VXR8 6.0 - 4 INTO 1 HEADERS - OTHER MODS
Discussion
As some of you may be aware I've removed my engine for some minor surgery!
Looking at spending some money on a few other bits in the process and would appreciate your thoughts on a few things...
I have a big box sat in Australia at present that I'm slowly filling up with bits before it all gets sent over here.
What do people think to these? They seem pretty good for the money!
http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/VE-VF-Holden-HSV-Commod...
Looking at spending some money on a few other bits in the process and would appreciate your thoughts on a few things...
I have a big box sat in Australia at present that I'm slowly filling up with bits before it all gets sent over here.
What do people think to these? They seem pretty good for the money!
http://www.ebay.com.au/itm/VE-VF-Holden-HSV-Commod...
ringram said:
1-7/8 Pacemakers IMO
another option for 1-7/8http://www.vpw.com.au/Category/Index/431529
following in the footsteps of Behold81 (Antony Pugh)I've just ordered the Monaro equivalents with loom extensions and plug lead boots for $640 + shipping(fedex $350) which is a bit of a saving over the online price so worth sending an email to Joe / Aaron
ringram said:
1-7/8 Pacemakers IMO
Is this good, on all but the highest output engines? I know you say that no restriction is best, but I've been reading about exhaust gases stalling at slow speed and slowing the next exhaust pulse when they meet. Is there anything in this?Edited by ARAF on Thursday 20th March 19:36
captainblakk said:
Certainly look ok. Roger did recommend not to get stainless headers to me tho, can make quite a resonance apparently, Defillippo get my vote. Not cheap mind
Defillipo are now manufactured for them by Pacemaker so I'm told, so you might as well get the real thing and not pay DF for the name tag.If you get stainless ceramic coated they're OK.
ETA: Cant understand why Roger would advise against stainless as AFAIK, Wortec are stainless.
Edited by MyM8V8 on Friday 21st March 09:09
ARAF said:
ringram said:
1-7/8 Pacemakers IMO
Is this good, on all but the highest output engines? I know you say that no restriction is best, but I've been reading about exhaust gases stalling at slow speed and slowing the next exhaust pulse when they meet. Is there anything in this?Loads of results showing gains even on stock LS1's; its down to exhaust port flow.
Old numbers WCF
441.6 hp
391.4 tq
New numbers WCF
461.4 hp
406.5 tq
Again, ONLY thing changed is from Kooks to Kooks headers larger primaries.
http://ls1tech.com/forums/dynamometer-results-comp...
Im more open minded about exhaust sizing. But Vizards article here is always a good read http://www.popularhotrodding.com/enginemasters/art...
ringram said:
Old numbers WCF
441.6 hp
391.4 tq
New numbers WCF
461.4 hp
406.5 tq
Again, ONLY thing changed is from Kooks to Kooks headers larger primaries.
http://ls1tech.com/forums/dynamometer-results-comp...
Im more open minded about exhaust sizing. But Vizards article here is always a good read http://www.popularhotrodding.com/enginemasters/art...
With possibly a newer/better collector design (6 years newer headers) and a tune up. The previous run/tune was from 8 months previous.441.6 hp
391.4 tq
New numbers WCF
461.4 hp
406.5 tq
Again, ONLY thing changed is from Kooks to Kooks headers larger primaries.
http://ls1tech.com/forums/dynamometer-results-comp...
Im more open minded about exhaust sizing. But Vizards article here is always a good read http://www.popularhotrodding.com/enginemasters/art...
The second (very good) article states the importance of collector / secondary design, so it's pretty tough to get a like for like comparison going from one to the other, and it'll vary by what power your engine is making too.
All very interesting though

Edited by SturdyHSV on Friday 21st March 10:47
Thanks. 
So this leads onto my next thought. When I have had cars/bikes on which the exhaust has broken (not the headers), this should in theory allow exhaust gasses to escape easier and therefore be better. However, engines have often run a lot worse, with a big hole in the power curve. Now, these vehicles have been on carbs, so would this just be that the increased flow has caused the engine to run lean at certain stages of the carburettor operation?
Moving this on to modern fuel injection, will an engine adapt to the better flow or have the same problem as carbs? I guess what I am saying is will an engine need remapping with just headers to work as well as before? I'm not thinking of an optimum tune, just not making the car run worse by upgrading the headers.

So this leads onto my next thought. When I have had cars/bikes on which the exhaust has broken (not the headers), this should in theory allow exhaust gasses to escape easier and therefore be better. However, engines have often run a lot worse, with a big hole in the power curve. Now, these vehicles have been on carbs, so would this just be that the increased flow has caused the engine to run lean at certain stages of the carburettor operation?
Moving this on to modern fuel injection, will an engine adapt to the better flow or have the same problem as carbs? I guess what I am saying is will an engine need remapping with just headers to work as well as before? I'm not thinking of an optimum tune, just not making the car run worse by upgrading the headers.
I'm with you on this Ian ^^^^
I also like to understand the technical side a little, but I'm also interested in what is just theory against what happens in the real world. It never hurts to have a little knowledge to guide you towards a goal and it's even better when there are quantifiable gains to justify the costs.
This is a complex issue with many contradictory views. I'm even a little sceptical about the scavenging theory having any real merit................. but then again, I could be wrong.
I also like to understand the technical side a little, but I'm also interested in what is just theory against what happens in the real world. It never hurts to have a little knowledge to guide you towards a goal and it's even better when there are quantifiable gains to justify the costs.
This is a complex issue with many contradictory views. I'm even a little sceptical about the scavenging theory having any real merit................. but then again, I could be wrong.
Ah, you are now getting into the relative merits of speed density and maf based airflow for fueling and timing calculations.
If you touch the exhaust in any way, shape or form engine efficiency will change. Stock the VE tables are not optimal anyway, so the maf is used as a patch at higher airflow as its based on a fixed diameter pipe and a simple resister to map to a table of airflow.
So changes in theory will be reflected in a different Hz output from the resister in the maf.
No ideally you would change the VE values for each mod. Then your timing, fueling etc will be bang on, or near to it all the time. But with the maf this is less important and mods will be reflected in a different measured airflow.
So yes, in a modern car changes are reflected in the tune "adapting". But there is always room for improvement. Fueling is crap stock anyway, so you want to change that even if you have not changed anything else.
If you touch the exhaust in any way, shape or form engine efficiency will change. Stock the VE tables are not optimal anyway, so the maf is used as a patch at higher airflow as its based on a fixed diameter pipe and a simple resister to map to a table of airflow.
So changes in theory will be reflected in a different Hz output from the resister in the maf.
No ideally you would change the VE values for each mod. Then your timing, fueling etc will be bang on, or near to it all the time. But with the maf this is less important and mods will be reflected in a different measured airflow.
So yes, in a modern car changes are reflected in the tune "adapting". But there is always room for improvement. Fueling is crap stock anyway, so you want to change that even if you have not changed anything else.
ringram said:
.. also read the article. Scavanging and exhaust pulses are very important. So if you bust or remove the exhaust you also bust or remove the pulses of negative pressure.
Thats why exhaust overlap is good. A per Mr V's "5th cycle"
It's actually a well balanced article, giving the advantages and pitfalls to all of the conventional approaches. Or does it introduce even more questions? Fascinating stuff really. Thats why exhaust overlap is good. A per Mr V's "5th cycle"

I have this book. Its very good if you want to know as much as possible about specific things.
It covers just about anything you can imagine.
http://www.amazon.co.uk/INTERNAL-COMBUSTION-ENGINE...
It covers just about anything you can imagine.
http://www.amazon.co.uk/INTERNAL-COMBUSTION-ENGINE...
ringram said:
.. also read the article. Scavanging and exhaust pulses are very important. So if you bust or remove the exhaust you also bust or remove the pulses of negative pressure.
Thats why exhaust overlap is good. A per Mr V's "5th cycle"
He does repeatedly refer to race engines when talking of this 5th cycle though, how much of that is applicable?Thats why exhaust overlap is good. A per Mr V's "5th cycle"
Also, and forgive me for being dense here, but he mentions how the pressure difference at the exhaust valve is, what was it, 700 times greater than the amount caused by the cylinder going down the piston? So during valve overlap, he suggest that this 5th cycle is from the exhaust drawing in a significant amount of air through the intake port, more so than the piston movement.
That makes sense, but to my silly mind, if there's such a pressure difference, isn't most of this effect just pulled straight out of the exhaust valve? Or is this the case, and the 'leftovers' are what give the greater than 100% VE, making this a '5th' part of the cycle.
The biggest thing I've picked up in my reading, agreed with by that article, is primary length doesn't make too much difference, primary diameter needs to be appropriate (i.e bigger isn't always better) and that the collector length/diameter is a lot more important than people realise.
I'm still stuck with the old school theories too much. The idea of using scavenging to pull air into the cylinders isn't something I'd ever considered as realistic. As James has mentioned ^^^ , it can't be easy to effectively achieve without some of the air washing straight through.
But I like the idea of targetting the rev-range you'd like to improve ( as per the Vizard article) rather than just trying for as big a number as possible without blowing up.
But I like the idea of targetting the rev-range you'd like to improve ( as per the Vizard article) rather than just trying for as big a number as possible without blowing up.
You can see what happens at the drags with the flames out the exhaust. Thats from fuel and overlap.
Crackle on overrun is the same thing. Its just much more pronounced in race engines.
Yes you waste fuel, but there is more power, much the same as FI
The idea is to get the intake momentum going (out the exhaust) then close the exhaust and let momentum keep charging the cylinder while the piston then also helps create a (lower) pressure differential.
You want good intake port velocity because as we all know velocity is exponentially more important than mass for kenetic energy.
Thats where a lot of gains from cam changes comes from. Overlap is obviously bad for emissions, but good for power. So guess why OEM cams have such a wide lobe separation.. and why there is so much potential in large displacement v8's for more power.
Crackle on overrun is the same thing. Its just much more pronounced in race engines.
Yes you waste fuel, but there is more power, much the same as FI

The idea is to get the intake momentum going (out the exhaust) then close the exhaust and let momentum keep charging the cylinder while the piston then also helps create a (lower) pressure differential.
You want good intake port velocity because as we all know velocity is exponentially more important than mass for kenetic energy.
Thats where a lot of gains from cam changes comes from. Overlap is obviously bad for emissions, but good for power. So guess why OEM cams have such a wide lobe separation.. and why there is so much potential in large displacement v8's for more power.
Gassing Station | HSV & Monaro | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



