Multiple business corporation tax question
Multiple business corporation tax question
Author
Discussion

blindswelledrat

Original Poster:

25,257 posts

263 months

Thursday 10th April 2014
quotequote all
If I owned a car dealership and decided to set up a motorcycle dealership as a separate business would I have to treat them as one business and combine the profits for corporation tax purposes or could I treat them as a separate entity?

Does this vary according to how closely related the business types are?

Thanks

Eric Mc

125,920 posts

296 months

Thursday 10th April 2014
quotequote all
It depends on how you structure your business.

Corporation Tax follows the same principles for Income Tax when it trading, tax profits (and losses) are being worked out.

In essence, if an entity carries out two or more distinct and separate trading activities, then the profits or losses arising from those activities need to be returned separately for tax purposes.

However, if the trading activities are inseparable, then there is no need to distinguish between the two.

Sometimes, determining whether slightly different activities within one entity are distinct and separate is not easy - and ity can lead to disputes between the taxpayer and HMRC.

A few years ago there was a tax case where a fish and chip shop owner was trying to prove that two separate fish and chip shops he owned were all part of one and the same business. HMRC argue that they were two separate trades - even though they were of the same trading nature. HMRC won that one.

These distinctions tend to become an issue when there are trading losses being generated and the taxpayer is keen to offset the losses from one activity against the other profits of another.


blindswelledrat

Original Poster:

25,257 posts

263 months

Thursday 10th April 2014
quotequote all
Thanks Eric.
Can you expand on "same entity"?

Using my analogy above: If I owned the car dealership and it made £250k profit and I set up the motorcycle dealership and it made the same profit, what would be the likely result of the corporation tax question?

Eric Mc

125,920 posts

296 months

Thursday 10th April 2014
quotequote all
blindswelledrat said:
Thanks Eric.
Can you expand on "same entity"?

Using my analogy above: If I owned the car dealership and it made £250k profit and I set up the motorcycle dealership and it made the same profit, what would be the likely result of the corporation tax question?
"Entity" refers to the actual "vehicle" through which the business is conducted.

If you were running a business as a sole trader. the "entity" would be the "sole trader".

If you are running a business through a limited company, then the "entity" is the limited company.

If you are running a business through a partnership, then the "entity" is the partnership.

You are probably using the term "I" far too loosely. If "you" personally owned a car dealership and made a profit of £250,000, you would personally have to pay a lot of Income Tax and NI on that profit.

If you ran a car dealership through a separate limited company, then that company would pay Corporation Tax on that profit.
If you also ran a motorcycle dealership through the same company and it also made a profit of £250,000, then the company would pay Corporation Tax on combined profits of £500,000.

At the moment, a company pays higher Corporation Tax rates on profits over £300,000. However, these higher rates of CT are being reduced and at some point the rate of 20% will be standard for all profits irrespective of the level of profit.

Per HMRC -

Main rate of Corporation Tax

From 1 April 2015 the small profits rate will be unified with the main rate, so there will be only one Corporation Tax rate for non-ring fence profits - set at 20%.

blindswelledrat

Original Poster:

25,257 posts

263 months

Thursday 10th April 2014
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
From 1 April 2015 the small profits rate will be unified with the main rate, so there will be only one Corporation Tax rate for non-ring fence profits - set at 20%.
Ah, interesting - then the question could be obsolete.
I realise from your answer how terribly described my analogy was now.
I meant same director but two separate limited companies.

Alpinestars

13,954 posts

275 months

Thursday 10th April 2014
quotequote all
Not sure what your concern is?

If they are both run through companies, depending on whether they are in a group (one owns the other, or are under a common parent company), or not in a group, will determine some of the tax implications.

In a group, loses of one can be offset against profits of the other. Both will have their small companies profit threshold reduced by 1/2 or 1/3 depending on which structure above you have.

If they are not in a group, they cannot offset profits and losses, but the small company threshold will still be reduced by 1/2.

If you are running the businesses as a sole trader, you will aggregate profits and losses in your personal tax return.

Eric Mc

125,920 posts

296 months

Thursday 10th April 2014
quotequote all
The permutations are endless.

The OP's concerns seemed to center on how large profits are taxed - especially if they become large when the trading activities are combined - rather than usability of losses.

As of 1 April 2015 large profits will not be an issue as no matter how large the profits are, the overall CT rate will be a basic 20%.

At the moment, having to combine profits which then push the company over the £300,000 small profits threshold can work out quite expensive, especially on those profits which fall between £300,000 and £1.5 million where the marginal rate works out even higher than the "Higher Profits" rate.


blindswelledrat

Original Poster:

25,257 posts

263 months

Thursday 10th April 2014
quotequote all
Alpinestars said:
If they are not in a group, they cannot offset profits and losses, but the small company threshold will still be reduced by 1/2.
Ah, this is what I was getting at. So if a director/shareholder owns two completely unrelated limited companies then both of them have the small company threshold reduced.
Does this apply even if he has different co-shareholders in each of the companies?
Seems a bit unfair

Eric Mc

125,920 posts

296 months

Thursday 10th April 2014
quotequote all
blindswelledrat said:
Ah, this is what I was getting at. So if a director/shareholder owns two completely unrelated limited companies then both of them have the small company threshold reduced.
Does this apply even if he has different co-shareholders in each of the companies?
Seems a bit unfair
NO!!!!!!!!!!

HMRC are wise to this and have a concept called "Associated Companies". An associated company is a company which shares common ownership, management or permutations of both. They know that some people might try to set up multiple companies to try and get below the £300,000 limits. So the associated company legislation was brought in to prevent this.

The very fact that a director/shareholder owns/manages another company, by definition, means they can't be "completely unrelated".

As I said, this will largely be of academic impact after 1 April 2015.

blindswelledrat

Original Poster:

25,257 posts

263 months

Thursday 10th April 2014
quotequote all
GOod stuff and thanks Eric.

Although it's not important/absolete I am still a bit puzzled over this and want to labour the conversation on the current rules.
I always understood it as your described and completely understand the reason for it, but didn't believe it could be that black and white.
Say, for example, I own a Ltd company accountant practice and my wife wants to start a ltd company florist with me as a partner/director- would the florist really have to pay the 30% ct?

Alpinestars

13,954 posts

275 months

Thursday 10th April 2014
quotequote all
blindswelledrat said:
Ah, this is what I was getting at. So if a director/shareholder owns two completely unrelated limited companies then both of them have the small company threshold reduced.
Does this apply even if he has different co-shareholders in each of the companies?
Seems a bit unfair
Yes the reduction can apply, and probably will apply unless the ownership of each company is widely held.

Alpinestars

13,954 posts

275 months

Thursday 10th April 2014
quotequote all
blindswelledrat said:
GOod stuff and thanks Eric.

Although it's not important/absolete I am still a bit puzzled over this and want to labour the conversation on the current rules.
I always understood it as your described and completely understand the reason for it, but didn't believe it could be that black and white.
Say, for example, I own a Ltd company accountant practice and my wife wants to start a ltd company florist with me as a partner/director- would the florist really have to pay the 30% ct?
No. Firstly CT is no longer 30 PC. It's nearly as low as 20. Second, you only fall into the higher rate if the profits of each business are sufficiently high to breach the small companies' threshold. In your example, that threshold would be divided by 2.

In any case as Eric says the rates are converging so it's somewhat academic.

Jockman

18,414 posts

191 months

Thursday 10th April 2014
quotequote all
blindswelledrat said:
GOod stuff and thanks Eric.

Although it's not important/absolete I am still a bit puzzled over this and want to labour the conversation on the current rules.
I always understood it as your described and completely understand the reason for it, but didn't believe it could be that black and white.
Say, for example, I own a Ltd company accountant practice and my wife wants to start a ltd company florist with me as a partner/director- would the florist really have to pay the 30% ct?
If the Florist's biggest customer was the Accountancy firm then you would definitely be in trouble yes

If the Florist was renting an office space from the Accountant then it can get messy.

Essentially, the further the arms length transaction / association the stronger you can argue your point.

I had a coffin making company and a veneering company, the former in Merseyside, the latter in Hull. No income was derived from the latter and my share was held through a legal firm. No issues.

I join the companies under the same roof in Merseyside....HMRC views them as Associated and I lost the £300k limit on the veneering company frown

blindswelledrat

Original Poster:

25,257 posts

263 months

Thursday 10th April 2014
quotequote all
Thanks everyone.
Pretty clear and a bit harsh I think but it wont matter soon

Eric Mc

125,920 posts

296 months

Thursday 10th April 2014
quotequote all
Yes - it's like walking a tightrope. One slip and they will get you.

Good job these overly complex and rather esoteric rules are becoming irrelevant - not before time.

blindswelledrat

Original Poster:

25,257 posts

263 months

Thursday 10th April 2014
quotequote all
I didn't realise that the middle rates had come down so much over the past 6 years anyway. It was 30% last time I looked!

Alpinestars

13,954 posts

275 months

Thursday 10th April 2014
quotequote all
Jockman said:
Essentially, the further the arms length transaction / association the stronger you can argue your point.
(
Not true. These rules have nothing to do with interdependency. If I own 2 completely independent companies, they are caught. There's the obvious question of will HMRC pick it up? But you'd then be into the realms of evasion.

Jockman

18,414 posts

191 months

Thursday 10th April 2014
quotequote all
Alpinestars said:
Not true. These rules have nothing to do with interdependency. If I own 2 completely independent companies, they are caught. There's the obvious question of will HMRC pick it up? But you'd then be into the realms of evasion.
What if you only own a part share of another company?

What if that ownership is not in your name?


Alpinestars

13,954 posts

275 months

Thursday 10th April 2014
quotequote all
Jockman said:
What if you only own a part share of another company?

What if that ownership is not in your name?
It's complicated. It's about control, not ownership. So you could have control without owning the shares.

If you want to look at the law, look up S13 and S416 icta 1988. Happy reading!

Jockman

18,414 posts

191 months

Thursday 10th April 2014
quotequote all
Alpinestars said:
It's complicated. It's about control, not ownership. So you could have control without owning the shares.

If you want to look at the law, look up S13 and S416 icta 1988. Happy reading!
Gee...thanks !!!

It is indeed complicated. I would not set up any business structure without involving Grant Thornton and Hill Dickinson smile