clutch fail - what choices do i have

clutch fail - what choices do i have

Author
Discussion

vcm

Original Poster:

72 posts

157 months

Thursday 27th March 2014
quotequote all
driving along today and noticed the occasional slight difficulty in engaging gear. blamed myself of course. anyway, within 10 miles,now in town + traffic, couldn't get any gears easily. stop at lights, start in gear etc, got home without too much fuss, but basically slave or fingers i would guess. will start investigations tomorrow. what choices do i have to replace unit, if need be. what have you used. what should i buy and where.any comments would be helpful. thank-you

....and, any ideas on cost?

Edited by vcm on Thursday 27th March 21:45

nawarne

3,126 posts

275 months

Friday 28th March 2014
quotequote all
Firstly, have you checked the master cylinder? I ask because mine failed in a similar manner - difficulty getting gears etc(55K miles 'ish) and my first thought was the clutch itself.

Believe you have 2 options now:
Firstly, replace original AP unit like for like. Think the kit is about £800.
Secondly, go for the Helix Autosport version offered by Racing Green. This is supposed to be cheaper and fully re-buildable....But it's only been on the market for a month or two, so not a known quantity.

Nick

vcm

Original Poster:

72 posts

157 months

Friday 28th March 2014
quotequote all
nick, thanks.
master cylinder levels good - so i guess it's the clutch. my concern was ap fails
that you read on these forums, and how to go better. but after searching through my
history, probably complete since day 1, (i'm 3rd owner) it's not had any clutch work before - and
now on 43.4k, which is good enough for a clutch in my opinion. so i think i'm off to powers, replace the lot, and might get it back on road for weekend. (i don't fancy trialing the helix on behalf of rg. i use the car any day, any weather, so would rather know what's in there)

Edited by vcm on Friday 28th March 11:42

Walford

2,259 posts

181 months

Friday 28th March 2014
quotequote all
nawarne said:
fully re-buildable...
I had a 1000 mile AP clutch covered in brake fluid, AP told me to chuck it, not sure why AP wont sell components but i don't see it as good PR

m4tti

5,479 posts

170 months

Friday 28th March 2014
quotequote all
Walford said:
I had a 1000 mile AP clutch covered in brake fluid, AP told me to chuck it, not sure why AP wont sell components but i don't see it as good PR
Because there is an exclusive agreement on the clutch packs and brake discs with TVR power...

vcm

Original Poster:

72 posts

157 months

Friday 28th March 2014
quotequote all
well, i've gone ap - having collected this pm. best i try and make some time to fit it.

Zippee

13,768 posts

249 months

Friday 28th March 2014
quotequote all
I'm having a Helix fitted at the moment to my 4.3 T350 so will report with initial findings shortly (along with gearbox rebuild and lightened flywheel). It's £750 inc VAT so a fair bit cheaper than the AP and providing it lives up to it's promise should be a decnet bit of kit, especially as it can be rebuilt rather than having to buy a whole new unit.

vcm

Original Poster:

72 posts

157 months

Friday 28th March 2014
quotequote all
will be interesting to see how it lasts. hopefully as well, if not better, than the ap.

330p4

668 posts

245 months

Sunday 30th March 2014
quotequote all
Surely this kind of exclusivity is against European anti competition legislation BMW were sued for this cost them a lot of money
Ian

330p4

668 posts

245 months

Sunday 30th March 2014
quotequote all
Surely this kind of exclusivity is against European anti competition legislation BMW were sued for this cost them a lot of money
Ian