Small Claims Court!
Small Claims Court!
Author
Discussion

herbialfa

Original Poster:

1,489 posts

233 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
I have one against me at the moment. Went through mediation (no avail) so now down to the expert witness route. The EW has prepared his report and its pretty damming against me. Things like "I was unable to attend the site visit" - which is clearly documented in our emails where I asked to be in attendance! Only the client was there! I have always known the client to be called "William" but in the email requesting the site visit "Hi Billy can I pop round Friday afternoon?" from the EW

The whole report is against me in name but I got a court order to change it to the company name as thats who the client instructed.

I have contacted a solicitor who has all the court papers for 2 weeks now and hasn't returned any of my 4 calls.

Court date is 9th April 2014 and having never been in this position before where do I stand?

I have sent the report to friends, Building Control officer in Scotland (I live in England), Site manager of one the BIG house building companies and my local builder.

"YOU ARE BEING HUNG UP TO DRY" is the response.

Now I can can pick holes left right & centre in his report and have prepared a REFUTE document numerically as per his report.

Can I legally send this document to the EW (copied to the claimant) or what is my best course of action????

Any advice would be greatly received.

Thanks in advance!

Simpo Two

93,078 posts

296 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
Well I haven't been down this road but the claimant has got a buddy or at least tame 'expert' to write a report that supports his side and not yours. Hardly a surprise; I'm sure it happens all the time, and in legal slang 'Well he would wouldn't he?' (a good line to use in court!)

The Refute document, if that is what it's called, sounds like a very useful exercise. I expect you'd have to send one copy to the Court and one to the Claimant (use Signed For post of course). My feeling is that you should not send stuff to the EW directly, but stand to be corrected.

Can you get an EW to support YOUR side of the story? Also see if you can undermine the crdentials of HIS EW. Time for some research perhaps. Or maybe you can PROVE some of what he says to be wrong, irrefutably, which will cast doubt on everything else he says.

As said before, I have not been in this precise spot - in fact I thought I had an EW for my case but the judge said it was a Testimonial - but read all the small print and above all, follow protocol.

johnfm

13,751 posts

281 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
Is the claim being heard in Scotland or England?

herbialfa

Original Poster:

1,489 posts

233 months

Friday 21st March 2014
quotequote all
In England.

I have been told re. site visit that both parties or neither parties should be in attendance at the site visit so thats a technicality thats wrong straight off the bat.

singlecoil

35,868 posts

277 months

Friday 21st March 2014
quotequote all
Just to provide some context, to get an idea of what is at risk, how much is being claimed?

What are the actual merits of his case (if any)?

herbialfa

Original Poster:

1,489 posts

233 months

Friday 21st March 2014
quotequote all
5K

It was for a loft conversion (clients are town planner & Architect) but couldn't do the drawings as it was under their own L.A.

I obtained PP & building regs approval as instructed.

I specified a joist size (which I also stated see structural calcs) which in turn were upgraded by the structural engineer 2 months after I had issued the "Approved" plans.

Contractor installed joists to my dimensions then building control noticed the error.

I am being claimed for abortive costs on site, 11 additional weeks of scaffolding hire etc.

This all happened 4 months or so after all parties had been issued plans and calculations. I wasn't even asked to assist in resolving any issues plus they used my plans with the company name for a non material amendment application.

The first I knew of issues on site was when the small claims court document landed on my door step.

singlecoil

35,868 posts

277 months

Friday 21st March 2014
quotequote all
Looks like your case is pretty strong then. It all depends on how much they can confuse the issue. Not giving you a chance to put right any wrongs (real or imagined) is pretty damning in itself.

cuneus

5,963 posts

273 months

Friday 21st March 2014
quotequote all
Not knowing anything about the subject - why did the structural engineer change the joist size and what is the protocol for that?

Can you show that change to be superfluous ? (via an independent expert witness for court)

Edited by cuneus on Friday 21st March 10:13

Simpo Two

93,078 posts

296 months

Friday 21st March 2014
quotequote all
herbialfa said:
The first I knew of issues on site was when the small claims court document landed on my door step.
Well that's not right for a start - claimants are required to serve due notice and give them a chance to make amends before it goes legal. You didn't have a chance to take any corrective action. I think the Court might throw it out on those grounds alone - but of course they will probably start again.

It looks like the Contractor is in the clear - he simply did what was on the plans. But who failed to point out that the joists had been upgraded? Whose job was that? And did the joists actually need upgrading? If the thing was built to plans that said Approved, why is Building Control bothered?


JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Friday 21st March 2014
quotequote all
herbialfa said:
The whole report is against me in name but I got a court order to change it to the company name as thats who the client instructed.

I have contacted a solicitor who has all the court papers for 2 weeks now and hasn't returned any of my 4 calls.

Court date is 9th April 2014 and having never been in this position before where do I stand?
Have you filed a Defence?

Is the hearing date 9th April, or is this the date to file a Defence?

You need a solicitor to go through everything from a contractual standpoint. The first thing they would have done was to file a Defence on the grounds that the Claimant does not have a contract with you.

That would have meant them paying out for the claim again.

Get a new solicitor!

johnfm

13,751 posts

281 months

Friday 21st March 2014
quotequote all
So is their claim that you breached te implied term of the SGSA to provide your services with reasonable skill and care?

As Tonker suggests, if you can show that your designed beam size is sufficient you have a defence.

If the contractor has used the wrong drawings, why hasn't the claimant chased them? You could bring them in with a Part 20 claim if you think they were negligent and cause the damage claimed.

I suppose absolute first step is to show that the beam size originally specified satisfies building regs. If they do satisfy relevant regs, you haven't caused any damage to the claimant.

When is the hearing? Apply to court for a new hearing date if you need time to get an engineer to provide a report on beam size. But you may need to ask the court permission to use an expert witness.

cuneus

5,963 posts

273 months

Friday 21st March 2014
quotequote all
Sorry more thoughts:

Shouldn't you be contacting your insurers and professional body ?

herbialfa

Original Poster:

1,489 posts

233 months

Wednesday 26th March 2014
quotequote all
OK update.

I instructed a solicitor yesterday who thinks I have a very strong case and is drafting up a letter for me by the weekend.

Joist sizes were sprecced from the TRADA tables and the ends of the joists were to pick up with studs dropping down off the purlins.

The clients subsequently amended my drawings (including my title box and initials) for another application to amend certain items without my knowledge.

The court date is a directional case (30 mins) to basically send it to trial.

HoHoHo

15,405 posts

281 months

Wednesday 26th March 2014
quotequote all
Sounds like a nightmare and I'm sure you'll win albeit with costs and unnecessary time spent fighting the case.

We were recently taken to a Tribunal by a contractor claiming to be an employee and after 6 months he gave up and walked as he had no case. Cost our insurers over £10k in legal fees to fight a case that never was.

I wish you the best, I'm sure you'll be fine.

herbialfa

Original Poster:

1,489 posts

233 months

Wednesday 9th April 2014
quotequote all
New update!

Court hearing was this afternoon for 30 minutes and its now going to trial on 20th June.

Judge was frowning at their statements "Yes we amended Mr. ? s plans to resubmit" I kept quiet to allow them to spill the beans!

The Expert Witness report is non CPR Compliant which means it has to be resubmitted. I have a rough idea of what "Non CPR Compliant" is but any info would be appreciated.

Finally, the judge while discussing the case and glancing at both parties his last statement he stared at the claimant and said "You know this can be resolved through mediation!"

Any further advice would be appreciated.

wattsm666

742 posts

296 months

Wednesday 9th April 2014
quotequote all
Mediate and/or put a part 36 offer in.


Johnniem

2,758 posts

254 months

Thursday 10th April 2014
quotequote all
An 'expert witness' is effectively acting for the court and not specifically for the person who instructed him/her. It is possible to have the same expert act for both parties. The 'expert' is there to confirm what should be done, not to take sides. You can, of course, have your own expert and he may well hold a contrary view from that of the other sides expert. It is then that the court must unravel the evidence.

Good luck.