council closed off road without notice
Discussion
In my old home town which I visit regularly there is an old road linking one part of the town with the other. It has been a road for hundreds of years. The road is narrow (about 10 feet) with an unmade surface and most people had stopped using it for cars so about 10 years ago the local council stuck up a bollard at either end and put up signs declaring it a footpath/cycleway. There was never a stopping up notice served or any formal change of use. I complained at the time and was told by some pleb at the town hall that it was no longer used by cars and did not comply with modern road standards so the council had a right to close it to road vehicles. I was moving away from the town at the time so didn't pursue the complaint any further. I have since made it a point to ride a motor bike along it as often as possible when I visit the town and record this with a dated photo. I have been shouted at a few times by pedestrians and once was stopped by the local bobby. We knew each other and he had been in the town well before the council put up the bollards so when I explained my point just shrugged and said 'well ca canny then and dinnae hit onybody'. I've been spending more time in the old town lately and am thinking of bringing this back up with the Council. As I have kept using the road on a regular basis and have proof of this, do I have any chance of forcing the Council to remove the bollards and maintain the road again?
Just chop the bollards down and pop up a little sign to say 'road open to all traffic.'
When I am a multi-millionaire there are a few local roads that I am going to implement some common sense improvements on. Just minor stuff like cutting back kerbs on huge traffic islands, but I'll need my team to look 'official' when carrying out the works.
When I am a multi-millionaire there are a few local roads that I am going to implement some common sense improvements on. Just minor stuff like cutting back kerbs on huge traffic islands, but I'll need my team to look 'official' when carrying out the works.
Tribal Chestnut said:
Just chop the bollards down and pop up a little sign to say 'road open to all traffic.'
When I am a multi-millionaire there are a few local roads that I am going to implement some common sense improvements on. Just minor stuff like cutting back kerbs on huge traffic islands, but I'll need my team to look 'official' when carrying out the works.
You can get away with just about anything if you've got a white Transit Connect and a Yellow jacketWhen I am a multi-millionaire there are a few local roads that I am going to implement some common sense improvements on. Just minor stuff like cutting back kerbs on huge traffic islands, but I'll need my team to look 'official' when carrying out the works.
I would suggest firing off an email to my 10 year old son - You will at least get the courtesy of a reply, if a tad incoherent!
Anyway, good luck with dealing with any local authority up here - IMO they are universally ignorant and useless.
And apparently we want to be able rule ourselves? <Shudder> ;(
Anyway, good luck with dealing with any local authority up here - IMO they are universally ignorant and useless.
And apparently we want to be able rule ourselves? <Shudder> ;(
vanordinaire said:
In my old home town which I visit regularly there is an old road linking one part of the town with the other. It has been a road for hundreds of years. The road is narrow (about 10 feet) with an unmade surface and most people had stopped using it for cars so about 10 years ago the local council stuck up a bollard at either end and put up signs declaring it a footpath/cycleway. There was never a stopping up notice served or any formal change of use. I complained at the time and was told by some pleb at the town hall that it was no longer used by cars and did not comply with modern road standards so the council had a right to close it to road vehicles. I was moving away from the town at the time so didn't pursue the complaint any further. I have since made it a point to ride a motor bike along it as often as possible when I visit the town and record this with a dated photo. I have been shouted at a few times by pedestrians and once was stopped by the local bobby. We knew each other and he had been in the town well before the council put up the bollards so when I explained my point just shrugged and said 'well ca canny then and dinnae hit onybody'. I've been spending more time in the old town lately and am thinking of bringing this back up with the Council. As I have kept using the road on a regular basis and have proof of this, do I have any chance of forcing the Council to remove the bollards and maintain the road again?
Start with the council.If no joy, then talk to your local elected councillor - that's what they are there for...
Vaud said:
Riley Blue said:
Vaud said:
Start with the council.
If no joy, then talk to your local elected councillor - that's what they are there for...
But he doesn't live there, just visits.If no joy, then talk to your local elected councillor - that's what they are there for...
Hooli said:
geeks said:
Hooli said:
I think for a TRO to be legal it must be displayed at the end of the road?
Nope!geeks said:
Hooli said:
geeks said:
Hooli said:
I think for a TRO to be legal it must be displayed at the end of the road?
Nope!Right, if this is in Scotland, then the relevant legislation is different from England. We don't have "green lanes" for a start.
The Roads (Scotland) Act 1984 defines a road as "any way over which there is a public right of passage (by whatever means)... The definition is much clearer than the Highways Act 1980 that applies in England and Wales. The "road" may be split into different parts, for example a carriageway, a footway and/or a verge, but all of those bits together constitute a "road" and there is a public right of passage over all of it.
The Council can close a road under that Act if it is either dangerous, or no longer necessary. That means that it's closed, stopped up, not used by anybody. The public right of passage (by any means) is extinguished. To do that, they have to make a Stopping-Up Order under that Act.
If the Council want to keep the road open, but change its use (that is, to limit the "means" by which that public right of passage can be exercised), then they have two options:
1. To redetermine the public right of passage by Order, under that same Act, so that it can only be used by pedestrians and/or cyclists or equestrians; or
2. To promote a Traffic Regulation Order under the Road Traffic Regulation Act 1984 to prohibit vehicles of a certain class, or all motor vehicles, as required.
Both of those options also require an Order. Both of those Orders must follow procedures set down by parliament in Statutory Instruments. Although the two procedures are slightly different, both involve public advertisement of the proposal in a "newspaper circulating in the area", both require that notices be placed on the lengths of road affected for a specified time (21 or 28 days), both require that the opportunity be given to make objections during the advertisement period, and both require that those objections be properly considered (although the procedure for resolving objections is slightly different between the two procedures).
Only then can the Order be made, without risk of legal challenge.
The local authority can't just go closing roads as they like, when the procedures are clearly set out.
The Roads (Scotland) Act 1984 defines a road as "any way over which there is a public right of passage (by whatever means)... The definition is much clearer than the Highways Act 1980 that applies in England and Wales. The "road" may be split into different parts, for example a carriageway, a footway and/or a verge, but all of those bits together constitute a "road" and there is a public right of passage over all of it.
The Council can close a road under that Act if it is either dangerous, or no longer necessary. That means that it's closed, stopped up, not used by anybody. The public right of passage (by any means) is extinguished. To do that, they have to make a Stopping-Up Order under that Act.
If the Council want to keep the road open, but change its use (that is, to limit the "means" by which that public right of passage can be exercised), then they have two options:
1. To redetermine the public right of passage by Order, under that same Act, so that it can only be used by pedestrians and/or cyclists or equestrians; or
2. To promote a Traffic Regulation Order under the Road Traffic Regulation Act 1984 to prohibit vehicles of a certain class, or all motor vehicles, as required.
Both of those options also require an Order. Both of those Orders must follow procedures set down by parliament in Statutory Instruments. Although the two procedures are slightly different, both involve public advertisement of the proposal in a "newspaper circulating in the area", both require that notices be placed on the lengths of road affected for a specified time (21 or 28 days), both require that the opportunity be given to make objections during the advertisement period, and both require that those objections be properly considered (although the procedure for resolving objections is slightly different between the two procedures).
Only then can the Order be made, without risk of legal challenge.
The local authority can't just go closing roads as they like, when the procedures are clearly set out.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



