Discussion
My car has suffered DPF complete blockage also the turbo actuator failed which I'v had replaced. I decided to get the DPF removed and software put on the car instead of paying near 2k for new one. Since taking it to a garage, they say they opened the ECU up to upload the software, but it was fried (there is a burn mark and strong smell of it). Is it possible for the car to fry its ECU?
What car is this? Any car new enough to have a DPF will also be new enough that you do not need to physically open the ECU to reprogramme it - this is all done via the diagnostics port so strictly speaking there is no need to even physically touch the ECU at all.
Sounds like garage has cocked up big time if you took them a running car with a DPF issue and now they are telling you they have removed the DPF but your ECU is dead.
Sounds like garage has cocked up big time if you took them a running car with a DPF issue and now they are telling you they have removed the DPF but your ECU is dead.
It's a 2.0tdi Golf 2009 (140bhp) I thought that you could do it all via the diagnostics port, but he said you can't on the Golf? Anyone know if this is true?
I personally don't believe a word they are saying and believe they have foobard it trying to upload the map. The garage is supposedly a specialist at DPF removals and *Motor Diagnostics* in Birmingham.
I personally don't believe a word they are saying and believe they have foobard it trying to upload the map. The garage is supposedly a specialist at DPF removals and *Motor Diagnostics* in Birmingham.
2009 you say, that puts you right on the edge of having one of two types of ECU, the pre 2009 can certainly be accessed via the OBD2 port and have information uploaded/downloaded.
There is a later type of ECU on 2009> Siemens I believe which is a bit harder to complete remove the DPF software as VW changed the regeneration process but it can be done and I still don't believe it requires the ECU to be opened up.
There is a later type of ECU on 2009> Siemens I believe which is a bit harder to complete remove the DPF software as VW changed the regeneration process but it can be done and I still don't believe it requires the ECU to be opened up.
jackjackjack said:
My car has suffered DPF complete blockage also the turbo actuator failed which I'v had replaced. I decided to get the DPF removed and software put on the car instead of paying near 2k for new one. Since taking it to a garage, they say they opened the ECU up to upload the software, but it was fried (there is a burn mark and strong smell of it). Is it possible for the car to fry its ECU?
DPF removal = MOT fail btw You could have removed the DPF and had it cleaned by DPF genie. It is an MOT fail at the moment (if they can tell) but it'd be cheaper to get it cleaned
than the ECU messed about with etc.
It's very unlikely it was fried before they had a go at it - it had to be working to go into limp home mode. Send it to somebody competent for repair.
than the ECU messed about with etc.
It's very unlikely it was fried before they had a go at it - it had to be working to go into limp home mode. Send it to somebody competent for repair.
jackjackjack said:
There no guarantees with getting dpf removed and cleaned, will only block again.
Im trying to findout which ecus are compatible with my car, currently looking for one which all number match.
If you're constantly blocking your DPF. Then you have the wrong car for your needs. Removing it is a bodge. You probably need a petrol instead.Im trying to findout which ecus are compatible with my car, currently looking for one which all number match.
Rich_W said:
If you're constantly blocking your DPF. Then you have the wrong car for your needs. Removing it is a bodge. You probably need a petrol instead.
I expect some people will argue against that but I see it as a very valid point. How much is this DPF removal an remap costing, £500? You could travel 2500 miles on £500 worth of petrol in a car averaging 30mpg
jackjackjack said:
The car travels 25k a year minimum, at least 200 miles on motorway and always give it a good run.
Im trying to find out which number need to match on the new ecu so i can get it mapped.
If you're genuinely doing that mileage with long runs. It's not the DPF that's at fault. It's something else. Perhaps the pressure sensor is knackered. Perhaps you have a leaking injector.Im trying to find out which number need to match on the new ecu so i can get it mapped.
No its definatly dpf, the light is on and i have had it vag-com by two diffrent garages. The turbo actuator was recently replaced also.
I dropped the car of at end of day so tbey could start work next morning, they said that when they went to start car it would not start and they tried jumping it. Could they have damaged it by trying to jump start ut? I can't see gow the battery went flat also?
May start looking into my legal rights or just take the hit on the ecu.
I dropped the car of at end of day so tbey could start work next morning, they said that when they went to start car it would not start and they tried jumping it. Could they have damaged it by trying to jump start ut? I can't see gow the battery went flat also?
May start looking into my legal rights or just take the hit on the ecu.
jackjackjack said:
No its definatly dpf, the light is on and i have had it vag-com by two diffrent garages...
Without knowing exactly what the garage(s) have done simply reading off fault codes is not a diagnostic and is absolutely no guarantee of correctly identifying a fault.The ECU can only tell you what it sees is wrong, it cannot tell you what caused it.
Dr G said:
jackjackjack said:
No its definatly dpf, the light is on and i have had it vag-com by two diffrent garages...
Without knowing exactly what the garage(s) have done simply reading off fault codes is not a diagnostic and is absolutely no guarantee of correctly identifying a fault.The ECU can only tell you what it sees is wrong, it cannot tell you what caused it.
Dr G might be able to confirm but wasn't there a software patch relating to the DPF regeneration process and how frequently it occurs?
jackjackjack said:
No its definatly dpf, the light is on and i have had it vag-com by two diffrent garages. The turbo actuator was recently replaced also.
I dropped the car of at end of day so tbey could start work next morning, they said that when they went to start car it would not start and they tried jumping it. Could they have damaged it by trying to jump start ut? I can't see gow the battery went flat also?
May start looking into my legal rights or just take the hit on the ecu.
I have to think that this place you take your car don't sound very good. You've had no probs with the battery. All of a sudden it's flat? Now the ECU is potentially buggered? For them to say DPF is knackered AND the Turbo Actuator failed (which is generally rare on the later cars) sounds like they are guessing a bit too much for my liking.I dropped the car of at end of day so tbey could start work next morning, they said that when they went to start car it would not start and they tried jumping it. Could they have damaged it by trying to jump start ut? I can't see gow the battery went flat also?
May start looking into my legal rights or just take the hit on the ecu.
Also are they trying to force regen the thing when it's overfull of ash? There's a limit to what's sensible before risk of fire/damage. have they made the situation worse? Have the examined the possibility of another factor to the failing? Are they showing you the core of the DPf or just guessing. Did they fit the right DPf the first time round or a cheapo pattern one?
Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


