Interested in a Monaro - advice required please!
Discussion
Hi guys,
I am looking into the possibility of purchasing a Monaro. I know they sound great, look great and are pretty much rare as rocking horse excrement, but was after a bit of advice as follows:
1. What are the real life running costs? MPG, servicing, tyres etc.
2. What is the difference between a Monaro and VXR?
3. Is the 6.0 worth spending the extra for over a 5.7?
I am based in Portsmouth, Hampshire. Not been able to test drive yet as nothing local, so trying to do some initial research.
Thanks all,
Paul
I am looking into the possibility of purchasing a Monaro. I know they sound great, look great and are pretty much rare as rocking horse excrement, but was after a bit of advice as follows:
1. What are the real life running costs? MPG, servicing, tyres etc.
2. What is the difference between a Monaro and VXR?

3. Is the 6.0 worth spending the extra for over a 5.7?
I am based in Portsmouth, Hampshire. Not been able to test drive yet as nothing local, so trying to do some initial research.
Thanks all,
Paul

Greetings Fellow Southantser 
Ok, Here's the Basics-ish
1. What are the real life running costs? MPG, servicing, tyres etc.
If you have to ask... , but seriously my Average MPG is 19 on a Good Run 26
Tyres 460 notes for a pair of Michelin Pilot Super Sport - Beware cheap tyres if they don't kill you first, you will probably regret penny pinching later.
Servicing isn't too bad - Take a look at Monkfish - they do 'takeaway style' service kits too.
Roadtax is 200 and sommet to 490
Insewerants - ask before you buy one, but can be gotten cheapish.
2. What is the difference between a Monaro and VXR? confused
Monaro (CV8) has a 5.7 lump (latter ones can Readily get to 6.0 power with very little work.) 18" Rims
Some Have big boots some don't
Confusingly Early VXRs had a 5.7 Lump.
3. Is the 6.0 worth spending the extra for over a 5.7?
If you want to Stop - then Yes
Don't blow ur entire budget on the car imho would suggest At Least 2k left over for remedials and mods. Some potential buyers pass up a higher tax car just cos it'll save money, Condition and service history should be higher on priority.
and Welcome to the Madhouse

Ok, Here's the Basics-ish
1. What are the real life running costs? MPG, servicing, tyres etc.
If you have to ask... , but seriously my Average MPG is 19 on a Good Run 26
Tyres 460 notes for a pair of Michelin Pilot Super Sport - Beware cheap tyres if they don't kill you first, you will probably regret penny pinching later.
Servicing isn't too bad - Take a look at Monkfish - they do 'takeaway style' service kits too.
Roadtax is 200 and sommet to 490
Insewerants - ask before you buy one, but can be gotten cheapish.
2. What is the difference between a Monaro and VXR? confused
Monaro (CV8) has a 5.7 lump (latter ones can Readily get to 6.0 power with very little work.) 18" Rims
Some Have big boots some don't
Confusingly Early VXRs had a 5.7 Lump.
3. Is the 6.0 worth spending the extra for over a 5.7?
If you want to Stop - then Yes
Don't blow ur entire budget on the car imho would suggest At Least 2k left over for remedials and mods. Some potential buyers pass up a higher tax car just cos it'll save money, Condition and service history should be higher on priority.
and Welcome to the Madhouse

PompeyPaul said:
Hi guys,
I am looking into the possibility of purchasing a Monaro. I know they sound great, look great and are pretty much rare as rocking horse excrement, but was after a bit of advice as follows:
1. What are the real life running costs? MPG, servicing, tyres etc.
2. What is the difference between a Monaro and VXR?
3. Is the 6.0 worth spending the extra for over a 5.7?
I am based in Portsmouth, Hampshire. Not been able to test drive yet as nothing local, so trying to do some initial research.
Thanks all,
Paul
Hi Paul,I am looking into the possibility of purchasing a Monaro. I know they sound great, look great and are pretty much rare as rocking horse excrement, but was after a bit of advice as follows:
1. What are the real life running costs? MPG, servicing, tyres etc.
2. What is the difference between a Monaro and VXR?

3. Is the 6.0 worth spending the extra for over a 5.7?
I am based in Portsmouth, Hampshire. Not been able to test drive yet as nothing local, so trying to do some initial research.
Thanks all,
Paul

Running costs are expensive if it's a daily runner..... Mine has been my daily driver for the last 2years and I would say £70 a week was roughly what I spent on fuel, from a full tank I can get a 400miles which is ok I guess.
Monkfish performance offer a service plan, the cost is on there website.
Tyres are as expensive as you want it to be.
5.7 is cheaper to tax, I pay around 225 for the year.
I've got a VX GTS so I think other members might be able to help with questions 2 & 3.
To be honest fella the best thing I ever done was get another car, I've got a little 1.2 corsa as my run around and get the beast out on sunny days.
Hope this helps
Riggz
Copied & pasted from the FAQ's, may help a little 
There are 5 variants of the Monaro.
04 CV8 - Standard Holden Monaro with Gen III LS1 5.7 V8
04 VXR - HSV take the above and tweek the brakes, power, suspension plus sportier looking
05 CV8 - As 04 but the boot space has been drastically reduced as the petrol tank was relocated to behind the rear seats to meet US safety regulations
05 VXR - Again, small boot, but now has the Chevvy Gen IV LS2 6.0 V8
One notable point is that it is well documented that the CV8 brakes (both 04 and 05) hare shockingly poor for the power of the car. The VXR has much better brakes but both versions can be further upgraded to High Performance Racing Brakes.
Oh, and finally, there's the VXR 500 - This is a special & limited edition of the 05 VXR with a Harrop Supercharger strapped to it... Very nice indeed

There are 5 variants of the Monaro.
04 CV8 - Standard Holden Monaro with Gen III LS1 5.7 V8
04 VXR - HSV take the above and tweek the brakes, power, suspension plus sportier looking
05 CV8 - As 04 but the boot space has been drastically reduced as the petrol tank was relocated to behind the rear seats to meet US safety regulations
05 VXR - Again, small boot, but now has the Chevvy Gen IV LS2 6.0 V8
One notable point is that it is well documented that the CV8 brakes (both 04 and 05) hare shockingly poor for the power of the car. The VXR has much better brakes but both versions can be further upgraded to High Performance Racing Brakes.
Oh, and finally, there's the VXR 500 - This is a special & limited edition of the 05 VXR with a Harrop Supercharger strapped to it... Very nice indeed
PompeyPaul said:
Hi guys,
I am looking into the possibility of purchasing a Monaro. I know they sound great, look great and are pretty much rare as rocking horse excrement, but was after a bit of advice as follows:
1. What are the real life running costs? MPG, servicing, tyres etc.
2. What is the difference between a Monaro and VXR?
3. Is the 6.0 worth spending the extra for over a 5.7?
I am based in Portsmouth, Hampshire. Not been able to test drive yet as nothing local, so trying to do some initial research.
Thanks all,
Paul
1 20 - 25 MPG depending on driving conditions (motorway, extra urban, town etc). Servicing is not unduly expensive, but some parts are much cheaper sourced from the USA (Pontiac GTO). body parts, trim etc is expensive.I am looking into the possibility of purchasing a Monaro. I know they sound great, look great and are pretty much rare as rocking horse excrement, but was after a bit of advice as follows:
1. What are the real life running costs? MPG, servicing, tyres etc.
2. What is the difference between a Monaro and VXR?

3. Is the 6.0 worth spending the extra for over a 5.7?
I am based in Portsmouth, Hampshire. Not been able to test drive yet as nothing local, so trying to do some initial research.
Thanks all,
Paul

2 Monaro is "cooking" model, VXR is Australian HSV with enhanced (though more expensive to support) cycle parts etc.
3 Yes, if only because UK CV8s all had over long gearing, the 6.0 has shorter gearing as well as the enhanced engine.
Here are some things to look out for, which my own car has suffered from at some point:
Brake judder, theory is pad material transfers onto disk rather than warpage.
Water ingress through poor fitting door membranes.
Alloy wheel corrosion – had them redone twice.
Paint flaking off door handles.
Power steering judder – both track rod ends replaced. After market ones didn't last.
Clutch easily cooked (slipped once else OK).
Tail light cluster mounting breakage .
One rear wheel bearing failed – noise and slop.
Rear brake lining broke off backing plates.
Heater intermittent no control, cold is cold but 17 - Hot is fully hot.
Squeaky idler pulleys.
Problems others report:
Intermittent problems with dials
Corrosion of some pipe work at front of car
Clutch easily cooked – pedal does not return then goes hard on pumping
Super charger belts can come off
Occasional piston problems, slap and can fail on super charged cars.
Spigot bearing failure – consequences for gearbox
Many cars have "mods" so check out any departures from standard and think carefully are they for you. Most modifications don't command a premium and some can even be a liability long term in increased consumable costs - e.g. AP brakes. Having said that most would agree shortening the gearing on CV8s is worthwhile and stock exhausts are fairly tame. Removing the middle boxes gives a cost effective compromise on quality and volume.
There are some very accomplished and knowledgeable people on the forum with many impressive engine projects. I'm dismayed at some of the cosmetic mods though and the only right hand drive (until we get the Mustang?) muscle car ever sold in the UK deserves better. As the Monaro approaches it's 10th Birthday we need to work together to preserve stock ones for future generations, so if you want lots of mods please buy one already modified.
4 Monaro variants were sold in the UK, 2004 VY CV8 5.7, 2004 VY VXR 5.7, 2005 VZ CV8 5.7 and 2005 VZ 6.0VXR. Greens did a special in combination with Wortec the supercharged VXR500. A conversion of the 6.0VXR. Key stats:

2004 VY cars have the larger boot but exhaust exits on the left only. 2005 VZ had duel exhausts, smaller boot, nostrils (not functional) on the bonnet. The most common and best car is the 6.0VXR which also had shorter gearing as well as the most power and torque.
Edited by granada203028 on Sunday 30th March 22:49
Running costs can be high but i run mine as a daily driver and yes its expensive but i'd say it is worth it.
The later post facelift cv8 have different bumpers and wheels and look rather nice too.
As said above the early vxr were 5.7. I have this model and although i initially wanted a 6.0 i'm very happy with mine. In fact i used to swap my cars a lot but this has been with me for a year now and will be for a while.
Tyres can be expensive the vxr run 19s as standard. Yes michelins are good but there are cheaper options without resorting to ditch finders.
The later post facelift cv8 have different bumpers and wheels and look rather nice too.
As said above the early vxr were 5.7. I have this model and although i initially wanted a 6.0 i'm very happy with mine. In fact i used to swap my cars a lot but this has been with me for a year now and will be for a while.
Tyres can be expensive the vxr run 19s as standard. Yes michelins are good but there are cheaper options without resorting to ditch finders.
I have a totally standard 04 CV8 - that's the 1st one, with the 5.7.
Downsides - brakes, for the power they are poo
Alloys, as someone else said they corrode and mine need a refurb
Mpg, mine is a daily and my pootle to and from work in rush hour = 14 mpg, cruising can= high 20s
Sound, the standard exhaust is very quiet.
Saying all that, she's a keeper and a lovely car to drive and in this guise quite a sleeper to the majority.
I have a habit of changing cars yearly and I'm coming up to a years ownership and am totally content
Downsides - brakes, for the power they are poo
Alloys, as someone else said they corrode and mine need a refurb
Mpg, mine is a daily and my pootle to and from work in rush hour = 14 mpg, cruising can= high 20s
Sound, the standard exhaust is very quiet.
Saying all that, she's a keeper and a lovely car to drive and in this guise quite a sleeper to the majority.
I have a habit of changing cars yearly and I'm coming up to a years ownership and am totally content

Gassing Station | HSV & Monaro | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff






