From engineering to finance?
From engineering to finance?
Author
Discussion

motorsportbeng

Original Poster:

200 posts

191 months

Friday 21st March 2014
quotequote all
I think I'm posting this in the right section, let me know if I'm not!

I'm approaching the completion of a motorsport engineering degree (hopefully 1st class BEng level) and currently assessing my future options. I love motorsport, having worked in the industry before and during my studies, so I can't really see myself working outside of it.
However, after reading a few articles and over-hearing a few bar conversations, I'm led to believe the engineering skill set comprising of a problem solving mentality and efficient use of numbers is valuable in the 'big city' finance industry.
I have no understanding of the finance industry currently but I basically see it as an opportunity to earn the big bucks, sufficient enough to fund my own motorsport adventures at the weekends. Obviously there is the inherent long hours, stressful working environment and dealing with some 'characters' but this doesn't sound much different to working in the UK Motorsport industry!

Does anyone have any experiences that relate to the above that means I should start looking into it in more detail?

Thanks!

Frimley111R

19,421 posts

265 months

Friday 21st March 2014
quotequote all
No experience but you can either work doing something you love 5 days as week or you can work doing something you may not like 5 days a week and hopefully enjoy what you do 2 day of the week (but probably less).

Might be worth posting this in the jobs section too.

LooneyTunes

9,516 posts

189 months

Friday 21st March 2014
quotequote all
motorsportbeng said:
I have no understanding of the finance industry currently but I basically see it as an opportunity to earn the big bucks, sufficient enough to fund my own motorsport adventures at the weekends. Obviously there is the inherent long hours, stressful working environment and dealing with some 'characters' but this doesn't sound much different to working in the UK Motorsport industry!
Depends what you mean by "finance industry", but you may find that setting up a career and having weekends (let alone ones that you'd still be alert enough to race on) prove to be mutually exclusive for a few years.

GrandSilva

3 posts

152 months

Sunday 23rd March 2014
quotequote all
I am in the position of graduating from a MSc in Motorsport Engineering, followed by an offer to work in finance (London), which I accepted and worked for around 2 years before I moved back into engineering. Yes, you can use your skills in finance, they appreciate the way you use maths into real problems. But my question for you is, do you really want to work 5 days out of 7 doing something just for money? what if you don't like it at all, do you think is worth doing it? I don't have an answer for you, but for me was something very challenging that I enjoyed doing it, as much as I enjoy doing engineering now.

Have a great weekend!

coetzeeh

2,894 posts

267 months

Monday 24th March 2014
quotequote all
I don't have experiece either but Eamonn O'Hare is probably the best example out there (Aerspace Engineer moved into Finance)

Formerly Tesco CFO before joining Virgin Media as CFO - recently moved on from V after 4 years with shares worth £45m.

marky1

1,094 posts

227 months

Monday 24th March 2014
quotequote all
Probably best to apply to some of the Investment Banks, especially if you think you'll get a 1st. Morgan Stanley, Goldman Sachs etc. You would need to come up with good reasons why you would want to work at these places though, because they will ask you and I'm not sure "for the money" will get you a job.

glm1977

200 posts

192 months

Wednesday 26th March 2014
quotequote all
i did engineering at uni and wanted to go into motor sport but wasn't able to and fell into Finance (city working at top tier IBs) - sure it pays the bills but boy does it destroy the soul. Would i swap some of the luxuries i can afford to be more mentally engaged at work - yes. But the grass is always greener.

If its purely money you want from a job, then the bonuses are not what they used to be for the average 'banker' unless you are Front Office or a Quant and even then it will be a good few years before you are far enough up the chain, you'll not be getting anything like the daily mail likes to report for a bonus. Basic pay will be good, but you'd be better off working for hedge fund to get 'decent' bonuses. Its all relative, of course.

Having worked a couple of places in the city with very clever and intelligent people from a variety of walks of life, one thing that is common, is that we all sit there when we have a free moment talking about how we would love to be doing something we enjoy away from banking. Not just saying that for the benefit of this thread, a lot of people do leave to try things out, but also a lot want to leave but are committed to needing the money and would not be able to just walk away (i.e. they need the money to serve the mortgages, support families etc... )

If you want to be rich enough to be able to do racing at the weekends, be the next Ross Brawn or Adrian Newey, they seem to do ok :-P

All the best with whatever path you choose!


Newc

2,197 posts

213 months

Thursday 27th March 2014
quotequote all
I do some guest lectures at one of the business schools. I'm part of the light relief program of external industry people whose stuff isn't examined. My main topic is "the stuff they don't tell you at the interview", and it describes the types of roles available to grads in the city, and the personality types that are likely to be successful in those roles.

I try to hammer home that although the gross comp looks better than 90% of other grad slots, the lifestyle for juniors is all consuming and the chances of you "doing a bit of quant during the week, then leaving early on Friday and going racing for the weekend" are zero.

Trading floor slots tend to be skewed to an earlier start and an earlier finish, though you as the junior will be staying behind to tidy up while the rest of the desk is in the pub.  Anything client facing will involve late night entertainment most nights of the week.  Banking and PE slots are really indentured servitude for the first three years and you will be spending nights sleeping in the office.

Weekends are for catching up on sleep, buying milk, and getting the laundry done.  Also, don't forget that to be able to live the dream like this you will have to be based in the centre of town.  A gentle commute in from the South Downs is not viable, and a lot of that high gross salary goes right out the door on cost of living.

Having said that, if you are very good then you can have amassed enough seniority to control your diary and be generating enough cash to fund your hobbies after about 10 years.  But you will still be subject to drop-everything-and-get-the-next-flight interruptions and if you are only averagely good you will make a very comfortable but not outrageous living.  The marzipan layer is relatively thick and the icing on top is relatively thin.

I don't want to put you off, I just want you to be aware of the realities.  Much of the work is intellectually fascinating and the opportunities for good people come much earlier than all other career routes.

I'll leave you with a PH anecdote from my first boss, when I was a grad trainee on a trading desk.  Him: "I'll be in late tomorrow, got to drop the car in for a service"  Me, knowing he had a Ferrari and being a chippy git: "oh no, no Fezza, how on earth will you manage the commute ?"  Him:"I'll use my other Ferrari".

AyBee

11,363 posts

233 months

Thursday 27th March 2014
quotequote all
What he said ^^^! Engineering grad and ended up in the city myself. Salary is better than all my mates who went into engineering, but not amazing in the scheme of things, and I also work close to double the hours they do. I can't plan anything for weekday nights because I'll invariably have to cancel and weekends are spent sleeping, doing laundry and food shopping. I enjoy it at least so it's not all bad but 3 years in and I have the moments of wondering what else I could be doing and whether I'll regret it if I get tied into large mortgages, school fees etc and find I have no way out.

You don't really sound like it's something you'd consider doing if it wasn't for the money so I'd probably advise against it.

NightDriver

1,082 posts

257 months

Friday 28th March 2014
quotequote all
Stay in engineering, we need ambitious graduates!!

Seriously, I've always been in the auto side of the industry it has really taken off in the last few years. If your happy to travel a bit (a lot) and up for some hard work then you can do well. I've got a couple of uni mates who went down the finance route, one is doing well at an investment bank (no idea what he does, but hes very switched on) but the other is not doing as well and is trying to plan a move bank to engineering, which unfortunately is not as easy as he hoped!

Lazygraduate

1,790 posts

192 months

Friday 28th March 2014
quotequote all
Going into the city for the money ONLY is a sure fire way to end up really, really hating your job.

Be careful!

"Probably best to apply to some of the Investment Banks, especially if you think you'll get a 1st. Morgan Stanley, Goldman Sachs etc. You would need to come up with good reasons why you would want to work at these places though, because they will ask you and I'm not sure "for the money" will get you a job.
"

Without valid work experience, you most likely won't stand a chance at either of the two places listed above. Which university are you at OP? Do you have any work experience? If not, suggest you get some as your journey will be almost impossible without (for a front office role anyway)

Edited by Lazygraduate on Friday 28th March 22:56

Panthro

781 posts

249 months

Wednesday 9th April 2014
quotequote all
A member of my family graduated in engineering and moved into finance. He told me a while ago that in order to get your foot in the door, the best thing is to first become a chartered accountant.
He started out with the investment banks and is now the CFO for a Dubai World subsidiary.