Which A3 is right for me?
Author
Discussion

AudiSport

Original Poster:

1,499 posts

247 months

Saturday 29th March 2014
quotequote all
Hi team!

Well after 4 years of owning my B7 A4 Quattro it was time to move on - I fancied a change really and wanted to sell before I lost too much money. We have also sold our Qashquai (thank god!) and replaced it with an E60 520d which will be my wives car and double up as the family car at weekends.

I now need to buy myself a new car, and after flirting with VW Golfs I just miss the interior build of Audi's. So, I have narrowed it down to a 2004 - 2008 A3 5-Door Auto. My budget is up to £7600. Please get in touch if you have a nice one to sell!

I am confused on which engine to choose, and would love some input from you all on the below;

Quattro: I loved this on my A4, however to convinced I needed it much. It's a different system on the A3 - does it really add much benefit for real world driving?
DSG: Auto is a must, but does this suffer from the same multitronic issues?
3.2 Quattro: Some great deals to be had with this drivetrain, and I love the idea of a large NA silky engine for my 4-mile commute to work. But the road tax is going to hurt - and put of buyers again when I come to sell in a few years...
2.0T: Great engine, and loved this is my A4. How does it work with DSG? And how would the car feel after a Revo map and no Quattro?
2.0 TDI: Good residuals and economy, however will I see any benefit on 220 miles a month?

Thank you!

Dr G

16,009 posts

273 months

Saturday 29th March 2014
quotequote all
The 'best' engine to my mind in an A3 of that age is the 2.0T but if you want it paired with quattro and an auto box you'll need a newer car (you could have one or the other pre facelift).

Tax on a 3.2 not an issue pre 03.06

2.0 TDI better post facelift, the CR engine is much improved.

Revo with a 2.0 T front wheel drive is good fun but can get scrabbly if you're aggressive (particularly on wet or poor surfaces).

The S-Tronic box on these is generally very good, oil changes every 40k. Mechatronic issues are unusual.

AudiSport

Original Poster:

1,499 posts

247 months

Saturday 29th March 2014
quotequote all
Great input, as always Dr G. We're would you put your money?

Dr G

16,009 posts

273 months

Saturday 29th March 2014
quotequote all
MKV Golf GTI *runs for cover*

Something a bit like this would be nice:

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2014...

Sounds well maintained and has some nice upgrades.

I myself would hunt out Xenons and heated seats but the headlights are a rare option at this sort of age. A mildly modified 2.0t quattro is a really capable little all weather performance car. 17" wheels for me too, please.

AudiSport

Original Poster:

1,499 posts

247 months

Saturday 29th March 2014
quotequote all
Looks great, just 400 miles away from me in sunny Dorset!

The wheels can be original spec? They look like B7 S4 alloys?

AudiSport

Original Poster:

1,499 posts

247 months

Saturday 29th March 2014
quotequote all
Manual too... Really after DSG.

Dr G

16,009 posts

273 months

Saturday 29th March 2014
quotequote all
Sorry, in answer to 'what would I buy'.

Plenty of A3s for sale, just a game of balancing spec, maintenance, condition etc.

Have you considered a MKV GTI? That budget will buy a lovely one and they're a hoot to drive.

AudiSport

Original Poster:

1,499 posts

247 months

Saturday 29th March 2014
quotequote all
Yes, my previous car was a MK5 GTi. But the lack of traction up wet slip roads and drama caused by accelerating quickly out of junctions frustrated me, hence the A4 Quattro purchase.

I sat in a 2007 GTi yesterday and a 2008 A3 back to back, and the Audi is a much nicer place to sit by far. So A3 it is - just need to decide on 3.2 Quattro or 2.0T FWD...?

I would like to Revo, and it has to be DSG for me I'm afraid!

Edited by AudiSport on Saturday 29th March 16:44


Edited by AudiSport on Saturday 29th March 16:48

Dr G

16,009 posts

273 months

Sunday 30th March 2014
quotequote all
Why not decide on both? Means more cars will be available to look at so you can be more selective.

AudiSport

Original Poster:

1,499 posts

247 months

Sunday 30th March 2014
quotequote all
Dr G said:
Why not decide on both? Means more cars will be available to look at so you can be more selective.
Funnily enough, I'm doing just that. Finding a nice low tax band 3.2 is going to be difficult.. Let's see how long it is before I crack and just buy a 2.0T!

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Monday 31st March 2014
quotequote all
I really like my MKV GTI DSG, the transmission and engine suit each other perfectly. I think for day to day use its perfect whereas the 3.2 may sound nice but it will drink a lot. So I vote 2.0T but I disagree with your comments regarding interior as I think the Golf with some kit on it feels a bit more modern than the pre-facelift A3.

Overlord44

2 posts

151 months

Tuesday 1st April 2014
quotequote all
Hello there,

Im selling my 2006 A3 2.0 TDI, its a manual but its well within your budget and I'm in Poole so i thought i would give you a heads up. Its up on gumtree and audi sport at the mo and will be up on here soon. Its not exactly what your after, but feel free to ask any questions about a3s in general. They are great cars and I'm sure you will enjoy it when you get one.

AudiSport

Original Poster:

1,499 posts

247 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2014
quotequote all
Hi, as you say not really what I'm after, but please pm me details.. You never know!