Invest £8-10k on Edition 30 or buy new R/S3/B8S4/E92M3/RS6
Invest £8-10k on Edition 30 or buy new R/S3/B8S4/E92M3/RS6
Author
Discussion

Msportman

Original Poster:

313 posts

187 months

Thursday 3rd April 2014
quotequote all
Dilema:

Sell my GTI Engineering Stage 1 Edition 30 which so I have invested in KW Clubsports, H&R Spacers White Line Anti Lift Kiit, and Kenwood DNX Sat Nav and DAB roof mount.

Car is a mint black 3 door manual car with just 49k.

Or:

Invest a shed load and get to stage 2+ mainly for road and some track action. This will mean the following:
APR Stage 2+
APR HFP
APR RSC Exhaust
VWR Intake
Helix Clutch
Diff..Quaiffe or Wavetrack
Runner Flap Delete
H&R ARB (Rear)
VWR Big Brake Kit
APR FMIC
Wheels for Track
Dunlop Direzza Tyres (Similar to D01J)
OE Cruise Fitment

Approx £10k+ added up......dead money when it comes to re sell but will make the car pretty special.I hate the thought of losing a shed load down the road and perhaps keeping as it is is the more sensible approach.

Power will be approx 360bhp and more than enough for FWD. I have had a similar package before and got most of money back although I didn't have a big brake kit, clutch or diff.
As a road car it's more discrete than an RS and IMO more punchy than a heavy car. I don't know how good an S4 will be in comparison but the cost to mod it for track will be a fair few quid...brakes, MRC stage 2 to 450+ KW's, bigger cooler kit, the list goes on.....probably another £10k worth of bits.


M3 is a contender although the better spec Competion Pack cars are all £33k+...GTR money!

I always liked the RS4 but am told by tuners that I would get bored quickly as they are all (V8RS4) under power due to coking issues and the 4wd dulls the feeling of speed. I haven't tried one but APS tell me many are sub 380 bhp and in a heavy 4wd car will feel somewhat sluggish compared to the Ed 30.

Or do I turn my attention to the new R or S3 with view to map it and get similar 350+ when available. Certainly 4wd interests me not for track but for everyday useability.


Certainly C63 is out of the question as I hate the box and interior.

I'd like a GTR but it's not in budget at mo but my missus is interested in the new SQ5 and getting one on a PCP as there are some sharp deals around.

I have a mk2 16V as a sorted track car for honing around although I know the Edition could be made into a real track animal with big investment like most cars. It's rare to impossible to find a car that does everything as they are all compromised.

Ah what would you do ??

martin mrt

3,885 posts

232 months

Thursday 3rd April 2014
quotequote all
Financial suicide buying an E92 at the moment, the new M3/4 is due next month and will hit prices hard I'd imagine.


rb5er

11,657 posts

203 months

Thursday 3rd April 2014
quotequote all
Msportman said:
Ah what would you do ??
Buy an evo IX fq360

It will actually hold its money too.

cheddar

4,637 posts

205 months

Thursday 3rd April 2014
quotequote all
Msportman said:
Dilema: It's rare to impossible to find a car that does everything as they are all compromised.

Ah what would you do ??
Don't fettle the Golf any further it'll be a an ever diminishing bhp/fun/£ return and you'll still get bored, move on.

Same with the Golf R etc, accomplished 4 pot hatches with big depreciation and future boredom beckoning.

You've obviously got around 30k to spend so sell the ED30 and get an M3, a DCT equipped one, never mind the Performance Pack (unless you can afford it) save your money and do your own fettling over time as funds allow, you obviously like it.

Have you driven one? I did recently and expected a bloated lumpy V8 that was all torque and boredom - It absolutely knocked my socks off! The engine and DCT gearbox are masterpieces and that's coming from a died in the wool manual man who gets bored with auto's before leaving the driveway, don't think of that gearbox as an auto, try one.

It wasn't so much the speed of the M3 your Golf is probably as quick, but, let's be honest, 414bhp is quite enough thankyou - it's the delivery and juxtaposition between cultured silent cruiser and ballistic 8000+rpm screamer. The noise, oh the noise! 6000rpm sounded like 8000, 8000 sounded like the world was about to end.

The last of the N/A M cars and a future classic, do your best man maths, It'll blow you away.



Edited by cheddar on Thursday 3rd April 21:58

Msportman

Original Poster:

313 posts

187 months

Thursday 3rd April 2014
quotequote all
cheddar said:
Don't fettle the Golf any further it'll be a an ever diminishing bhp/fun/£ return and you'll still get bored, move on.

Same with the Golf R etc, accomplished 4 pot hatches with big depreciation and future boredom beckoning.

You've obviously got around 30k to spend so sell the ED30 and get an M3, a DCT equipped one, never mind the Performance Pack (unless you can afford it) save your money and do your own fettling over time as funds allow, you obviously like it.

Have you driven one? I did recently and expected a bloated lumpy V8 that was all torque and boredom - It absolutely knocked my socks off! The engine and DCT gearbox are masterpieces and that's coming from a died in the wool manual man who gets bored with auto's before leaving the driveway, don't think of that gearbox as an auto, try one.

It wasn't so much the speed of the M3 your Golf is probably as quick, but, let's be honest, 414bhp is quite enough thankyou - it's the delivery and juxtaposition between cultured silent cruiser and ballistic 8000+rpm screamer. The noise, oh the noise! 6000rpm sounded like 8000, 8000 sounded like the world was about to end.

The last of the N/A M cars and a future classic, do your best man maths, It'll blow you away.



Edited by cheddar on Thursday 3rd April 21:58
I have briefly had a go in a manual car last year. It was good....very good the chassis and the noise were pretty epic. But after getting back into my lowly Golf I found the lure of low end torque of the turbo made the performance more accessible for most of the time. I have made my Golf pretty useable and stable for road and track but could go alot further....but at what expense. It is mostly a boredom thing I suppose why I want to change and finding a big step as a road and track weapon is holy grail.....within budget!

I like the M3 saloon TBH....it look more aggressive....cool IMO.

Another contender is a 911 turbo or a C4S.

Have seen the Cupra R vid....very interesting....but it's no step on from what I have got....thought the R would have done better....quite subjective though.

S4 looks promising....worried it may suffer from big Audi understeer...although it can be driven around.


Edited by Msportman on Thursday 3rd April 22:37

cheddar

4,637 posts

205 months

Thursday 3rd April 2014
quotequote all
Msportman said:
I have briefly had a go in a manual car last year. It was good....very good the chassis and the noise were pretty epic. But after getting back into my lowly Golf I found the lure of low end torque of the turbo made the performance more accessible for most of the time.


Edited by Msportman on Thursday 3rd April 22:37
I implore you, try the DCT, completely overcomes any notion of lack of torque with it's instant quadruple, rev blipped downshifts.

Check some you tube vids of manual vs DCT first and you'll see what I mean.

Msportman

Original Poster:

313 posts

187 months

Thursday 3rd April 2014
quotequote all
cheddar said:
I implore you, try the DCT, completely overcomes any notion of lack of torque with it's instant quadruple, rev blipped downshifts.

Check some you tube vids of manual vs DCT first and you'll see what I mean.
Will do...I'm in no rush at mo.

Thinking RS4 may have been a contender until you weigh up power defficiency and 4wd sapping power....M3 is much quicker on track.....needs a good brake set up though...AP's?

graeme4130

3,956 posts

212 months

Friday 4th April 2014
quotequote all
Msportman said:
cheddar said:
I implore you, try the DCT, completely overcomes any notion of lack of torque with it's instant quadruple, rev blipped downshifts.

Check some you tube vids of manual vs DCT first and you'll see what I mean.
Will do...I'm in no rush at mo.

Thinking RS4 may have been a contender until you weigh up power defficiency and 4wd sapping power....M3 is much quicker on track.....needs a good brake set up though...AP's?
I agree, try dct, is genuinely very good
Would disagree about b7 RS4 vs e92 m3 on track. It would be pretty similar in terms of pace (although m3 would be much more fun), but on the open road the rs4 would leave it in most circumstances

cheddar

4,637 posts

205 months

Friday 4th April 2014
quotequote all
graeme4130 said:
Msportman said:
cheddar said:
I implore you, try the DCT, completely overcomes any notion of lack of torque with it's instant quadruple, rev blipped downshifts.

Check some you tube vids of manual vs DCT first and you'll see what I mean.
Will do...I'm in no rush at mo.

Thinking RS4 may have been a contender until you weigh up power defficiency and 4wd sapping power....M3 is much quicker on track.....needs a good brake set up though...AP's?
I agree, try dct, is genuinely very good
Would disagree about b7 RS4 vs e92 m3 on track. It would be pretty similar in terms of pace (although m3 would be much more fun), but on the open road the rs4 would leave it in most circumstances
If you just want to go quickly on track you buy an Evo or STI and throw some money at it, for £££/lap times nothing beats them.

If you want a beautifully appointed, exotic engined car that will cruise in silence, absorb bumps and sooth you before setting your arse on fire then buy an M3.

It's not how quick it is it's how it goes quick that matters.......

Msportman

Original Poster:

313 posts

187 months

Friday 4th April 2014
quotequote all
Saw this today:

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2014...

Overpriced??

It's been serviced all of it's life at Taunton Audi....in superb condition....needs a proper detail......money well spent??

Benefit from a full Miltek exhaust....the noise is epic....very very tempted.

Need another 12k to change from my Edition 30 for an older car but one that won't drop like a stone I suppose. It's a great spec if not the Avant but rare to find one with this mileage.

Could be a keeper?

Edited by Msportman on Friday 4th April 21:13

Murph7355

42,079 posts

287 months

Friday 4th April 2014
quotequote all
Msportman said:
Saw this today:

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2014...

Overpriced??

It's been serviced all of it's life at Taunton Audi....in superb condition....needs a proper detail......money well spent??

Benefit from a full Miltek exhaust....the noise is epic....very very tempted.

Need another 12k to change from my Edition 30 for an older car but one that won't drop like a stone I suppose. It's a great spec if not the Avant but rare to find one with this mileage.

Could be a keeper?

Edited by Msportman on Friday 4th April 21:13
Probably high on price BUT it all depends on the history and condition, and what work has been done recently. Service items can be expensive (discs and pads, clutch, DRC etc) so the car would need to be in absolute top nick and be known not to have issues with the big ticket items to warrant that price.

IMO try to find an RS4 that has recently been rolling road verified as healthy on the power front (400+bhp). Then go and test drive it. On the road they are lovely places to be and very quick cars. They're not track toys IMO. Too heavy and too expensive to run to waste that way. Power deficiencies are straight forward to address at known costs, so I wouldn't let that put you off - just buy wisely.

As an every day car, the only other in your list I'd consider would be the B8 S4. BMWs are hopeless in bad winter weather and where I live that's important.

As others have noted, I definitely would not chuck more money at the Golf.

Msportman

Original Poster:

313 posts

187 months

Friday 4th April 2014
quotequote all
Murph7355 said:
Probably high on price BUT it all depends on the history and condition, and what work has been done recently. Service items can be expensive (discs and pads, clutch, DRC etc) so the car would need to be in absolute top nick and be known not to have issues with the big ticket items to warrant that price.

IMO try to find an RS4 that has recently been rolling road verified as healthy on the power front (400+bhp). Then go and test drive it. On the road they are lovely places to be and very quick cars. They're not track toys IMO. Too heavy and too expensive to run to waste that way. Power deficiencies are straight forward to address at known costs, so I wouldn't let that put you off - just buy wisely.

As an every day car, the only other in your list I'd consider would be the B8 S4. BMWs are hopeless in bad winter weather and where I live that's important.

As others have noted, I definitely would not chuck more money at the Golf.
Thanks Murph.

I found this little baby in London:

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2014...

I agree on the power front...I have friends who run APS who have stated they rarely come close to 380 bhp let alone 414bhp due to coking inlet. I know MRC do the decoke for approx £1000. I want to do some track work and that's why coming out of a 310bhp+ hot hatch will be all new running a heavy V8 out front....I assume slow in fast out approach to track days. Evo's are too extreme for everyday and I already have a track dedicated car.....although I it's a holy grail finding a nice road car and track beast....don't think they exist in certain budgets.

RS6 is too heavy but ballistic in a straight line....too heavy and expensive for track. For that reason a good FWD with a diff is a great package...The Edition ticks many boxes...although spending more is a personal thing making it into a more focused car while making it civilised. TTRS is out of budget but the heavier car's like the M3 are looking much cheaper right now.

Edited by Msportman on Friday 4th April 23:02


Edited by Msportman on Friday 4th April 23:07

p1tse

1,412 posts

223 months

Friday 4th April 2014
quotequote all
What do you use the car for?

Personally I wouldn't dump that cash on a golf

Save the money towards what you really want the gtr if its in sight
Keep the ed30 as is or sell and buy cars if that budget and try a whole load of other things

I wouldn't listen to rs4 being boring. Maybe it is, but why not try it out for 6-12 months then move on.
335i went passed me te other day sounded brutal more so than I expected so another option, as I see you like the bigger Bhp stuff.
Or lighter and more nimble

The Stiglet

2,063 posts

225 months

Saturday 5th April 2014
quotequote all
Msportman said:
Another contender is a 911 turbo


Edited by Msportman on Thursday 3rd April 22:37
yes

g7jhp

7,035 posts

269 months

Saturday 5th April 2014
quotequote all
I'd get a 996 turbo.....oh I did (X50)! biggrin

davehRS4

23 posts

154 months

Saturday 5th April 2014
quotequote all
Just get an rs4 and get it de-coked if it needs it. Sounds like that's the car you really want.

graeme4130

3,956 posts

212 months

Sunday 6th April 2014
quotequote all
g7jhp said:
I'd get a 996 turbo.....oh I did (X50)! biggrin
As awesome a car as the X50 996 is, it's not really the track car the OP's apparently looking for. My experiences of driving 996 and 997.1/2 Turbo's on track is that's it's crushingly fast (capable of being one of the fastest cars at most track days), but you tend to just link the straight line speed up by guessing your way around adhesion limits and understeer in the corners
Does the OP's budget reach to an early 996 GT3 ?

FWIW, as much as I'm a massive Audi RS fan, an E90 M3 is a way better track car for driver involvement and fun

graeme4130

3,956 posts

212 months

Sunday 6th April 2014
quotequote all
g7jhp said:
I'd get a 996 turbo.....oh I did (X50)! biggrin
As awesome a car as the X50 996 is, it's not really the track car the OP's apparently looking for. My experiences of driving 996 and 997.1/2 Turbo's on track is that's it's crushingly fast (capable of being one of the fastest cars at most track days), but you tend to just link the straight line speed up by guessing your way around adhesion limits and understeer in the corners
Does the OP's budget reach to an early 996 GT3 ?

FWIW, as much as I'm a massive Audi RS fan, an E90 M3 is a way better track car for driver involvement and fun

Murph7355

42,079 posts

287 months

Sunday 6th April 2014
quotequote all
Msportman said:
...although I it's a holy grail finding a nice road car and track beast....don't think they exist in certain budgets....
They don't exist at any price point IMO as the two uses have mutually exclusive requirements. So it comes down to what you want to compromise if you intend to use one car for both purposes...

Ref the RS4, I think vacuum issues are more usually the cause of big drops in power than coking...Fortunately the car I bought has neither issue and runs the full amount of horses it should do smile Cross country when the weather cannot be guaranteed it's the fastest car I've owned, and supremely enjoyable with it. They look and sound great and the interior's a nice play to be - very well thought out generally with only a few minor niggles.