Landlord and lease problems!
Landlord and lease problems!
Author
Discussion

21TonyK

Original Poster:

13,398 posts

240 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
Few years back I bought a restaurant on the ground floor of a 3 storey high street building. under the terms of the lease my landlord regularly "recovers" 50% of the cost of general maintenance, roof repairs, gutter cleaning, painting soffits etc

All fairly minor stuff although its about £2K over the past few years but I accept that.

Now he is talking about re-rendering the whole front of the building from the first floor up!!

This is a grade 2* listed building, lime plaster, decorative frontage etc etc

Conservative estimate £50K!!

He wants to 1) scaffold the frontage for our main summer season which will destroy business and 2) expects me to pay 50% of the cost!!

Best bit is hes trying to squeeze this in before my lease expires in September this year.

So... where do i start checking this evening. I have the lease itself and TBH its all mumbo-jumbo.

Can get hold of a solicitor and the landlord wants to meet first thing to discuss.

What to do???!!

Gargamel

16,422 posts

292 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
Do you want to renew the lease ?

If not, then the answer is very simple. If you do want to stay there then it is a little more awkward.

Inevitably it really boils down to what is covered in the lease. What does it say about upkeep and maintenence. Who is in the other two floors, and what have they been paying. Sounds likely the Landlord hasn't been contributing anything, simply charging you 50% and the other two floors 50% ?

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
there will be no substitute for proper advice from a lawyer. When you bought the restaurant did someone review the lease with you?

If he wants to meet tomorrow I suppose you could start off by asking him why he thinks you are liable, and why he thinks it is reasonable to do the work at you busiest period?

I've signed some horrific leases in my time.

Simpo Two

93,081 posts

296 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
Offer him £25Ksworth of free dinners?

That way it will only cost you £5K or whatever the net cost is.

21TonyK

Original Poster:

13,398 posts

240 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
in all honesty i have been considering selling up but having ploughed best part of £100K into the place I cannot walk away.

i do however have the option of relocating to a building very, very near by which would be suitable with no ingoing at the moment.

Moving to this location would be fairly minimal disruption and virtually no loss of trade (its within direct sight of the existing location)

i would rather stay where i am but not if i am going to be liable for this sort of thing ongoing.




yes the lease was reviewed by a solicitor and parts by a barrister (when the 54 act was questioned) so i am assuming its watertight

But... to whos advantage!

any things i can look for in the lease, specific terms etc?

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
21TonyK said:
in all honesty i have been considering selling up but having ploughed best part of £100K into the place I cannot walk away.

i do however have the option of relocating to a building very, very near by which would be suitable with no ingoing at the moment.

Moving to this location would be fairly minimal disruption and virtually no loss of trade (its within direct sight of the existing location)

i would rather stay where i am but not if i am going to be liable for this sort of thing ongoing.




yes the lease was reviewed by a solicitor and parts by a barrister (when the 54 act was questioned) so i am assuming its watertight

But... to whos advantage!

any things i can look for in the lease, specific terms etc?
it really depends how it was drawn up - some are very difficult to follow. I'd be searching for words like repairs/maintenance and trying to decipher. Did you sign a PG?

Rude-boy

22,227 posts

264 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
Your conversation tomorrow needs to be very non committal and I would suggest with little input from you other than ‘I’ll get back to you’

Make notes immediately afterwards of the conversation and the plans.

Call your solicitor (although I am slightly intrigued as to why a barrister’s opinion on a S54LTA clause should be required...) and get them to set out in detail your position.

Pointless to advise anything else without sight of the Lease.

One thing I would mention is that if there is any chance of you moving out then you really need to speak to a solicitor and/or surveyor now about dilapidations (they will explain if you are already lost) as if the LL is this free with your money you could be in for a nasty surprise...

21TonyK

Original Poster:

13,398 posts

240 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
Rude-boy said:
Your conversation tomorrow needs to be very non committal and I would suggest with little input from you other than ‘I’ll get back to you’

Make notes immediately afterwards of the conversation and the plans.

Call your solicitor (although I am slightly intrigued as to why a barrister’s opinion on a S54LTA clause should be required...) and get them to set out in detail your position.

Pointless to advise anything else without sight of the Lease.

One thing I would mention is that if there is any chance of you moving out then you really need to speak to a solicitor and/or surveyor now about dilapidations (they will explain if you are already lost) as if the LL is this free with your money you could be in for a nasty surprise...
yeah, thought so. but.... if i go into bankruptcy I assume he will be chasing nothing with the new place under a limited company in someone elses name

really not trying to be devious but fk me if im getting shafted for rebuilding half a 300 year old building!

21TonyK

Original Poster:

13,398 posts

240 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
desolate said:
it really depends how it was drawn up - some are very difficult to follow. I'd be searching for words like repairs/maintenance and trying to decipher. Did you sign a PG?
PG= personal guarantee? if so no, i am a sole trader, not limited etc

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
21TonyK said:
PG= personal guarantee? if so no, i am a sole trader, not limited etc
OK - just to be boringly repetitive definitely take advice - plus it's probably not as easy to go bankrupt as you might think and from the looks of your posts the restaurant's a cracker.

Play calm and dumb in the morning and see if he will show his cards.


Rude-boy

22,227 posts

264 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
desolate said:
Play calm and dumb in the morning and see if he will show his cards.
yes

This is one of those times to appear more dopey than you are.

Cerbieherts

1,652 posts

172 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
If its a full repairing and insuring lease you could be responsible for the upkeep of the building, which could include roof, walls etc, depending on the agreements within the lease. If you leave you still may have to pay under a "delapidation" clause. IANAL, but have leased several commercial properties over the last 7 years. I had a chartered survey carried out last time so there weren't any nasty suprises in store!

Pit Pony

11,515 posts

152 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
21TonyK said:
desolate said:
it really depends how it was drawn up - some are very difficult to follow. I'd be searching for words like repairs/maintenance and trying to decipher. Did you sign a PG?
PG= personal guarantee? if so no, i am a sole trader, not limited etc
Surely if you are a sole trader, you've signed the contract yourself, and it makes you personally responsible ? If you were the MD of a ltd company, then you "might" be asked to make a PG, but if not then the ltd company is responsible, and you should pay yourself a massive pay increase, so that when they come calling for the 50% you can give them your now dead company.

Wacky Racer

41,412 posts

278 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
Many years ago, in the early seventies I leased a fairly large shop in Bournemouth, at the back was a FIVE story high metal fire escape, with very intricate ornate ironwork, and the lease stipulated it had to be hand painted black every three years, probably three weeks work, bit like painting the Forth bridge....biggrin

Fortunately I sold the (profitable) business after a couple of years, and someone else took on the lease, so this is why I advise anyone to go through ANY lease with a fine tooth comb, because once you have signed on the dotted line...........

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
Pit Pony said:
Surely if you are a sole trader, you've signed the contract yourself, and it makes you personally responsible ? If you were the MD of a ltd company, then you "might" be asked to make a PG, but if not then the ltd company is responsible, and you should pay yourself a massive pay increase, so that when they come calling for the 50% you can give them your now dead company.
and all the goodwill built up by the restaurant, and the equipment.

I think his point was he is trading as a sole trader so he is on the hook if the landlord can enforce.

21TonyK

Original Poster:

13,398 posts

240 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
Sounds like i play dumb (lol)

I can move premises for about £10K which is less than a years (difference/reduction) in rent on a new play assuming permission to sublet.

Looks like a very quiet meeting tomorrow.

The jiffle king

7,548 posts

289 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
I would keep quiet, but also find the time to ask questions like>
Why does it need doing now?
What would be the best timing?

Don't offer answers, just explore what he's getting at

Blib

48,366 posts

228 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
I can understand the LL wanting to do the re-render in the warmer, drier, summer months.

21TonyK

Original Poster:

13,398 posts

240 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
Blib said:
I can understand the LL wanting to do the re-render in the warmer, drier, summer months.
yeah me too. ive renovated a few old places to know that advantage of summer sun

unfortunately this is the only time businesses in the SW make any/enough money to see them through the winter

Pit Pony

11,515 posts

152 months

Tuesday 25th March 2014
quotequote all
desolate said:
Pit Pony said:
Surely if you are a sole trader, you've signed the contract yourself, and it makes you personally responsible ? If you were the MD of a ltd company, then you "might" be asked to make a PG, but if not then the ltd company is responsible, and you should pay yourself a massive pay increase, so that when they come calling for the 50% you can give them your now dead company.
and all the goodwill built up by the restaurant, and the equipment.

I think his point was he is trading as a sole trader so he is on the hook if the landlord can enforce.
That's what I thought. Best then to "sell" the equipment to a ltd company, and "lease" it back from them?