Restrictive covenants in employment contracts?
Restrictive covenants in employment contracts?
Author
Discussion

A900ss

Original Poster:

3,314 posts

183 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
I have restrictive covenants in my employment contract and I am questioning one of them and would like to know if it can be enforced?

Quick summary, I am a Senior Account manager for an electrical manufacturer and according to my contract I can't work for a competitor for 12 months after leaving my current company. I did sign the contract, times move on and now I want to move on.

If i can't work for a competitor then so be it but I do want to know.

Although I work for neither of these companies, if supposedly I currently sold TV's for Samsung, would this covenant legally restrict me going to work for Panasonic to sell TV's for them?

The wording is:

You will not for the period of 12 months immediately after the termination of your employment, whether as principle or agent and whether alone or jointly, with or as a director, manager, partner, shareholder, employee or consultant of any other person, directly or indirectly engage in activities so as compete with the Company, carry on or be engaged, concerned or interested in any business which is similar to any business being carried on by the Company at the termination of the employment and with which you were involved at any time during the period of 12 months immediately preceding the termination of the contract.

Many thanks.

A900ss

Original Poster:

3,314 posts

183 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
PS - forgot to add that I know details of new products being launched into the trade about 9 months out which is the industry norm. So I currently know what my company will be launching for 2015.

archie456

526 posts

253 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
I'm not legally qualified, but my understanding is that these terms in a contract are not enforceable.

The principle is that if your skills are in selling a particular type of technology, then they can't force you out of that marketplace, because you have a right to be able to work. No doubt someone will be along soon to elaborate on this and the exact legal standing.

Steffan

10,362 posts

259 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
The judiciary regard restrictive covenants with suspicion and tend to interpret widely in consequence. To some extent it will depend upon the restrictive wording but the lawyers intensely dislike restraint of trade per se and tend to regard RC's with the narrowest possible interpretation. You really need an employment law specialist to read the actual wording and interpret the probable effects. I doubt if the current employer will pursue a claim but they could. Moving to a different town is usually sufficient to deter any action. I do not think an RC could be used to prevent employment in the same industry in another town. But you need specialist advice.

A900ss

Original Poster:

3,314 posts

183 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
The reality is that my skills are in account management; the product is not that relevant as I could sell TV's, computers, toasters using the same skill set.

What I am a concerned about is being offered a role by a competitor, handing my notice in and then my current employer being heavy handed and scaring the potential new employer into not hiring me. Legal or not.

Edited by A900ss on Thursday 20th March 18:59

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
You need proper legal advice as the covenants restrict your main employment and may not be enforceable. The fact they are there may make you a less attractive prospective employee.

Personally I think these sort of things are unethical and have refused to sign them previously.

A900ss

Original Poster:

3,314 posts

183 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
Steffan said:
The judiciary regard restrictive covenants with suspicion and tend to interpret widely in consequence. To some extent it will depend upon the restrictive wording but the lawyers intensely dislike restraint of trade per se and tend to regard RC's with the narrowest possible interpretation. You really need an employment law specialist to read the actual wording and interpret the probable effects. I doubt if the current employer will pursue a claim but they could. Moving to a different town is usually sufficient to deter any action. I do not think an RC could be used to prevent employment in the same industry in another town. But you need specialist advice.
My role is national, ie I deal at retailer head offices that are operative UK wide.

For example, I may sell Samsung TV's into Tesco head office and then these TV's are then sold throughout the country in every Tesco store.

For clarity, I do not work for Samsung or sell to Tesco.

Edited by A900ss on Thursday 20th March 19:00

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
Hopefully one of the lawyers will be along in a minute...

but my questions would be:

did they pay you to sign the covenant or did it form a part of the standard employment contract?
How senior and well paid are you?

It seems a bit harsh to me...

Cue Breadvan telling me I am talking ste.


A900ss

Original Poster:

3,314 posts

183 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
desolate said:
Hopefully one of the lawyers will be along in a minute...

but my questions would be:

did they pay you to sign the covenant or did it form a part of the standard employment contract?
How senior and well paid are you?

It seems a bit harsh to me...

Cue Breadvan telling me I am talking ste.
Standard T's and C's.

Package above £50k but below £100k

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
archie456 said:
I'm not legally qualified, but my understanding is that these terms in a contract are not enforceable.

The principle is that if your skills are in selling a particular type of technology, then they can't force you out of that marketplace, because you have a right to be able to work. No doubt someone will be along soon to elaborate on this and the exact legal standing.

You are completely wrong. As you are not legally qualified, why are you giving (rubbish) legal advice?

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
A900ss said:
Standard T's and C's.

Package above £50k but below £100k
On the presumption you are moving for similar money I would be very tempted to pay for a consultation to get a considered opinion, as the idea of "reasonable" varies from industry to industry and position to position.

Find a decent lawyer who will give you advice rather than platitudes and the weigh up the risk. There have been some recommendations on here in the past.

Or ignore all that, get the new job and fk 'em.


anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
Steffan said:
The judiciary regard restrictive covenants with suspicion and tend to interpret widely in consequence. To some extent it will depend upon the restrictive wording but the lawyers intensely dislike restraint of trade per se and tend to regard RC's with the narrowest possible interpretation. You really need an employment law specialist to read the actual wording and interpret the probable effects. I doubt if the current employer will pursue a claim but they could. Moving to a different town is usually sufficient to deter any action. I do not think an RC could be used to prevent employment in the same industry in another town. But you need specialist advice.
OP, Ignore all but the second sentence of that post.

This is an area in which there is no substitute for expert professional advice and none of you well meaning amateurs is even remotely qualified to give such advice, as is evident from the utter nonsense that appears above, well intended as it is.

I am travelling and about to go offline but will post an informed view later. For the present, OP, IGNORE all guff emanating from well intentioned bloke in pub types. They could cost you a lot of money, and I mean a lot.

Siscar

6,315 posts

160 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
Unfortunately Breadvan breaks the first rule of Internet advice by posting about things he actually does know about, shouldn't be allowed.

I predict that he is going to confirm that they can be enforceable and he has been involved in such cases himself as a barrister with some speciality in this area.

So I would be starting from the perspective that it can be enforced in a way that will cost you a lot of money, and then look for anyone who can give you reliable advice in why that may not be the case.

A900ss

Original Poster:

3,314 posts

183 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
Thanks Breadvan.

I will not post who I work for but they have an active legal team and I don't want to put myself in a position where I am out of work after handing in my notice and another potential employer getting cold feet by receiving a legal letter.

I accept I signed the contract, I wanted the job at the time and if it is enforceable then I'll stand by it.

Terminator X

20,985 posts

235 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
A900ss said:
PS - forgot to add that I know details of new products being launched into the trade about 9 months out which is the industry norm. So I currently know what my company will be launching for 2015.
This will be why your contract is worded so rofl lesson learnt though, don't sign up to stuff that you may regret later.

TX.

A900ss

Original Poster:

3,314 posts

183 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
And thanks Siscar.

Looks like it might be best to look for an employer that sells toasters rather than TV's (not that I sell TV's!)

I use the TV's, toasters, Samsung details as I do not want to indicate my employer or the category in which they manufacture.

A900ss

Original Poster:

3,314 posts

183 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
Terminator X said:
A900ss said:
PS - forgot to add that I know details of new products being launched into the trade about 9 months out which is the industry norm. So I currently know what my company will be launching for 2015.
This will be why your contract is worded so rofl lesson learnt though, don't sign up to stuff that you may regret later.

TX.
I've never had this wording in my contracts in previous companies and my current company won't employ anybody who doesn't sign up to it.

In previous companies I have had details of NPD (new products) at least 3 years out but this company is much tighter on what they reveal and much more litigious.

Hey ho.

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
As I posted in another thread(s).

"Post term restrictive covenants are enforceable if reasonable, relevant and proportionate. Whilst is is a restraint of trade, courts will enforce if it's necessary to protect the legitimate interests of the employer.

The courts will balance the former employee’s right to trade and earn a living with the former employer’s right to protect its interests, while taking into account that the contract was entered into freely.

If everyone from receptionist to MD has the same clause then often these will not be enforceable (relatively recent case law had a senior employee who had signed a contract with a non-compete years ago when junior rejected)

Lots more details, but the above is a summary"

12 month global RC have been enforced in the past, although there was some interesting behaviour that led to this, so much so that it appeared the hiring firm had taken advice from some bloke in a pub.

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
That is a fair summary. Twelve month post termination restrictions on working for a competing business are regularly upheld by English Courts, provided that they do no more than is reasonable to protect legitimate business interests. The ideas that such clauses are inherently unenforceable or that Judges are inherently hostile to them are simply incorrect.

I have now read the OP's covenant. It has one weakness that might prove fatal to it, which is the words "similar to". This brings into play the leading case of TFS Derivatives but the employer could seek to distinguish TFS as in the OP's case the words "similar to" are qualified by "so as to compete with". That was not the position in TFS. Also, even in TFS case the possibility of an effective restriction in respect of business similar to that of the employer was left open. The enforceability of such a restraint would depend on the precise business context. No one can advise the OP properly without knowing what job he does, for which company, and in which business etc.

An aggressive and well funded employer may seek to enforce a clause even of it is not a slam dunker at trial, and very often the Court will grant an interim injunction pending a speedy trial. This puts the employee into a tense and costly process, and most employees then settle on terms more or less dictated by the employer. Fair? Probably not, but it's real life.

Take expert and insured advice. Do not rely on anything said to you on the internet, not by me, not by anyone(except this).

IAAL but IANYL.


Edited by anonymous-user on Thursday 20th March 20:44

Terminator X

20,985 posts

235 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
To the OP, how will existing employer know where you've gone? I didn't tell mine for example or indeed the previous company that I worked for.

Breadvan - what would happen if OP jumped ship to a competitor, old company don't know initially but find out about it before the restrictive 12 month period elapses?

TX.