Car Rental - Excess Insurance?
Car Rental - Excess Insurance?
Author
Discussion

Biscuit dunker

Original Poster:

91 posts

160 months

Monday 31st March 2014
quotequote all
Sorry if this has been asked before but we're going to Madrid later this year and will need to hire a car but initial enquiries on what's available opens up a real can of worms regarding CDW Excess. There seems to be the potential for having a £500 - 1000 excess per claim (per scratch/dent??) taken from your credit card on return of the rental car!

I have looked into excess waiver insurance but this in some instances can be almost as much as the hire of the car!

There also seems to be companies (eg iCarhireinsurance.com) that provide excess waiver insurance separate to the hire companies.

Anyone any experience of these insurance waiver companies or can anyone suggest a car rental company with sensible insurance excesses?

MarkK

667 posts

310 months

Monday 31st March 2014
quotequote all
Free bump as I'm interested in this too. Seems like annual cover is available for about £40 but not sure which company to go for.

Phil.

5,952 posts

281 months

Monday 31st March 2014
quotequote all
I've used icarinsurance for the past couple of years but haven't need to claim yet. Less than £40 pa to cover multiple trips to Europe. Far less than buying excess cover from a car hire co. The worst case is I have to pay out the excess and the reclaim it later.

Beware, some hire car co.'s want a deposit of several hundred Euro's if you don't take out their excess cover. It's normally repaid a week or so after returning but you can get caught by a few quid if exchange rates change (you could also make a few quid).

BigAl77

102 posts

193 months

Monday 31st March 2014
quotequote all
I've used I car insurance.com (small cash back through quidco), never had to use it but would hope it does what it says.

rcspeirs

181 posts

245 months

Tuesday 1st April 2014
quotequote all
The excess amount is a maximum. If it's an excess of €800 and you were unfortunate enough to suffer two dents, it would be one charge.
All rental companies across Europe are strict on damage, so it's essential that you thoroughly check the car damage sheet (listing pre existing damage) before you drive away. If you see any scratch, however minor, insist that it is added to the damage sheet.
While all rental companies are strict, I've never had problems with Avis and Hertz. A quick search on a well known advisory site for trips will give you clues on the names to avoid.
I have annual excess insurance through American Express (many alternatives are available) and it works well. You need to appreciate that if you do have a prang, your credit card will be charged, and you'll reclaim the amount off your insurance provider. When you collect the car, your card is not charged, but a "hold" for the excess amount is placed, which reduces your available credit by that amount.

Birdster

2,548 posts

174 months

Sunday 13th April 2014
quotequote all
Also wondering about this. I travel to the Republic Of Ireland two, or three times a year and normally pay the £12(?) a day excess over a weekend. I'm on first name terms with the lady on the Avis desk as it's small airport and she's always there.

With the roads I frequent being quite narrow and the brushing of hedges quite common it just makes it simple as they don't even check the car when you hand it back. I suspect if I didn't pay the CDW upfront that they'd be more thorough.

This leads me to the same question as the OP, has anyone first hand experience of using these companies? I suspect if I went somewhere less likely to result in surface scratches I'd benefit and save money in the process. However I may be traveling to Ireland more so the cost will rise and I'm thinking of taking this option instead. If however it's a hassle to claim and not always successful then it's probably not worth it.

pmanson

13,388 posts

284 months

Sunday 13th April 2014
quotequote all
Birdster said:
Also wondering about this. I travel to the Republic Of Ireland two, or three times a year and normally pay the £12(?) a day excess over a weekend. I'm on first name terms with the lady on the Avis desk as it's small airport and she's always there.

With the roads I frequent being quite narrow and the brushing of hedges quite common it just makes it simple as they don't even check the car when you hand it back. I suspect if I didn't pay the CDW upfront that they'd be more thorough.

This leads me to the same question as the OP, has anyone first hand experience of using these companies? I suspect if I went somewhere less likely to result in surface scratches I'd benefit and save money in the process. However I may be traveling to Ireland more so the cost will rise and I'm thinking of taking this option instead. If however it's a hassle to claim and not always successful then it's probably not worth it.
Sign up to Avis Preferred. I think three rentals a year entitles you to a free weekend rental.

The sign up process online is slightly painful but worth persevering

indigostr

384 posts

157 months

Monday 14th April 2014
quotequote all
I've also been using iCarhireinsurance.com for the last 2 years , I clicked through topcashback last year and paid £28 for Europe cover. Really pisses the desk people off but it's the same insurance they're trying to flog you. If you google reviews of them they are rated highly ,I was skeptical before using but on my last trip alone I saved 400euros (bloke next to me added on his insurance at 100euros for a week). It also covers all named drivers on the rental agreement as long as the main renter is the policy holder. Just read the terms and conditions which are straight forward such as report accidents to police etc..same as you would with the rental company policy.