VW golf Mk5 steering rack fault
VW golf Mk5 steering rack fault
Author
Discussion

turnleftwhere

Original Poster:

164 posts

250 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2014
quotequote all
Hi all - I've got some play in the steering of my 57 plate mk5 2.0 tdi golf, which also comes with an audible knocking noise when turned from left to right and back again. It has been diagnosed as a faulty rack to be replaced which my independant specialist has given two options; The first being a geniune VW part at over £700, or an aftermarket pattern rack from AMK at around £200.

My reason for posting is to gauge opinion over whether I should spend the extra on a genuine VW part, or save around £500 by opting for the pattern part? Spending the extra isn't a major issue, but I'm wondering if it would be money well spent, or not.

Thank you in advance for any input.

Rich_W

12,548 posts

243 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2014
quotequote all
2 years warranty on the VAG part. Which if it fails means you get the work carried out by VAG for free.

Does the cheapo version do that?

turnleftwhere

Original Poster:

164 posts

250 months

Wednesday 2nd April 2014
quotequote all
Very good point, just looked it up and the AMK rack is covered by a 1 year warranty compared to the 2 year warranty of the VAG part, as you say. I imagine the second year will be the one that makes the difference.

supersport

4,646 posts

258 months

Thursday 3rd April 2014
quotequote all
You would hope that a new VW rack would last way more than 2 years and so the 2nd year would be meaningless. I would reasonable expect that as with many things, they either work or not. If they are going to give up it would more than likely be within the first year.

Generally you also only get what you pay for, and cheap parts are more likely to crap out the minute the warranty runs out.