Which brand of radiator? ('06 Octavia)
Discussion
Chaps,
Quickie; my folks have an '06 Octavia TDi. I think it's the 2.0 version. The radiator has sprung a leak and they have been quoted 'a bit more than £300' to fix it by their local dealer.
I'm going down to see them in a couple of weeks and tinkering with cars is something my dad and I always used to enjoy, and hence I am thinking that replacing the radiator on their car is something that we could have a bit of fun doing. The question is which radiator to buy? Carparts4less (i.e. Euro Car Parts) lists five at hugely varying prices;
Hella - £156
Valeo - £111
Denso - £96
EIS - £88
EIS - £52
(Prices are rounded to the nearest quid.)
I recognise the first three brands mentioned. Which one would you choose? The car is something they are likely to keep for the next 10 years or more, so we're happy to pay for quality. Which one is likely to be OE? (Is OE-quality worth going for, given that the existing one has lasted all of 8 years and about 75k miles?)
Thanks,
Oli.
Quickie; my folks have an '06 Octavia TDi. I think it's the 2.0 version. The radiator has sprung a leak and they have been quoted 'a bit more than £300' to fix it by their local dealer.
I'm going down to see them in a couple of weeks and tinkering with cars is something my dad and I always used to enjoy, and hence I am thinking that replacing the radiator on their car is something that we could have a bit of fun doing. The question is which radiator to buy? Carparts4less (i.e. Euro Car Parts) lists five at hugely varying prices;
Hella - £156
Valeo - £111
Denso - £96
EIS - £88
EIS - £52
(Prices are rounded to the nearest quid.)
I recognise the first three brands mentioned. Which one would you choose? The car is something they are likely to keep for the next 10 years or more, so we're happy to pay for quality. Which one is likely to be OE? (Is OE-quality worth going for, given that the existing one has lasted all of 8 years and about 75k miles?)
Thanks,
Oli.
If you must buy a new rad, then I would go with the first 3 brands mentioned.
However, rads can be easily and cheaply fixed - providing they're relatively new-ish with no rust or other damage.
I've successfully and permanently repaired a few rads with Chemical Metal - and the repair has never failed. Depends on the overall condition of the rad as I said, and where the damage itself is and how bad. For me, it's always been a hole in a single horizontal slat - and repairing involves removing any paint, roughing up the surface on and around the hole, and squashing a big blob of Chemical Metal onto the hole - a lump about the size of a 2p piece is normally sufficient.
Actually, I've even race-tested a Chemical Metal repair. When I raced bikes, I used to buy a new bike every couple of seasons. I would run them in on the road before stripping them down for race prep / tuning.
One time I bought a new one, I went off out to start running it in, and a car in front flicked up a few stones. One went through the rad
I got the bike home, and removed the rad, thinking I would do a Chemical Metal repair for now to carry on running the bike in, and then get a new rad for the racing seasons coming up.
However, I repaired the rad as said, and it then kinda got overlooked. I then went on to race the bike for 3 years / seasons around most tacks in Britain, with it still wearing the original Chemical Metal repair on the rad.
It never failed, and in fact I sold it on with the repair still in place!
It's good stuff is that - and in my experience, lasts perfectly!
However, rads can be easily and cheaply fixed - providing they're relatively new-ish with no rust or other damage.
I've successfully and permanently repaired a few rads with Chemical Metal - and the repair has never failed. Depends on the overall condition of the rad as I said, and where the damage itself is and how bad. For me, it's always been a hole in a single horizontal slat - and repairing involves removing any paint, roughing up the surface on and around the hole, and squashing a big blob of Chemical Metal onto the hole - a lump about the size of a 2p piece is normally sufficient.
Actually, I've even race-tested a Chemical Metal repair. When I raced bikes, I used to buy a new bike every couple of seasons. I would run them in on the road before stripping them down for race prep / tuning.
One time I bought a new one, I went off out to start running it in, and a car in front flicked up a few stones. One went through the rad

I got the bike home, and removed the rad, thinking I would do a Chemical Metal repair for now to carry on running the bike in, and then get a new rad for the racing seasons coming up.
However, I repaired the rad as said, and it then kinda got overlooked. I then went on to race the bike for 3 years / seasons around most tacks in Britain, with it still wearing the original Chemical Metal repair on the rad.
It never failed, and in fact I sold it on with the repair still in place!
It's good stuff is that - and in my experience, lasts perfectly!
Chaps,
Bit of a delay - sorry - but thanks for the answers. I'm with you vxturbo, Valeo seems like a good choice. I wonder what you get for the more expensive Hella one (apart from possibly the same item in a different box.)
WhoMe - thanks, briskoda is a good idea.
Ray L-Y, good yarn! Given it's my folks' everyday waggon I'm not sure that that is such a good idea but some epoxy putty is a good thing to have in an emergency toolkit ... and I am moving the stick of the stuff I have from my workshop to the boot of my car on the strength of your post, thanks!
Oli.
Bit of a delay - sorry - but thanks for the answers. I'm with you vxturbo, Valeo seems like a good choice. I wonder what you get for the more expensive Hella one (apart from possibly the same item in a different box.)
WhoMe - thanks, briskoda is a good idea.
Ray L-Y, good yarn! Given it's my folks' everyday waggon I'm not sure that that is such a good idea but some epoxy putty is a good thing to have in an emergency toolkit ... and I am moving the stick of the stuff I have from my workshop to the boot of my car on the strength of your post, thanks!
Oli.
Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


