LP640 or 458 or therapy
LP640 or 458 or therapy
Author
Discussion

Sarnie

8,379 posts

240 months

Friday 14th March 2014
quotequote all
Do.Not.Do.It.

erics

2,721 posts

242 months

Saturday 15th March 2014
quotequote all
Fast manual?
Aston v12v.

458 not bad. See it as a big go kart.

S1M VP

949 posts

265 months

Saturday 15th March 2014
quotequote all
I'm in a similar boat in terms of being drawn towards the 458, especially now the Speciale is out ..... But it's that DREADED ITCH to change coming back.

But, like you, I absolutely love my car and the sheer "in your face brashness" off it ... which the Ferrari simply doesn't quite have ... Although I personally think the interior designs of Ferrari are much better/nicer than Lambo (other than the red flap) and the exterior,is more flowing and graceful than the sharper angular limes of a Lambo.

It's a tough call ... And depends what you want ...
The 458 will feel newer and fresher, but it will also feel more clinical and precise, slicing its way down the roads, whereas the LP640 more of a big hammer smashing along.

Conclusion .... I can't bear to part with mine just yet, despite the £3500 service due next week (before any recommendations, ouch!) .... so I've started looking for a new house with a bigger garage or enough space to build one ha ha!

Standing back from it all .... It's a nice dilemma to have .... "shall I change my Lambo, for a Ferrari"

ted 191

1,470 posts

256 months

Saturday 15th March 2014
quotequote all
Jumped out of my 458 into a mates LP roadster a few weeks ago, for a quick blast.......as good as the lambo looks, it's a complete dinosaur to drive compared to a 458 and noticeably slower.

Davey S2

13,394 posts

285 months

Sunday 16th March 2014
quotequote all
ted 191 said:
Jumped out of my 458 into a mates LP roadster a few weeks ago, for a quick blast.......as good as the lambo looks, it's a complete dinosaur to drive compared to a 458 and noticeably slower.
So is an F50 but I know which one I would rather own long term.

The Lambo will be / is a lot more collectible than a 458. I think manual V12 Supercars are the ones to buy and keep hold of long term because we won't ever see them again.

ted 191

1,470 posts

256 months

Sunday 16th March 2014
quotequote all
Davey S2 said:
So is an F50 but I know which one I would rather own long term.

The Lambo will be / is a lot more collectible than a 458. I think manual V12 Supercars are the ones to buy and keep hold of long term because we won't ever see them again.
I'm not interested in a car sat in the garage hoping it will appreciate ......I want to drive it.

andysv

1,363 posts

258 months

Sunday 16th March 2014
quotequote all
I can only use my 670 as a comparison however I drove a 458 last year and was amazed by the pace and usability but did not look back when I returned to the Lambo, the two don't really compare tbh one is bit of a dinosaur but what a magnificent example of old tech, you already summed it up with the Porky, perfection in all areas doesn't always tick the most important boxes.

S1M VP

949 posts

265 months

Sunday 16th March 2014
quotequote all
They are far too different to directly compare the two .... And 10 years gap between the base technology in the two cars.

Not particularly relevant but ...... I watched a programme the other night about billionaires .... One had a 458 spider as a daily, the other had a stunning Jaguar e-Type .... That's the great thing about being a petrol head ... If you fancy a change, your only restraint on what type f car you drive is your own self.

andysv

1,363 posts

258 months

Sunday 16th March 2014
quotequote all
I agree with that, I love anything with wheels and character, I am currently pondering over a Smart for two Brabus, I had a left hook early car years ago and had a fantastic time driving it to the Le Mans 24hr now I fancy another go with a quicker one!

woppum

1,137 posts

217 months

Sunday 16th March 2014
quotequote all
Interesting comparison. The lambo never even came on to my radar when choosing. Looks very special and rare, even in London, however they are very dated inside and are a bit of a lump. Can't imagine it will be much of a pleasure using one every day.

F355spider

1,395 posts

262 months

Monday 17th March 2014
quotequote all
458s are absolutely brilliant, best car i have had by a million miles. They do everything brilliantly.

I like them better in lighter colours, suits the lines so well.



Edited by F355spider on Monday 17th March 16:14

sone

4,612 posts

269 months

Monday 17th March 2014
quotequote all


I recently considered moving on my 458 but then I thought what with, I honestly don't think there's anything that much better mechanically and certainly not better looking in my opinion anyway
I would add that anyone test driving a 458 shouldn't be put off by the very fast steering rack and sensitive throttle it takes a few miles to get used to but once you do its fantastic.

jdwcd

2,519 posts

233 months

Tuesday 18th March 2014
quotequote all
Johnny

You never drive your cars..;)

countachman

1,290 posts

242 months

Tuesday 18th March 2014
quotequote all
Pictures of your lambo needed for us to help you.

KFC

3,687 posts

161 months

Tuesday 18th March 2014
quotequote all
jonny finance said:


Nowt wrong with this 'lounge' and look and that wonderful stick thing!!

Edited by jonny finance on Tuesday 18th March 19:18
I don't think they're aging gracefully at all!

edit link fixed, cant embed pic - http://mycarimages.com/lamborghini-aventador-inter...

Chilli

17,320 posts

267 months

Wednesday 19th March 2014
quotequote all
I visit this forum every now and then to dream...

Johnny...Isn't there any possible way AT ALL of owning both?! Seriously the 458 is a dream car for me, but if I had your lambo, I couldn't part with it.
Is that a BMW in the garage? Couldn't that be sold to help??!!

JasonSF

248 posts

240 months

Wednesday 19th March 2014
quotequote all
Leave the 458, wait a few month's and get a Huracan! Also depends on how often you want to use your car. I chose Gallardo over 458 as daily driver.

andysv

1,363 posts

258 months

Wednesday 19th March 2014
quotequote all
jonny finance said:


Yes I do _ look it goes out in its cage quite often!!
Off topic but that fits lovely compared to mine.

This was how we took it to the Evo shoot in Wales.



andysv

1,363 posts

258 months

Wednesday 19th March 2014
quotequote all
We loaded it in the dark to head there, in hindsight I have no idea how we did it, worst thing was you couldn't strap it in well as you couldn't get around the car in the trailer, I was so happy to get it out the other end unmarked, just as well my pal that came with me owns a bodyshop luckily his services were not required!

Do you own the Brian James? We hired ours from the guys at Silverstone and it was their widest unit.

andysv

1,363 posts

258 months

Wednesday 19th March 2014
quotequote all
We loaded it in the dark to head there, in hindsight I have no idea how we did it, worst thing was you couldn't strap it in well as you couldn't get around the car in the trailer, I was so happy to get it out the other end unmarked, just as well my pal that came with me owns a bodyshop luckily his services were not required!

Do you own the Brian James? We hired ours from the guys at Silverstone and it was their widest unit.

Edited by andysv on Wednesday 19th March 20:48