What do I need to know to help my son
What do I need to know to help my son
Author
Discussion

silvagod

Original Poster:

1,086 posts

191 months

Wednesday 9th April 2014
quotequote all
As my own business is doing well at the moment and my son has been made redundant, I am proposing to fund him to start his own business. The market place he is going into is buoyant and there is plenty scope for doing well. He is a hard worker and I don't have any doubt that he will try his hardest to make it work.

My questions are...

1. Should I lend him the money and accept a regular repayment schedule after a given amount of time providing his business is successful?
2. Should I be a shareholder and take whatever that gives as a return on my investment?
3. Do I need to declare this investment on my self assessment and if so, what does it come under?
4. In the event it fails, can I put the loss of money against my self assessment?

There's no question about helping, I'm just looking for the best way to give him a start and not lumber myself too much trouble if it works. If it doesn't, I can stand the loss of money but can I recoup some via the system (another business making a loss for example)

I should also add that due to certain circumstances of my own a few years ago, I can't be a director of the business for at least 18 months.

Any advice would be most welcome.

Jockman

18,414 posts

191 months

Wednesday 9th April 2014
quotequote all
Shareholder route and you only need to declare any income or gains AFAIK.

Pretty sure you can offset losses against gains (take advice on this) but I'd rather make a profit and just pay the tax smile

silvagod

Original Poster:

1,086 posts

191 months

Wednesday 9th April 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for your input.

That's the route I'm leaning towards and I too would rather pay the tax for success!

Simpo Two

93,078 posts

296 months

Wednesday 9th April 2014
quotequote all
Is there any need for limited companies and directors and shareholders and tax? Can't you just give him a personal loan, with repayment terms in writing? Or gift him £3K as an early Christmas present?

silvagod

Original Poster:

1,086 posts

191 months

Wednesday 9th April 2014
quotequote all
Simpo Two said:
Is there any need for limited companies and directors and shareholders and tax? Can't you just give him a personal loan, with repayment terms in writing? Or gift him £3K as an early Christmas present?
That's a very good point and this has been discussed. It's £8k and not £3k so that makes a small difference. I don't really want to tie him or me into any legal agreements because, as stated, I can stand the loss and I have confidence in him being a success (what dad doesn't)

I am more leaning towards wanting to put him on the correct path as a business owner though and not someone who's dad lent him some money (and if I can save tax along the way too, well that's a bonus!)

silvagod

Original Poster:

1,086 posts

191 months

Wednesday 9th April 2014
quotequote all
O/T but just wondering....why is there a huge blank space below my last sentence in my last post?...it means people have to scroll unnecessarily.

insurance_jon

4,099 posts

277 months

Thursday 10th April 2014
quotequote all
ph have served an advert next to it with poor formatting

Johnniem

2,758 posts

254 months

Thursday 10th April 2014
quotequote all
Treat it as a business investment (as stated above re taxes etc) and agree that, once the business is self perpetuating, the lad repays the loan (in installments if necessary, at nil interest). This way he see's the need for management of loans, the consequences of having a business partner who requires income from his investment (you always have the option to allow your son to keep the profit that he should pay you as a shareholder) and general business acumen. Hell, if his business takes off you may wish to join him and let your own go. Now there's a thought!

I wish you both luck with the new venture.

silvagod

Original Poster:

1,086 posts

191 months

Thursday 10th April 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for the help guys. Discussions are ongoing smile

happychap

545 posts

179 months

Thursday 10th April 2014
quotequote all
It's an interesting question that you pose. My son has just asked me to lend him £200 and he would pay me back in instalments. At first I agreed to lend him the money, then after considering it I told him he didn't have to pay it back and it was gift. My point being, I know the amounts are significantly different, but the good feeling it gave me to help him out without any expectation of the money being return was fantastic. A father helping his son out is a great feeling, if you can afford the money as a gift I would highly recommend it.

Obiwonkeyblokey

5,400 posts

271 months

Thursday 10th April 2014
quotequote all
as much as I agree with the sentiment, the benefit to the son of "having" to make profit to repay Dad can be quite a motivator. You can always buy him something further down the line when the Business floats for a few billion.

Pot Bellied Fool

2,264 posts

268 months

Thursday 10th April 2014
quotequote all
How old is he? Less than 30?

Maybe see if you can get him on the Princes Trust Entering Enterprise Scheme. A 4 day course covering the fundamentals of running a biz and then continued support from a business mentor (all free) and they'll help stress test the plan before he launches - and that's often better coming from strangers than his Dad.

Pit Pony

11,515 posts

152 months

Thursday 10th April 2014
quotequote all
I would have my ltd company buy 49% of the shares in his company, and have him sell the ltd company his 'IDEA' in exchange for 49% of the shares in the company.

Then I would get his Godfather, or a distant uncle to buy the other 2% of the shares.

Then I'd make him work out the minimum he could afford to live on.

And tell him that as soon as he makes a profit, he will be paid 2/3rd of that as salary.

If you do any work, you expect payment as NMW on PAYE

Obviously the 1/3rd is retained in the business to help it grow, until YOU retire, and then you expect all 3 of you to get start getting a dividend.

That's what I've told my 2 kids. If they have a good idea and they can convince me that it holds water, I'd be only 2 happy to fund it.

happychap

545 posts

179 months

Thursday 10th April 2014
quotequote all
Obiwonkeyblokey said:
as much as I agree with the sentiment, the benefit to the son of "having" to make profit to repay Dad can be quite a motivator. You can always buy him something further down the line when the Business floats for a few billion.
I take your point and at some level I agree. However, speaking as father sometimes just giving your child a gift with no expectations or strings can be liberating for both you and your child. The op already believes his son will make good use of the money.

silvagod

Original Poster:

1,086 posts

191 months

Friday 11th April 2014
quotequote all
happychap said:
Obiwonkeyblokey said:
as much as I agree with the sentiment, the benefit to the son of "having" to make profit to repay Dad can be quite a motivator. You can always buy him something further down the line when the Business floats for a few billion.
I take your point and at some level I agree. However, speaking as father sometimes just giving your child a gift with no expectations or strings can be liberating for both you and your child. The op already believes his son will make good use of the money.
Interesting points, however, one reason for me wanting a part of the business is so there is some obligation for him work to. I could gift it to him, indeed I have done to a lesser degree in the past (not for business, just to help out) I think it will be better for him business wise if there is some sort of payback.

silvagod

Original Poster:

1,086 posts

191 months

Friday 11th April 2014
quotequote all
Pot Bellied Fool said:
How old is he? Less than 30?

Maybe see if you can get him on the Princes Trust Entering Enterprise Scheme. A 4 day course covering the fundamentals of running a biz and then continued support from a business mentor (all free) and they'll help stress test the plan before he launches - and that's often better coming from strangers than his Dad.
He's 26 so that would be an option. I've never heard of that. I'll look into it, thanks.

silvagod

Original Poster:

1,086 posts

191 months

Friday 11th April 2014
quotequote all
Pit Pony said:
I would have my ltd company buy 49% of the shares in his company, and have him sell the ltd company his 'IDEA' in exchange for 49% of the shares in the company.

Then I would get his Godfather, or a distant uncle to buy the other 2% of the shares.

Then I'd make him work out the minimum he could afford to live on.

And tell him that as soon as he makes a profit, he will be paid 2/3rd of that as salary.

If you do any work, you expect payment as NMW on PAYE

Obviously the 1/3rd is retained in the business to help it grow, until YOU retire, and then you expect all 3 of you to get start getting a dividend.

That's what I've told my 2 kids. If they have a good idea and they can convince me that it holds water, I'd be only 2 happy to fund it.
Good points, that is the sort of agreement we have been discussing, it's not an easy decision doing the right thing!

happychap

545 posts

179 months

Friday 11th April 2014
quotequote all
silvagod said:
Good points, that is the sort of agreement we have been discussing, it's not an easy decision doing the right thing!
Out of interest, what do you consider the 'rigth thing' are you thinking as a father or buisness man. Not being a buisness man myself I'm looking at this from a fathers view point.

Engineer1

10,486 posts

240 months

Friday 11th April 2014
quotequote all
silvagod said:
Pot Bellied Fool said:
How old is he? Less than 30?

Maybe see if you can get him on the Princes Trust Entering Enterprise Scheme. A 4 day course covering the fundamentals of running a biz and then continued support from a business mentor (all free) and they'll help stress test the plan before he launches - and that's often better coming from strangers than his Dad.
He's 26 so that would be an option. I've never heard of that. I'll look into it, thanks.
Get him on some form of a course as it is as much about learning how to run a business book keeping etc as networking there will be someone there who can help in some way buiness cards, photos for the website or similar.

sanguinary

1,598 posts

242 months

Friday 11th April 2014
quotequote all
I would consider setting up a Ltd company with you owning 49 or 50 % of the shares, in return for the loan. So you then get a share of any dividends if the business does well. What you do with the cash is up to you... but it gives your son some responsibility to his company shareholder.

Once the loan is paid back, pass your shares over to him. That way he has something tangible to work for, ie 100% control of his business.

Again, the loan repayments that come back to you could well be given back to your son after date, if you so wish.