Suitable car for back pain?
Suitable car for back pain?
Author
Discussion

Joolzyk

Original Poster:

1 posts

149 months

Sunday 6th April 2014
quotequote all
Our 7 year old smax needs to be replaced. I have 2 main criteria:
As we live on a slight hill, I need to be able to get home in the bad weather - winter tyres on the smax has not made this possible
I need a car that is comfortable for my bad lower back - preferably I need to sit with my hips higher than my knees and kmy nees at 90 degrees to the floor. I seem to think that a 'tall car' (SUV type vehicle makes this more possible???
Space for 2 kids important
I enjoy driving and picked the smax because at the time it was the most interesting of the family cars to drive, but its quite boring! We do c. 12k miles pa in this car. I'm keen to minimise depreciation costs so plan to buy second hand, at a point where the worst of the depreciation has been hit. I have 25k to spend and am considering an infiniti FX, X5, Merc ML. Any advice on comfort gratefully received. Many thanks

matthias73

2,901 posts

179 months

Sunday 6th April 2014
quotequote all
When you say slight hill, do you mean you live halfway up Snowdon?


I was in an X5 not too long ago and seemed quite comfortable, but the ride was a bit bumpy. Get smaller alloys and fat tyres regardless of your choice!

Impasse

15,099 posts

270 months

Sunday 6th April 2014
quotequote all
2002-2005 Range Rover Vogue. It's imperative for comfort you have an earlier car as the multi adjustable seats were deleted during the facelift.

Highway Star

3,615 posts

260 months

Sunday 6th April 2014
quotequote all
Joolzyk said:
Our 7 year old smax needs to be replaced. I have 2 main criteria:
As we live on a slight hill, I need to be able to get home in the bad weather - winter tyres on the smax has not made this possible
I need a car that is comfortable for my bad lower back - preferably I need to sit with my hips higher than my knees and kmy nees at 90 degrees to the floor. I seem to think that a 'tall car' (SUV type vehicle makes this more possible???
Space for 2 kids important
I enjoy driving and picked the smax because at the time it was the most interesting of the family cars to drive, but its quite boring! We do c. 12k miles pa in this car. I'm keen to minimise depreciation costs so plan to buy second hand, at a point where the worst of the depreciation has been hit. I have 25k to spend and am considering an infiniti FX, X5, Merc ML. Any advice on comfort gratefully received. Many thanks
You live on a slight hill in the South East and winter tyres on a SMax don't cut it?

Volvos are supposed to have good seats, perhaps try an XC90?

stupidbutkeen

1,025 posts

184 months

Sunday 6th April 2014
quotequote all
get a mx5, Take the driverseat out,Replace with a bar stool. jobs jobebed


On the other hand, I hear nothing but good from my aunt who has a volvo xc90 and a bad back.

Zedboy1200

884 posts

240 months

Sunday 6th April 2014
quotequote all
Something Scandinavian - no brainer. Personally recommend XC-60

Zedboy1200

884 posts

240 months

Sunday 6th April 2014
quotequote all
Something Scandinavian - no brainer. Personally recommend XC-60

davepoth

29,395 posts

228 months

Monday 7th April 2014
quotequote all
And remember, whichever car you choose, get the smallest wheels available. It makes a big difference to the ride.

ChemicalChaos

10,712 posts

189 months

Monday 7th April 2014
quotequote all
I'd be going left-field and looking at something American here in order to satisfy your ride quality needs.

A Chevy Blazer 4wd is about the size of an Audi Q5, has squish-matic yank suspension, a 4.0 V6 and they were sold over here with RHD.
If you fancy something bigger, then the Chevy Suburban was also sold over here in RHD and crops up on ebay occasionally...... if you can find somewhere to park one!

Tammyj

36 posts

151 months

Monday 7th April 2014
quotequote all
The Swede's are your friend here

Volvo seats were designed with the help of orthopaedic surgeons, and I personally love the them.

Seats in a Volvo S60 helped my mums Sciatica pain tremendously, and the XC90 seats work wonders on mine when I get achey.

Word of warning though, I wouldn't recommend the R-Design trim, the seats are OK. Slightly firmer (some prefer this) and have more support at the side presumably for a more sporty feel. They are comfortable when the car is still, but the stiffer suspension soon starts to interfere with the overall comfort and you won't be as impressed. But generally speaking, even the entry level trim seats are fantastically comfortable.

If you was looking for something brand new, you can get and XC90 on a VERY VERY GOOD deal at the moment! Over £10k off the OTR price can easily be had.


Edited by Tammyj on Monday 7th April 03:00

rejn

2,020 posts

251 months

Monday 7th April 2014
quotequote all
A few years ago I found a Subaru Legacy has a surprisingly comfortable seat - and I'm sure its drivetrain would help you get up the hill!

Podie

46,649 posts

304 months

Monday 7th April 2014
quotequote all
The Volvos have the best seats out there.


kambites

71,459 posts

250 months

Monday 7th April 2014
quotequote all
Another vote for something with a Volvo badge on the grill - they really do produce very supportive seats. Avoid sports suspension or big wheels so the ride is decent and I don't think you'll do much better.

Superhoop

4,909 posts

222 months

Monday 7th April 2014
quotequote all
Try a Mazda CX-5. Even a fully loaded car is within your budget, and will give you an electric drivers seat with infinite levels of adjustment, and a fully adjustable steering column (reach and rake) which is also an important part of the puzzle when it comes to getting comfortable and minimising/eliminating back pain.

flatso

1,364 posts

158 months

Monday 7th April 2014
quotequote all
What you need is a SUV-/ Van-type ride height (angle between hips and legs), with a Citroen Hydropneumatik suspension, a Subaru 4WD system and a powerful motor.

Only one choice that combines these attributes:

Merc R-Class!

rodericb

8,865 posts

155 months

Monday 7th April 2014
quotequote all
flatso said:
Merc R-Class!
Intriguing car that. V8 powered all wheel drive people moverish type of thing. It'd have to be the V8.

geeks

11,618 posts

168 months

Monday 7th April 2014
quotequote all
Heated seats, they do wonders for my back, I have something called Scheuermann's Disease (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scheuermann%27s_disease) mine is mild and wasn't picked up untill very recently after alot of hounding of my GP (but that is a seperate story) if i have had a bad day with it when i get in the car to drive home from work the heated seats really do make a huge difference, i take the long way home with them on sometimes just for the pain releif. Sadly can't afford an XC-90 but if i could i would have one for the reasons mentioned above, easily the most comfortable car i have ever sat in and good on my back, my requirements were similar to yours but my budget was 4% of what you have, but an XC-90 is on the cards next year

J8 SVG

1,470 posts

159 months

Monday 7th April 2014
quotequote all
My dad has the same problem and found the seats and driving position in his XC60 brilliant for it - 6 hours down to Kent being stuck on the M25 for 4 of those and he gets out absolutely fine!

Pistachio

1,116 posts

219 months

Monday 7th April 2014
quotequote all

Volvo Seats

mwstewart

8,553 posts

217 months

Wednesday 9th April 2014
quotequote all
Don't forget you could add a Recaro Orthopaed to a vehicle with less than ideal OEM seats https://www.recaro-automotive.com/en/product-areas...