Police accuse driver of using mob phone at the wheel, BUT...
Police accuse driver of using mob phone at the wheel, BUT...
Author
Discussion

750turbo

Original Poster:

6,164 posts

255 months

Saturday 15th March 2014
quotequote all
"Police accused driver of using mobile phone at the wheel.. but he has a FALSE ARM which cannot grip"

Spotted in the "Scottish" Daily Mail...

How stupid can things get?

http://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/news/scottish-news/po...

A DAD with a false arm was hauled into court five times after police said he used his phone with his plastic hand while driving.

Russell Cameron and his lawyer argued time and again that his right hand didn’t move or grip and couldn’t be used to work a phone.

But the case wore on for a year and got all the way to trial before a JP finally threw it out.

And fed-up Russell, 31, told the Record: “It’s a disgrace it went on so long – it’s a farce.

“I’m quite disturbed that the two officers shared the same apparition that landed me in court. It stinks.”

He believes he was a victim of Police Scotland performance targets for handing out fixed penalties. The force deny they have any such targets.

Police pulled Russell over in Greenock on March 5 last year and said they saw him using his right thumb to operate a satnav on his phone.

They handed him a £60 fixed penalty, which would have meant three penalty points.

Dad-of-five Russell, who was born without a right forearm, decided it was best to say nothing at the time.

He said: “If they were accusing me when I was totally innocent, I wanted to know exactly what they thought they saw.

“I didn’t want to give them a chance to see it was impossible to use my right hand, then change the story to suit the charge and say it was my left.

“I had to hire a lawyer, who said it would never get to trial, given the stupidity of it.”

But the case continued through a series of pre-trial hearings, despite Russell producing a certificate from his GP about his false arm.

Two days before the March 6 trial date, Russell’s lawyer called prosecutors to ask if they still wanted to go ahead, and was amazed to be told they did.

Russell said: “They told my lawyer the policemen’s statements were so strong that the case had to be heard. He was in a state of disbelief.”

The trial duly went ahead at Greenock Justice of the Peace Court, where PC Colin Taylor insisted he saw Russell use his right arm to work the phone.

Russell’s lawyer, Ronnie Simpson, then asked his client to roll up his sleeve and show his plastic limb.

“You should have seen the policeman’s face,” Russell said.

“He tried to stick to his guns but I’d like to see him use his phone with my artificial hand. I doubt he’d have much joy.”

Russell said the second officer, PC Lewis Golbourn, then said he wasn’t sure if he had used his left or right hand – despite the allegation being specific.

Simpson called for the case to be thrown out. And after talking to the court’s legal assessor, JP Breda Rankin ruled there was no case to answer.

Onlookers in court cheered, but Russell was in no mood to celebrate. He said: “I’ve been docked £400 wages because of this and it’s cost me £400 in legal fees, which is a big deal when you have five kids.

“I don’t know if the police are under too much pressure with targets for catching people doing this sort of thing, or whether their eyesight needs testing.

“I hate to think there are lots of people who may be getting stitched up because they can’t fall back on such a strong defence. If the police stick to their story you’re in a tough spot.”

Russell, who works for phone firm EE, was also accused of using a mobile while driving 11 years ago. But prosecutors dropped the case after a medical certificate suggested it was impossible.

Simpson, of Phillip Rooney Solicitors, said: “Drivers with a limited understanding of the law often choose to pay fixed penalty notices and end up with a criminal record for matters in which they had no business being stopped in the first place.”


EskimoArapaho

5,135 posts

166 months

Saturday 15th March 2014
quotequote all
750turbo said:
Dad-of-five Russell, who was born without a right forearm, decided it was best to say nothing at the time.

He said: “If they were accusing me when I was totally innocent, I wanted to know exactly what they thought they saw.

“I didn’t want to give them a chance to see it was impossible to use my right hand, then change the story to suit the charge and say it was my left.
Smart guy.

Mike_Mac

664 posts

231 months

Saturday 15th March 2014
quotequote all
EskimoArapaho said:
Smart guy.
Just as well too - seeing as that's exactly what the Policeman then did!

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Saturday 15th March 2014
quotequote all
They work very hard under difficult circumstances, you know.

And Cameron did nasty things to them.

daveinaravecave

1,149 posts

166 months

Saturday 15th March 2014
quotequote all
Why aren't those two pricks charged with perjury?

Mk3Spitfire

2,921 posts

159 months

Saturday 15th March 2014
quotequote all
Rovinghawk said:
They work very hard under difficult circumstances, you know.

And Cameron did nasty things to them.
As useful a contribution as one would expect from yourself. On form.

g3org3y

22,523 posts

222 months

Saturday 15th March 2014
quotequote all
750turbo said:
Russell’s lawyer, Ronnie Simpson, then asked his client to roll up his sleeve and show his plastic limb.

“You should have seen the policeman’s face,” Russell said.
Beautiful. biggrin

carinaman

25,297 posts

203 months

Saturday 15th March 2014
quotequote all
daveinaravecave said:
Why aren't those two pricks charged with perjury?
Because we've spent a lot of money training them and we can't afford to lose their skills and experience.

dacouch

1,172 posts

160 months

Saturday 15th March 2014
quotequote all
Dare I say it, but is this not an example of the long arm of the law?

Hooli

32,278 posts

231 months

Saturday 15th March 2014
quotequote all
carinaman said:
daveinaravecave said:
Why aren't those two pricks charged with perjury?
Because we've spent a lot of money training them and we can't afford to lose their skills and experience.
I think skill & experience at fabricating evidence is something we really can afford to lose.

Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Saturday 15th March 2014
quotequote all
Mk3Spitfire said:
Rovinghawk said:
They work very hard under difficult circumstances, you know.
And Cameron did nasty things to them.
As useful a contribution as one would expect from yourself. On form.
I was doing it on behalf of the usual apologists, saving them some time.

But why have a go at me instead of the lying deceitful b4st4rds who were rather obviously trying to have someone convicted for something he quite clearly didn't do? Wouldn't your anger be better directed at them?

NPI

1,310 posts

155 months

Saturday 15th March 2014
quotequote all
Russell Cameron said:
I didn’t want to give them a chance to see it was impossible to use my right hand, then change the story to suit the charge and say it was my left.
I know he's already been quoted above but police chiefs everywhere should be hanging their heads in shame that this is what the general public have come to expect of the Police.

carinaman

25,297 posts

203 months

Saturday 15th March 2014
quotequote all
750turbo said:
He believes he was a victim of Police Scotland performance targets for handing out fixed penalties. The force deny they have any such targets.
The first caller on Any Answers on Radio 4, last Saturday so it's probably just been replaced on iplayer for the one broadcast today, said he'd been a police officer for 28 years. He said that the new Scottish police were being 'Metropolitanised' with a tick box and target culture and that it was alienating police officers and the public.

eldar

25,351 posts

227 months

Saturday 15th March 2014
quotequote all
Hooli said:
I think skill & experience at fabricating evidence is something we really can afford to lose.
And apparently cost the victim of this erroneous evidence £800. The CPS and the police should be ashamed of themselves for this low-level and common corruption. Sadly, they will blame the victim. Does nothing but harm to the majority of honest and dedicated police.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 15th March 2014
quotequote all
dacouch said:
Dare I say it, but is this not an example of the long arm of the law?
The wrong arm of the law, surely?

It occurs to me that, if this guy has been stopped and wrongly accused twice, how many others have been so accused but been unable to prove their defence?


Rovinghawk

13,300 posts

189 months

Saturday 15th March 2014
quotequote all
Will all previous convictions from this pair's evidence now be open to appeal?

Will those who accepted FPNs, knowing how likely they were to lose in court, also have the right to appeal?

Will there be any sanction against them for perjury & bringing the police into disrepute?

Will the police be stupid enough to try reprisals against him for proving their corruption?

Edited by Rovinghawk on Saturday 15th March 22:00

carinaman

25,297 posts

203 months

Saturday 15th March 2014
quotequote all
eldar said:
And apparently cost the victim of this erroneous evidence £800. The CPS and the police should be ashamed of themselves for this low-level and common corruption. Sadly, they will blame the victim. Does nothing but harm to the majority of honest and dedicated police.
Simpson of Phillip Rooney Solicitors said:
Drivers with a limited under-standing of the law often choose to pay fixed penalty notices and end up with a criminal record for matters in which they had no business being stopped in the first place.
So the moral of this sorry tale is to smile sweetly as you're shafted, don't argue with the nice police officers and take the conviction, fine and points or risk yourself being £800 out of pocket.

Edited by carinaman on Saturday 15th March 22:00

Mr GrimNasty

8,172 posts

201 months

Saturday 15th March 2014
quotequote all
Well who knows the truth? I have a friend with a false arm, no robotics or articulation, just cosmetic, and he certainly is able to use it to operate and 'hold' a phone. It's amazing how people adapt.

eldar

25,351 posts

227 months

Saturday 15th March 2014
quotequote all
Mr GrimNasty said:
Well who knows the truth? I have a friend with a false arm, no robotics or articulation, just cosmetic, and he certainly is able to use it to operate and 'hold' a phone. It's amazing how people adapt.
And how does the unarticulated non-robotic hand operate a phone with a dumb thumb? Hold for sure, but that wasn't the allegation here.

dacouch

1,172 posts

160 months

Saturday 15th March 2014
quotequote all
Mr GrimNasty said:
Well who knows the truth? I have a friend with a false arm, no robotics or articulation, just cosmetic, and he certainly is able to use it to operate and 'hold' a phone. It's amazing how people adapt.
A false arm would not be able to operate a touch screen