Insurance told me a claim has been made against me??
Discussion
Hi,
Got a telephone call from my insurance company telling me someone has put in a third party claim against me.
Judging by the details they have given me, the car is different, my name is different and I was no where near the area where the accident is alleged to have occurred.
What concerns me is this 'alleged' claim is against my name and on file irrespective of the fact it is false and nothing to do with me.
Can anyone shed light on the impact of this on future insurance prospects.
Thanks
Got a telephone call from my insurance company telling me someone has put in a third party claim against me.
Judging by the details they have given me, the car is different, my name is different and I was no where near the area where the accident is alleged to have occurred.
What concerns me is this 'alleged' claim is against my name and on file irrespective of the fact it is false and nothing to do with me.
Can anyone shed light on the impact of this on future insurance prospects.
Thanks
My sister received a letter claiming an alleged incident a couple of years ago, when she was nowhere near the area (in fact a different town) where it supposedly took place.
Nothing came of it but it did put her premium up last year because it was "on file." Thankfully they refunded the money this time and have cleared it from the system.
Nothing came of it but it did put her premium up last year because it was "on file." Thankfully they refunded the money this time and have cleared it from the system.
Martin4x4 said:
I don't see how can the claim be against you, if the they don't have your name?
Are you sure this was your insurance company and not some phone scam?
I would phone your insurance company back to confirm and get them to put it in writing.
All they need is your car reg number, their insurance will do the rest.Are you sure this was your insurance company and not some phone scam?
I would phone your insurance company back to confirm and get them to put it in writing.
OP, please do as advised and ring your company yourself, just to make sure it isn't a telephone scam to start with.
After that, if the claim is genuine, consult LoonR1, he's an insurance chap.
My initial reaction was 'this is a scam' but checked the phone number and it did come back to my insurers so I gave them a call and they confirmed the situation.
It does sound like someone has written a registration number down incorrectly as the location of the 'alleged' accident is over 150 miles away from my home so when I am proved not to be involved the 'alleged' claim will still be on file.
My concern is that will be still be on file and some muppet will use it to bump the premium up when it is not justified so not really sure of the best way to defend myself.
It does sound like someone has written a registration number down incorrectly as the location of the 'alleged' accident is over 150 miles away from my home so when I am proved not to be involved the 'alleged' claim will still be on file.
My concern is that will be still be on file and some muppet will use it to bump the premium up when it is not justified so not really sure of the best way to defend myself.
gottans said:
My initial reaction was 'this is a scam' but checked the phone number and it did come back to my insurers so I gave them a call and they confirmed the situation.
It does sound like someone has written a registration number down incorrectly as the location of the 'alleged' accident is over 150 miles away from my home so when I am proved not to be involved the 'alleged' claim will still be on file.
My concern is that will be still be on file and some muppet will use it to bump the premium up when it is not justified so not really sure of the best way to defend myself.
That is a worry I agree, but it will be dealt with in due course.It does sound like someone has written a registration number down incorrectly as the location of the 'alleged' accident is over 150 miles away from my home so when I am proved not to be involved the 'alleged' claim will still be on file.
My concern is that will be still be on file and some muppet will use it to bump the premium up when it is not justified so not really sure of the best way to defend myself.
I have experience of this happening twice, once to a neighbour which did turn out to be a wrongly noted number, and once to myself which was a malicious claim, both cases were sorted by the Police, mine taking longer, and I lost my no claims at renewal time, although the money was completely refunded later.
Try not to worry, easier said than done I know, it will be sorted out.
If you weren't there and didn't do it, insurance companies aren't idiots, and don't just roll over and pay claims as is often suggested.
It will be very easy for you to prove you weren't in an area at a given time.
To be honest, it's happening more and more often these days.
Ever since the amount solicitors could recover for claims dropped, they are doing the bare minimum work on a case. Some muppet gives them a reg,and it may not even be the muppet who is making the allegations, but their referral source, and they stick the reg into MID, and launch off on a half cocked claim to the the insurers identified, causing everyone else plenty of aggravation and bother in sorting out their sheer laziness. No fact checking, no call to the claimant to confirm make model or reg or even name of the defendant. Most of the time I get claims for injury, and when I call the solicitors within 24 hours of receiving the claim, half the time they can't tell me anything as they stuck the claim in without any background work covering the basics.
Basically, BI claims are just a commodity to be "shifted on" as quickly and cheaply as possible.
Ever since the amount solicitors could recover for claims dropped, they are doing the bare minimum work on a case. Some muppet gives them a reg,and it may not even be the muppet who is making the allegations, but their referral source, and they stick the reg into MID, and launch off on a half cocked claim to the the insurers identified, causing everyone else plenty of aggravation and bother in sorting out their sheer laziness. No fact checking, no call to the claimant to confirm make model or reg or even name of the defendant. Most of the time I get claims for injury, and when I call the solicitors within 24 hours of receiving the claim, half the time they can't tell me anything as they stuck the claim in without any background work covering the basics.
Basically, BI claims are just a commodity to be "shifted on" as quickly and cheaply as possible.
We had one of these 2 years ago.
A woman claimed that my wife had forced her off a road leading to our village (narrow, twisty, with lots of blind corners). My wife wasn't there at the time - we could be precise as it was around school dropping off time for my wife and she works to a very precise timetable giving other kids a lift before going on to work. We mentioned this to the other party's insurance co, who inferred the police were involved, and they asked her to 'think again'.
My wife was suspicious because the insurance company couldn't offer any precise facts and called the local police (who are typically very helpful). They confirmed there was no report of an accident at the time/place/involving the other party's car. However, discussing this, the helpful lady PC did raise her interest, as apparently it's not an uncommon 'scam' for someone to damage their own car and try and recover the cost of repairs from someone else after being 'forced off the road'. She asked my wife where her car is parked when at home - it's parked out front of the house and visible from the main road though the village, at a point where cars wait to let oncoming cars pass. Again, this is typically a feature of such claims. She gave us advice, which we followed.
We called the third party insurance and relayed the facts & output from our conversation with the police. The claim was dropped very shortly afterwards. The PC had spoken about instigating some sort of fraudulent claim investigation, but I've no idea whether that happened or not.
Incidentally, I did a bit of internet snooping and found the third party on Facebook - not how I expected, quite well off, with horses, big 4x4, etc, liked to live her life on FB - but strangely no mention of the 'accident' around the time it was supposed to have happened. Scum comes in all shapes and sizes.
ETA correct spelling
A woman claimed that my wife had forced her off a road leading to our village (narrow, twisty, with lots of blind corners). My wife wasn't there at the time - we could be precise as it was around school dropping off time for my wife and she works to a very precise timetable giving other kids a lift before going on to work. We mentioned this to the other party's insurance co, who inferred the police were involved, and they asked her to 'think again'.
My wife was suspicious because the insurance company couldn't offer any precise facts and called the local police (who are typically very helpful). They confirmed there was no report of an accident at the time/place/involving the other party's car. However, discussing this, the helpful lady PC did raise her interest, as apparently it's not an uncommon 'scam' for someone to damage their own car and try and recover the cost of repairs from someone else after being 'forced off the road'. She asked my wife where her car is parked when at home - it's parked out front of the house and visible from the main road though the village, at a point where cars wait to let oncoming cars pass. Again, this is typically a feature of such claims. She gave us advice, which we followed.
We called the third party insurance and relayed the facts & output from our conversation with the police. The claim was dropped very shortly afterwards. The PC had spoken about instigating some sort of fraudulent claim investigation, but I've no idea whether that happened or not.
Incidentally, I did a bit of internet snooping and found the third party on Facebook - not how I expected, quite well off, with horses, big 4x4, etc, liked to live her life on FB - but strangely no mention of the 'accident' around the time it was supposed to have happened. Scum comes in all shapes and sizes.
ETA correct spelling

Edited by anonymous-user on Tuesday 18th March 08:35
Cloned registration mark, where the person using the cloned plates can't even be bothered putting them on an outwardly identical-looking vehicle to the OP's???
That's a police matter - just wait until the speeding tickets start coming through the post...
Surprised no-one's been cynical to mention this yet
.
That's a police matter - just wait until the speeding tickets start coming through the post...Surprised no-one's been cynical to mention this yet
.different car, different name
how is it a claim against you?
It's not your car that was being driven, so can't be a claim against the car named on your insurance policy
It's not you named as the driver, so it can't be a claim for you using drive any car cover driving another vehicle.
Tell your insurer to check thier facts first and stop wasting your time with calls about other people's claims
how is it a claim against you?
It's not your car that was being driven, so can't be a claim against the car named on your insurance policy
It's not you named as the driver, so it can't be a claim for you using drive any car cover driving another vehicle.
Tell your insurer to check thier facts first and stop wasting your time with calls about other people's claims
My insurers have the claim down against me. I know I wasn't involved in this but even if proven not involved, this is still kept on my file. We all know how accurate or inaccurate databases are so just having this un proven claim is a concern and effectively a slur on my good insurance record which I do not like.
gottans said:
My insurers have the claim down against me. I know I wasn't involved in this but even if proven not involved, this is still kept on my file. We all know how accurate or inaccurate databases are so just having this un proven claim is a concern and effectively a slur on my good insurance record which I do not like.
Ask them to remove it.If they don't, change insurers next time. You haven't been involved in an accident and no one has claimed on your insurance so other than being an entry on your exisiting insurers computer it will not be relevant to you taking out a policy with a different provider.
Devil2575 said:
gottans said:
My insurers have the claim down against me. I know I wasn't involved in this but even if proven not involved, this is still kept on my file. We all know how accurate or inaccurate databases are so just having this un proven claim is a concern and effectively a slur on my good insurance record which I do not like.
Ask them to remove it.If they don't, change insurers next time. You haven't been involved in an accident and no one has claimed on your insurance so other than being an entry on your exisiting insurers computer it will not be relevant to you taking out a policy with a different provider.
I had something like this a few years back, a phone call out of the blue from my insurers saying someone had made a claim but was very sketchy about details. I knew it wasn't me and told them so but asked for more details from them. Anyway, nothing came back so but I was adamant with my insurers that it wasn't going to affect my premium for the following year.
Fast forward to my renewal and I phone around, it became apparent that my insurers hadn't updated the database correctly and was still showing as a claim against me. Another phone call to them got it sorted out and my new insurers accepted the fact and I've never had a problem since.
Fast forward to my renewal and I phone around, it became apparent that my insurers hadn't updated the database correctly and was still showing as a claim against me. Another phone call to them got it sorted out and my new insurers accepted the fact and I've never had a problem since.
ZOLLAR said:
Devil2575 said:
gottans said:
My insurers have the claim down against me. I know I wasn't involved in this but even if proven not involved, this is still kept on my file. We all know how accurate or inaccurate databases are so just having this un proven claim is a concern and effectively a slur on my good insurance record which I do not like.
Ask them to remove it.If they don't, change insurers next time. You haven't been involved in an accident and no one has claimed on your insurance so other than being an entry on your exisiting insurers computer it will not be relevant to you taking out a policy with a different provider.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




