Poor economy !
Author
Discussion

motorheadman

Original Poster:

108 posts

207 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2014
quotequote all
Morning all,

I’ve got a 2002 VW Golf MK4 GT TDi (130 BHP) which has been amazing in the last four years until last summer. I’ve owned it from 119k miles and I’ve now taken it up to 193k miles but it still drives superb except one problem – the fuel economy. I had been averaging 55mpg with ease for four years and could do 63 mpg on the run to work if I drove conservatively. But last summer I had a new cambelt fitted and immediately afterwards the consumption dropped to 47 – 49mpg ish. No matter what I did I couldn’t get it above 50mpg. I’ve had the tracking done, the tyre pressures are perfect and I’ve had a new engine undertray fitted as the old one was hanging down and I thought it could be affecting the aerodynamics but it's no better. The exhaust doesn’t leak either so it’s not that either. I’ve had a word with the guy who done the cambelt and he said it won’t affect the economy but suggested it could be the Mass Air Flow sensor. I’m very sceptical as the car was fine before the cambelt change.

Has anyone else suffered a similar problem? Any ideas what it could be?

Cheers in advance...

MHM

aka_kerrly

12,506 posts

241 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2014
quotequote all
Rather than guess why not get the car run on VAGCOM diagnostics , this will highlight any faulty sensors or stray readings.

It is entirely possible that the MAF is playing up and needs a clean or if you are dead convinced the economy issue is linked to the new timing belt then it is possible for the timing to be 1 tooth out which will influence how the engine performs. The only way to check is to turn the engine by hand to line up the timing marks.


Adrian E

3,368 posts

207 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2014
quotequote all
Are the injectors OK and is it generally running OK?

Friend had one of these with a failing injector which eventually bore-washed the cylinder to the point it caused a major mechanical failure - at that sort of mileage it's potentially quite a few things but as above until you've gone through a fault identifying process people can only guess/offer an opinion on the likely cause.

decadent

2,572 posts

206 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2014
quotequote all
I had a MAF sensor issue on mine that caused a similar issue with fuel consumption.

Try cleaning it with electrical contact spray. Should fine your economy shoots back to previous levels but it will decline again as the cleaner wears off. In my circumstance a replacement MAF cured it.

My next step would have been a VAGCOM had it not solved the issue.

Matt


Dr G

16,009 posts

273 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2014
quotequote all
Belt a tooth out certainly wouldn't help.

With those miles on it could simply be badly gunked up:


aceparts

3,724 posts

272 months

Thursday 3rd April 2014
quotequote all
The cambelt is a tooth out. If it was fine before and not afterwards then that's all it can be. Been there.

Rich_W

12,548 posts

243 months

Thursday 3rd April 2014
quotequote all
If the belt is a tooth out. Indicates that they didn't do the job properly in more than just 1 way. There's a locking tool for the crank and a pin that goes into the cam pulley. (IIRC it's only 1 pulley on these engines) Then you loosen the 3 13mm bolts on that to help get the tension on the belt correct.

For it to be out means they "probably" just tipexed the pulley and crank and then set it back up to those. So you may find the belt is not tensioned properly either.

motorheadman

Original Poster:

108 posts

207 months

Monday 7th April 2014
quotequote all
aceparts said:
The cambelt is a tooth out. If it was fine before and not afterwards then that's all it can be. Been there.
Did you car run ok though, even if it was one tooth out? The mechanic at the garage reckoned it can't be as it would smoke really badly if it was a tooth out either side. What did your economy drop to when you suffered this?

MHM