NI Police Officers leave incapacitated alcoholic in bus lane
Discussion
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-foyl...
"A Londonderry woman, who was captured on camera being left in a bus lay-by by two police officers while incapacitated, has called for the officers to be sacked.
Bridget Mongan, 23, admits being drunk at the time, but said the officers should have left her on the pavement."
Always wondered what the Police procedure is on this front, I once fell asleep (I'd had a few) outside my mate's house whilst waiting for a lift home, and a couple of officers woke me up as they'd had a concerned call about me. But I was perfectly able to walk and talk, etc and they left me to it.
I wouldn't like to think they'd just have left me in the road if I was utterly blootered
Methinks there's, of course, a lot more to the story than on the Beebsite too
"A Londonderry woman, who was captured on camera being left in a bus lay-by by two police officers while incapacitated, has called for the officers to be sacked.
Bridget Mongan, 23, admits being drunk at the time, but said the officers should have left her on the pavement."
Always wondered what the Police procedure is on this front, I once fell asleep (I'd had a few) outside my mate's house whilst waiting for a lift home, and a couple of officers woke me up as they'd had a concerned call about me. But I was perfectly able to walk and talk, etc and they left me to it.
I wouldn't like to think they'd just have left me in the road if I was utterly blootered

Methinks there's, of course, a lot more to the story than on the Beebsite too

simoid said:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-foyl...
Methinks there's, of course, a lot more to the story than on the Beebsite too
Pretty much this, I reckonMethinks there's, of course, a lot more to the story than on the Beebsite too

!!Speculation alert!!
She admits to being an alcoholic, so maybe has previous with the Police?
If you're a Police officer and just arrested her man, do you go back to her and try to drag her out the road?
She doesn't look like she would take it lying down......no, wait.....she does....erm..
I have mixed feelings on this one.
She's clearly mobile; it's not like they dumped an unconscious person in the road.
She appears to be playing dead from the point the police grab her.
It was a bit silly to leave her there though rather than on the kerb or pavement.
I would suggest that these cops be retrained a bit in terms of where to dump drunk women.
No need to fire them though.
That's just the angry ranting of an alcoholic who isn't willing to take responsibility for herself.
She's clearly mobile; it's not like they dumped an unconscious person in the road.
She appears to be playing dead from the point the police grab her.
It was a bit silly to leave her there though rather than on the kerb or pavement.
I would suggest that these cops be retrained a bit in terms of where to dump drunk women.
No need to fire them though.
That's just the angry ranting of an alcoholic who isn't willing to take responsibility for herself.
Snowboy said:
I have mixed feelings on this one.
She's clearly mobile; it's not like they dumped an unconscious person in the road.
She appears to be playing dead from the point the police grab her.
It was a bit silly to leave her there though rather than on the kerb or pavement.
I would suggest that these cops be retrained a bit in terms of where to dump drunk women.
No need to fire them though.
That's just the angry ranting of an alcoholic who isn't willing to take responsibility for herself.
Amazingly enough I'm more or less in agreement.She's clearly mobile; it's not like they dumped an unconscious person in the road.
She appears to be playing dead from the point the police grab her.
It was a bit silly to leave her there though rather than on the kerb or pavement.
I would suggest that these cops be retrained a bit in terms of where to dump drunk women.
No need to fire them though.
That's just the angry ranting of an alcoholic who isn't willing to take responsibility for herself.
I'd presume their inspector will rip them a new one for the adverse publicity rather than the actual leaving her in the road, but it'll have the same effect. Leaving her there was pretty dumb by any standard.
OTOH she seemed quite mobile a few seconds earlier and might only be suffering from pendular plumbosis.
Slightly off topic, anyone getting drunk should be responsible for their actions- it was their choice to get drunk.
From the BBC story, it looked like the police came across a drunk woman lying in the road and moved her into a bus lane. If thats the case, then I'd have absolutrly no sympathy for the coppers.
But it seems there is more to the story. From what I have gathered from other posters it seems her boyfriend had been arrested and was being taken away in the unmarked police car. She then tries to 'rescue' him and the police safely and non-violently carry her away and leave her a safe distance away from the car.
I am not endeared to the police at all but if the second scenario is the case then the police officers involved should not even get a verbal warning let alone the sack. In fact they should be commended for not being jumped up like their colleagues in the Met who arrest on a whim.
But it seems there is more to the story. From what I have gathered from other posters it seems her boyfriend had been arrested and was being taken away in the unmarked police car. She then tries to 'rescue' him and the police safely and non-violently carry her away and leave her a safe distance away from the car.
I am not endeared to the police at all but if the second scenario is the case then the police officers involved should not even get a verbal warning let alone the sack. In fact they should be commended for not being jumped up like their colleagues in the Met who arrest on a whim.
For those who can't see the video.
There is a row of cars parked on the side of a road with a gap for a bus stop.
The cop car is parked in the road next to these cars and bus stop, the police have just put a bloke in their car.
The woman runs out from the pavement through the parked cars into the middle of the road and tries to rescue the bloke from the back of the car.
Maybe a 20 yard run.
The two cops pick her up and move her to the side of the road, into the bus stop gap.
She goes limp when they hold her and falls over when they let her go, but seems to fall comfortably and adjust herself so she's lying comfortably.
The police seem to say a few words then leave.
There is a row of cars parked on the side of a road with a gap for a bus stop.
The cop car is parked in the road next to these cars and bus stop, the police have just put a bloke in their car.
The woman runs out from the pavement through the parked cars into the middle of the road and tries to rescue the bloke from the back of the car.
Maybe a 20 yard run.
The two cops pick her up and move her to the side of the road, into the bus stop gap.
She goes limp when they hold her and falls over when they let her go, but seems to fall comfortably and adjust herself so she's lying comfortably.
The police seem to say a few words then leave.
simoid said:
Always?
Excluding spiked drinks, yes."Alcoholism is a disease" doesn't wash- I've had many drinks & been in many pubs/clubs/bars and never caught it. To become an alcoholic you have to work quite hard at it, as a few crafty gulps before noon isn't enough to 'infect' you with this 'disease'.
simoid said:
Rovinghawk said:
...it was their choice to get drunk.
Always?There is probably a statistically negligible number of people who get drinks spiked or who go drinking for the first time and get abandoned my mates who I have genuine sympathy for.
The remaining 99.99% of people only have themselves to blame.
And personally, I include alcoholics in that list.
I agree it's an illness of sorts - but it doesn't absolve them off responsibility.
Alcoholism is serious. If someone has developed a physical addiction, it's dangerous to withdraw from it. More so than every illegal drug I can think of.
Either way one one still has some control when drunk.
The officers should have pulled her that bit farther on to the path, but then could they have foreseen she would become "incapacitated" at that moment having had the cognitive ability to follow them and try to open a door.
Bit of a non-story, really.
Either way one one still has some control when drunk.
The officers should have pulled her that bit farther on to the path, but then could they have foreseen she would become "incapacitated" at that moment having had the cognitive ability to follow them and try to open a door.
Bit of a non-story, really.
I can't comment on this story (because I wasn't there) but I can relate to how things look compared to how things are.
We got called to a drunk and unresponsive women one night. On arrival it's obvious that she's faking her unconsciousness and is aware of everything that's going on. We got her into the back of the ambo and started checking her over. Once away from her entourage (a load of other drunk girls) she started shouting at us, threatening violence, vomited on the floor then pissed all over the stretcher.
By this point I'd had enough (and with her observations all stable), chucked her out of the ambulance and called the police. As soon as she was outside, amongst her friends, she went back into unresponsive mode. I then had her friends trying to get into the ambulance, hurling abuse, and threatening to sue. We decided that the safest course of action was to move out of sight till plod turned up, then decide what we were going to do.
From the inside we were justified in removing this women from the ambulance to protect ourselves and our vehicle. To an outsider it looked like we dragged an unconscious girl out of the vehicle and left her on the path then drove off.
Two sides, one story...
We got called to a drunk and unresponsive women one night. On arrival it's obvious that she's faking her unconsciousness and is aware of everything that's going on. We got her into the back of the ambo and started checking her over. Once away from her entourage (a load of other drunk girls) she started shouting at us, threatening violence, vomited on the floor then pissed all over the stretcher.
By this point I'd had enough (and with her observations all stable), chucked her out of the ambulance and called the police. As soon as she was outside, amongst her friends, she went back into unresponsive mode. I then had her friends trying to get into the ambulance, hurling abuse, and threatening to sue. We decided that the safest course of action was to move out of sight till plod turned up, then decide what we were going to do.
From the inside we were justified in removing this women from the ambulance to protect ourselves and our vehicle. To an outsider it looked like we dragged an unconscious girl out of the vehicle and left her on the path then drove off.
Two sides, one story...
Snowboy said:
For those who can't see the video.
There is a row of cars parked on the side of a road with a gap for a bus stop.
The cop car is parked in the road next to these cars and bus stop, the police have just put a bloke in their car.
The woman runs out from the pavement through the parked cars into the middle of the road and tries to rescue the bloke from the back of the car.
Maybe a 20 yard run.
The two cops pick her up and move her to the side of the road, into the bus stop gap.
She goes limp when they hold her and falls over when they let her go, but seems to fall comfortably and adjust herself so she's lying comfortably.
The police seem to say a few words then leave.
Having failed to get the bloke out of the car she's possibly trying to get herself arrested as well to go with him. There is a row of cars parked on the side of a road with a gap for a bus stop.
The cop car is parked in the road next to these cars and bus stop, the police have just put a bloke in their car.
The woman runs out from the pavement through the parked cars into the middle of the road and tries to rescue the bloke from the back of the car.
Maybe a 20 yard run.
The two cops pick her up and move her to the side of the road, into the bus stop gap.
She goes limp when they hold her and falls over when they let her go, but seems to fall comfortably and adjust herself so she's lying comfortably.
The police seem to say a few words then leave.
Seemed perfectly capable of running around, no staggering around or square tangoing.
She should either have been put on the pavement & left standing - or, if she wanted to continue the 'drunk & incapable' routine by lying on the ground, obliged by being arrested & removed to a place of safety. Would have required another vehicle to collect so I expect there would then be cries of what a waste of resources.
Taking in D&Is didn't endear you to the custody sergeant & it was normal practice - on the grounds that hospital was a safer place & that's what would happen anyway - for an ambulance to be called to take them away to A&E. Yet another wonderful use of resources. (Not very popular with the ambulance crews either!)
Edited by paintman on Thursday 20th March 15:20
I know it doesn't justify what happened and, for the record, I think they were numpties for just leaving her lying in the road but it appears its not Ms. Mongan's first time in the news.
http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/news/local-natio...
http://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/news/local-natio...
I wonder what happened to her in the 10 seconds between running down the road and trying to intefere in the arrest of her boyfriend to her being moved away that prevented her from getting up off the floor.
She didn't have a mobility problem running up to the car and trying to open the doors did she?
She didn't have a mobility problem running up to the car and trying to open the doors did she?
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


