Land charge in title deed: does it prevent solar panels?
Land charge in title deed: does it prevent solar panels?
Author
Discussion

peter_964rs

Original Poster:

287 posts

304 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
So here's a legal query. I have recently bought a house which has an attached orchard that was covered under a separate title. It's unattractive for anything other than trees, or solar panels, because it's extremely steep and in fact terraced. There are no houses nearby apart from mine; I think it originally belonged to the farmer next door and he sold it to the previous owners of our house.

There is a restrictive covenant in the title need that says I cannot erect any permanent structures of any kind on the land, nor any temporary structure that exceed 4m in height within 5 metres of one of the boundaries.

I would like to stick some ground mounted solar panels on this land as the situation is pretty much ideal. These would be mounted low and on wooden frames.

Do they qualify as permanent or temporary structures? They aren't sheds, greenhouses, swimming pools, houses, etc, just frames with panels on, so I'm not clear on what consitutes a 'structure'. If they are considered temporary the height and distance restrictions are not a problem as it's just a small array that can be some distance from the boundary. If they aren't a 'structure' then I'm fairly free on where to site them, but more importantly I don't want to fall foul of the covenant and have to remove them at some point.

I am assuming that the fact that they're on frames, potentially moveable, and I could reposition them elsewhere on my property (say) might class them as temporary, or is that disingenious?

Any informed advice very welcome!

MG0o

96 posts

156 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
If you can pick it up and move it about then it should be no problem at all,hehe other people picking them up and moving them to their car might be tho smile
But seriously:-
Temporary structures are things like playhouses, sheds/ larger wooden framed workshops etc, a few panels low down should t be a problem.

peter_964rs

Original Poster:

287 posts

304 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
Thanks - can you point me at any legal definitions of a temporary structure on t'internet so I can be sure?

Andy_GSA

518 posts

213 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
The property register should say who has the benefit of the covenant, have you asked them if they object as they're the only ones who can try to enforce it?

peter_964rs

Original Poster:

287 posts

304 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
Not yet as we have only just moved in - I think it would be the farm next door.

I would prefer to work on the basis that forgiveness is easier to seek than permission smile but also that the people currently in next door may not be there in a year or two's time. If the legal position is such that they shoudln't be there, either a future owner could object, or else anyone buying our house well in the future might have an attentive conveyancer who spots the fact that they're there and we have a problem selling.

Except, of course, if it isn't actually a legal problem after all.

Jobbo

13,911 posts

295 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
Do you have any idea who benefits from the restrictive covenant? It may not be your neighbour, and the person who benefits may not know or care.

As to definitions of temporary structure, if the solar panels are not intended to stay in place indefinitely (and I assume they have a finite lifespan) then a structure intended to support them only for their lifespan would be temporary. It's not a 100% argument if the structures are solidly fixed and not obviously intended to be anything less than permanent, but it's worth using if you were to have a fight.

I suspect you may have more difficulties with planning though; do check out the planning situation before installing anything.

Edited by Jobbo on Thursday 20th March 17:20

johnfm

13,751 posts

281 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
How big is the downside risk to you?

If £££££££££, get a legal opinion.

If £, ask on pistonheads.

peter_964rs

Original Poster:

287 posts

304 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
Jobbo said:
Do you have any idea who benefits from the restrictive covenant? It may not be your neighbour, and the person who benefits may not know or care.

As to definitions of temporary structure, if the solar panels are not intended to stay in place indefinitely (and I assume they have a finite lifespan) then a structure intended to support them only for their lifespan would be temporary. It's not a 100% argument if the structures are solidly fixed and not obviously intended to be anything less than permanent, but it's worth using if you were to have a fight.

I suspect you may have more difficulties with planning though; do check out the planning situation before installing anything.

Edited by Jobbo on Thursday 20th March 17:20
Thanks - yes, I will probably need planning. As for who benefits, I suspect it to be the farm next door. However, regardless if they care, I am aware that the covenant might restrict my ability to sell in future if I have put a 'structure' on the land. Tricky to know what qualifies as a 'structure' and legal advice can be expensive...

Jobbo

13,911 posts

295 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
Contractual interpretation relies on the plain meaning of the words in the context of the document as a whole. "Structure" would not exactly vex a court...

peter_964rs

Original Poster:

287 posts

304 months

Friday 21st March 2014
quotequote all
Godo question: I would think that the original intent was to prevent the reuse of the land for development. However, it could be that there was a concern about the increasing installation of solar arrays, wind turbines, etc, as well as any other structure that could be considered unsightly. It's steep, so I could see myself installing an Austrian-style sled run down the hill smile.

In any case, whilst I suspect that I wouldn't come into conflict with whomever might want the covenant enforced, in practice I just want to make sure any challenge can be robustly defended. I just want to offset increasing electricity bills and I don't think the panels would be noticable by anyone.