way. Advise her that in the event proceedings are issued she will apply to have the claim struck out before allocation as having no prospects of success and that she will then seek her full costs (which can be recovered as the claim had not been allocated to the small claims track).

She could agree to pay sums of money, but I don't see why she should....



SV8Predator

2,102 posts

196 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
archie456 said:
and contracted my friend for the supply and fit of the stone flooring only.
This will get very messy. Your friend will be better settling out of court before the legal fees mount up.


archie456

Original Poster:

526 posts

253 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for the input.

Just to clarify my friend, the floor supplier, is 'she' and the customer is 'he'. I know it's usually the other way round.

My friend had spoken to a tile supplier who said that they were taken to court, successfully, for recommending a tiler who had since disappeared.

Naturally this worried her, so I thought I'd seek some help here.

archie456

Original Poster:

526 posts

253 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
SV8Predator said:
This will get very messy. Your friend will be better settling out of court before the legal fees mount up.
This was supply and fit to a prepped floor, the prep was contracted by the customer directly with the tiler. It is the prep that has failed.

paulrussell

2,311 posts

192 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
SV8Predator said:
archie456 said:
and contracted my friend for the supply and fit of the stone flooring only.
This will get very messy. Your friend will be better settling out of court before the legal fees mount up.
Why though? The OP's friend had nothing to do with the preparation of the floor. I don't see how she could be made liable only because she recommended the person who did the floor preparation.

Grandad Gaz

5,284 posts

277 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
The issue here is the customer needs to sort it out with the tiler who was working directly for him, not your friend.
The fact he has emigrated is his problem, not hers.

It makes no difference, if your friend recommended him or not.

Edit: what exactly has failed? Surely, the floor would only need self levelling compound of some sort?

Edited by Grandad Gaz on Friday 14th March 19:03

voyds9

8,490 posts

314 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
archie456 said:
This was supply and fit to a prepped floor, the prep was contracted by the customer directly with the tiler. It is the prep that has failed.
As an expert should she not have been aware that the prep was not to standard?

archie456

Original Poster:

526 posts

253 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
voyds9 said:
archie456 said:
This was supply and fit to a prepped floor, the prep was contracted by the customer directly with the tiler. It is the prep that has failed.
As an expert should she not have been aware that the prep was not to standard?
The preparation was to level the floor and fit a decoupling membrane, which is stuck to the floor, so there would have been no visible clues. The membrane has subsequently become detached from the floor below, but the stone is still firmly attached to the membrane.

SV8Predator

2,102 posts

196 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
voyds9 said:
As an expert should she not have been aware that the prep was not to standard?
Yes, this is where it all gets messy. The 'customer' has an invoice that shows he's paid for a service.

It's up to the OP's 'friend' now to prove that the 'tiler' (who was apparently very capable, as she recommended him!), was in fact, not so capable. But capable enough to lay and fit the floor. but not capable enough to 'prepare' the substrate.

Messy? A can of worms looks simple compared to this!

The solicitors will initially advise your 'friend' that she has a strong case. Then, many months down the line, and many thousands of pounds spent on solicitor's fees, they will shake their heads and suck through their teeth and advise that it could go either way and that said 'friend' would be better settling out of court.

So, as I advised earlier, do that now.

archie456

Original Poster:

526 posts

253 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
SV8Predator said:
voyds9 said:
As an expert should she not have been aware that the prep was not to standard?
Yes, this is where it all gets messy. The 'customer' has an invoice that shows he's paid for a service.

It's up to the OP's 'friend' now to prove that the 'tiler' (who was apparently very capable, as she recommended him!), was in fact, not so capable. But capable enough to lay and fit the floor. but not capable enough to 'prepare' the substrate.

Messy? A can of worms looks simple compared to this!

The solicitors will initially advise your 'friend' that she has a strong case. Then, many months down the line, and many thousands of pounds spent on solicitor's fees, they will shake their heads and suck through their teeth and advise that it could go either way and that said 'friend' would be better settling out of court.

So, as I advised earlier, do that now.
It seems to be wormier than that. It appears that the decoupling membrane has failed, and there would appear to be other cases of this happening where the manufacturer has paid for amends . Since the tiler bought this it would seem to be hard to pin anything on the manufacturer.

It's not me by the way, I do IT stuff for a living, but that has its own set of worms.

Wacky Racer

41,412 posts

278 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
Whilst I sympathise for your friend, (for which this must be a nightmare), you also have to see it from the "customers" point of view. He has paid a lot of money for a nice stone floor which presumably is breaking up, due to problems with bonding underneath.

Difficult one. Why can't life ever run smoothly?

Simpo Two

93,085 posts

296 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
archie456 said:
The customer has said that he wants a full refund of the money he paid her for the stone and fitting, or he will take her to court for the (much) larger amount needed to remove the floor, kitchen, and fit new floor, and refit the kitchen.
She supplied the stone. She didn't fit it. If the stone itself is of merchantable quality then she has done her part OK. The fitter was commissioned by the customer, and that is where the contract lies.

Hence she should write a nice apologetic letter explaining the situation, tell him that the contract is with the fitter, and draw the line there. As I see it she is under no legal obligation to do anything so there is no case. He's looking for a scapegoat and trying it on.

SV8Predator

2,102 posts

196 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
She supplied the stone. She didn't fit it.
archie456 said:
and contracted my friend for the supply and fit of the stone flooring only.
You! At the back!

Stay awake that man!


SV8Predator

2,102 posts

196 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
Please, please, tell us that your 'friend' has adequate business insurance in place to cover such claims and allegations?

Mojooo

13,291 posts

211 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
As long as she can show it was down to the floor prep and the tiler had a seperate contract then she has no liability.

Her problem will be if there is just one invoice covering it all - which there should not be given your original account.

I have sympathy with the consumer - after all he dealt with 2 people and probably feels shafted.

crossy67

1,570 posts

210 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
The question for me would be what would the cost of rectifying the job? Sometimes it's best to loose an argument for the sake of reputation.

archie456

Original Poster:

526 posts

253 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
Mojooo said:
As long as she can show it was down to the floor prep and the tiler had a seperate contract then she has no liability.

Her problem will be if there is just one invoice covering it all - which there should not be given your original account.

I have sympathy with the consumer - after all he dealt with 2 people and probably feels shafted.
There was one invoice covering supply and fit, and she was copied on an email detailing and pricing the floor prep.

The challenge I'm sure will be proving it is the prep, nothing seems black and white. It also sounds like the customer blasted his under-floor heating a bit prematurely, but that seems to be anecdotal.

archie456

Original Poster:

526 posts

253 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
crossy67 said:
The question for me would be what would the cost of rectifying the job? Sometimes it's best to loose an argument for the sake of reputation.
Customer is asking her for a full refund or go to court, it doesn't seem to be related to making good currently.