2005 A3 3.2 vs 2000 B5 S4 - running costs differential?
2005 A3 3.2 vs 2000 B5 S4 - running costs differential?
Author
Discussion

SnowyQuattro

Original Poster:

24 posts

151 months

Friday 11th April 2014
quotequote all
I'm considering the two abovenamed cars... assuming they're both in tip-top condition at point of purchase, and both have apprx the same mileage on the clock, am wondering whether ongoing costs would be much different, assuming I intend to maintain their excellent state..? - apprx 8-10000miles pa, 20% urban, 80% extra-urban.

Backstory:
in 2002 bought a 2001 B5 2.8Q tip and loved it to pieces for 6 years - often eyed-up the S4 and coveted it... After a spell abroad i returned to UK and my love for the old B5 shape led me to buy a minty 2000 A4 2.5 tdiQ. Performance was a bummer but having the quattro made up for that enough to see me through another 5 years of audi fanboy-dom. A recent failure of power-steering belt mid-drive and subsequent 500 yard drive led to damage sufficient to render the car not worth repairing due to the range of components now needing replacement... :-( ....

So....I love the 3.2 engine... Having learned from these forums that choosing the manual version removes the potential future costly repairs of DSG problems I started browsing and learning about the A3 and the TT with this engine. I've kinda ruled out the TT for the time being as it looks too 'small' for me (6'2", 16st), though maybe I should drive one first!

It took me a while of watching the models come and go on Autotrader before I understood the price ranges / trim spec / models and I've narrowed it down to what I want...which is good....so now I wait with eyes open....

And then:...
I see a pristine 2000 S4 (remember I'm a total fan of the B5 shape) that's been enthusiast maintained and has low mileage to boot. Price is in the upper range of what I'm looking at for an A3 3.2...

In favour of the A3 there's a lovely, chain-driven, naturally aspirated and naturally under-stressed 250hp in an 'ok' body shape, remove the 3.2 from the back and it's an instant sleeper, updated interior wrt B5 versions, feels 'cleaner and newer', practical in 5dr version, image understated overall;

In favour of the B5 S4 - awesome retro-but-modern understated power-styling, vv responsive 265hp twin-turbocharged 2.7 - car is a classic and could maintain or increase in value if properly maintained. Belt-driven engine = would need doing 1 year after purchase in the one i saw @£650ish+ assuming water pump and tensioners /maybe pulleys, thermostat etc.

Performance differences in the two will be a small win for the S4 on acceleration plus a perhaps slightly bigger win in the cornering and general handling. I don't push my cars to their absolute limits so I'm only likely to enjoy a fraction of the S4's superiority in those areas.

I think I know what is being traded-off in choosing either of these options over the other...except for the ongoing maintenance cost equation for each....

Thanks in advance for any replies! :-)

ManOpener

12,467 posts

200 months

Friday 11th April 2014
quotequote all
The 2.7 Biturbo motor is an absolute nightmare to work on. Sixteen thousand miles of boost piping that can and will leak, two turbochargers that last on average perhaps 50k, cost £500 each to refurbish and require you to disassemble most of the front of the car to fit or remove. Cambelt changes are basically an engine-out job, you have to dissect so much of the front end.

Aside from the turbos it's a fairly hardy motor but the costs for regular engine servicing are ludicrous.

SnowyQuattro

Original Poster:

24 posts

151 months

Friday 11th April 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for the info, ManOpener. I was kinda worried about turbo reliability and you picked that out right away so...yeah...i guess the gist is that, all other things being as equal as possible at the outset of my new ownership, the 3.2Q will likely be less of a financial drain.

Now i gotta compare the TT and the A3 S-line examples of the 3.2 as a bit more research tells me the TT might just be sooo much fun that the loss of practicality might not be an issue...

catso

16,567 posts

298 months

Friday 11th April 2014
quotequote all
I have an A3 3.2 DSG which did have a cam-chain tensioner issue (fixed by Audi under 'goodwill') but has otherwise been very reliable and fairly cheap to run.

Servicing doesn't seem unreasonable even at Audi prices. Being a pre-2006, road tax is OK (£260 ish IIRC) and I just paid £140 for protected no-claims, comprehensive insurance (cheap insurance - the one and only advantage of being old!).

Fuel consumption is not great, averaging around 25mpg but it's not bad for the performance and I don't do huge mileage in it so it doesn't really worry me.

Overall I've been happy with mine. I bought it new (10 years ago) and still have it, which is the longest I've ever owned a car and the oldest car I've ever owned. Have thought about changing it but it just does what I need from a car without any fuss and I don't suppose it is worth much, so the cost to change would be high so it's just 'stuck around'.

In short running costs are not bad at all, the worst features being the depreciation (only applicable if you bought it new) and fuel consumption which maybe an issue if you do high mileages...

kmm

1,781 posts

211 months

Friday 11th April 2014
quotequote all
ManOpener said:
The 2.7 Biturbo motor is an absolute nightmare to work on. Sixteen thousand miles of boost piping that can and will leak, two turbochargers that last on average perhaps 50k, cost £500 each to refurbish and require you to disassemble most of the front of the car to fit or remove. Cambelt changes are basically an engine-out job, you have to dissect so much of the front end.

Aside from the turbos it's a fairly hardy motor but the costs for regular engine servicing are ludicrous.
My original turbo's on my s4 let go at 100k miles, some last less, but I also know of some on 150k miles and still going strong. Pre-face lift s4's had dodgy manifold which sometimes failed destroying the turbos.

To replace turbos the engine has to come out, but for a cambelt job, front bumper off and pretty straight forward from there.

Very tunable and a lot of fun. Lots of good info on audisrs.

SnowyQuattro

Original Poster:

24 posts

151 months

Friday 11th April 2014
quotequote all
Hi catsu
re the cam chain i've resolved to ensure i can get the specific vag-com diagnostics carried out on the ecu-timing chain relationship before i buy. Basically gonna wait for a max 2-owner sub 50k miler with leather or half leather, s-line, bose and all paperwork...1st choice green, 2nd - silver, 3rd - blue, 4th black.

Gonna stick to manual as the dsg is in the potentially very 'expensive toy extra' category though i know i'd love the dsg as long as it worked ok lol

Marshy

2,751 posts

315 months

Friday 11th April 2014
quotequote all
A bit of balance - I bought my S4 with about 140k, remapped it, then cranked it up to 180k with no bother engine-wise. Original turbos, exhaust and clutch too.

Yeah, belt change is a bit of an arse, but go specialist and it won't hurt too much.

Very wafty - all that low down torque made it totally effortless when not pressing on at 10/10ths. Very well screwed together too.

SnowyQuattro

Original Poster:

24 posts

151 months

Friday 11th April 2014
quotequote all
Hey Marshy - thanks for the perspective. Here's the car i was looking at: http://audisrs.com/Rare_7500_about52738.html
looks pretty sweet..

catso

16,567 posts

298 months

Saturday 12th April 2014
quotequote all
SnowyQuattro said:
re the cam chain i've resolved to ensure i can get the specific vag-com diagnostics carried out on the ecu-timing chain relationship before i buy.
Not sure if that has any value? mine went at under 50k (but out of warranty) and when it went it was instant. Car still ran but felt like it was running on 3 cylinders.

Initially Audi dealer wanted £1600+ but after some discussion, taking into account that I had bought it new from them, always serviced by them etc. they agreed to £400 including the service that was almost due (they had already quoted me £360 for the service).

It did take them almost 2 months to do though! but they gave me a loan car for that time...

SnowyQuattro

Original Poster:

24 posts

151 months

Saturday 12th April 2014
quotequote all
Ouch! Timing chain going that early seems like v bad luck tho at least you got it fixed cheaply!

I've read elsewhere on PH that there is a computer diagnostic that can spot 'timing issues'... if this is not in fact the case, then I'm getting a bit scared off the A3 3.2! As the timing chain is supposed to last the lifetime of the vehicle, is it crazy boy-racer behaviour that causes the chains to stretch in the first place? Looks even more important that I find a super-low mileage one with max 2 owners inc seller! With about 1 new 3.2 being listed every day or so, I'm seeing lots of multi-owner examples and/or what look like 'dodgy Dave' dealerships selling them! I would only buy from a dealer with an established reputation they're concerned about protecting or a private, long-term owner with ALL paperwork so I can experience first hand the degree to which they've loved the car...

I wonder how 'odd' I am as a driver that enjoys a car's power but feels no desire to 'rag it' when i have a few extra ponies under the right foot! ??

PS - a truly enthusiast-maintained & pristine B5 S4 is starting to look very appealing again!! (i know, i know...facepalm!)



Edited by SnowyQuattro on Saturday 12th April 18:53

catso

16,567 posts

298 months

Saturday 12th April 2014
quotequote all
I can't see how driving style can affect a chain failure? AFAIK it's a known issue that's not uncommon but by no means common either. As with the DSG mechatronic which has affected some but not all - mine has been fine (touch wood).

Not trying to put you off the 3.2, I like mine and other than that it has been fine and even that ended well - for me anyway.

Apparently the price is mostly labour as it's an engine out job to replace (18hrs labour, they told me), the actual tensioner only costs a few quid.

Maybe buy one from a dealer with some sort of warranty?...

SnowyQuattro

Original Poster:

24 posts

151 months

Sunday 13th April 2014
quotequote all
Hi catso - thanks again for the input. I dunno - was just a stab in the dark re the boy racer driving causing chain stretch! lol - i understand that you're saying it's an inherent possible fault, albeit not a common one.

I'm not put off...yet... I already changed my mind last week on a lovely DSG in green (my fave colour option) with low mileage due to the absurd potential cost of repairing the mechatronic units. I notice there are quite a few nice looking DSGs with low mileage available at the moment and they are taking a LOT longer to shift than the manual versions and are being offered at lower prices than manuals... I'm gutted really as the DSG box would seem perfect for the engine... I feel quite resentful of the mere existence of the DSG issue! lol

Re 'warranties' from dealers, I've done a bit of research and I reckon such warranties offer at best a very limited degree of the promised peace of mind due to the 'wear and tear' and 'consequential damage' clauses they all contain. I would always attempt to negotiate the 'warranty' away in favour of spending the ££ on preventive maintenance with my trusted mechanic! Used car dealer trustworthiness is, I believe, inversely proportional to the age and mileage of the car, i.e. there is likely to be more to lie about in an older car and there is so little comeback on a dealer that sells a faulty motor that they are easily tempted to be economical with the truth... [in case you can't tell, I can't stand used car salespeople! - tough really as I can't afford to buy nearly new or new in this performance bracket!]. Give me a private, enthusiast seller anyday and I'll then plug the savings over a dealer purchase into preventive maintenance. Shame that B5 S4 comes with a price tag that's double the Parker's guide value and will still need a big spend on cambelt + associated bits soon after purchase!

PS - I wonder what's hiding round the corner with this one that's on sale at a 'dealer' for close to the expected auction price!!! ??
http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2014...



Edited by SnowyQuattro on Sunday 13th April 01:25


Edited by SnowyQuattro on Sunday 13th April 01:26

SMB

1,523 posts

297 months

Sunday 13th April 2014
quotequote all
SnowyQuattro said:
Hi catso - thanks again for the input. I dunno - was just a stab in the dark re the boy racer driving causing chain stretch! lol - i understand that you're saying it's an inherent possible fault, albeit not a common one.

I'm not put off...yet... I already changed my mind last week on a lovely DSG in green (my fave colour option) with low mileage due to the absurd potential cost of repairing the mechatronic units. I notice there are quite a few nice looking DSGs with low mileage available at the moment and they are taking a LOT longer to shift than the manual versions and are being offered at lower prices than manuals... I'm gutted really as the DSG box would seem perfect for the engine... I feel quite resentful of the mere existence of the DSG issue! lol





Edited by SnowyQuattro on Sunday 13th April 01:25


Edited by SnowyQuattro on Sunday 13th April 01:26
A few things to remember, before talking about 'the dsg issue'

The costs you have heard about are from the days of dealer fix by wholesale replacement,
Now you can have the parts repairs by third parties at much lower costs. Read the thread a few days ago in the audi,vw category to see how many people have done higher mile ages on this box.

At the age you are looking at the potential damage hiding inside a manual box or worn clutches could be similar costs in the future, treat every inspection in the same way, if it's dsg ensure it's been serviced , perhaps look for old job sheets in the pack that show what items were investigated , and of course see how it drives.



SnowyQuattro

Original Poster:

24 posts

151 months

Sunday 13th April 2014
quotequote all
Thnks SMB - will bear in mind and do further reading as you suggest. BTW, am looking for a sub-40k example - that one at 60k just seemed such a low price compared to others similar in spec it seems 'questionable'...

Off to the DSG thread for me again! lol

catso

16,567 posts

298 months

Sunday 13th April 2014
quotequote all
SnowyQuattro said:
I'm gutted really as the DSG box would seem perfect for the engine...
Indeed it is, it's one of the things that's made me keep mine so long. I find that leaving it in 'D' is just right for everyday use (for an old fart like me) but playstation manual mode is always there at the touch of a button - almost 2 cars in one. wink

As mentioned above there are places that can repair the mechatronic for a few hundred quid if required, so making potential faults no more expensive than a clutch replacement on a manual and AFAIK the rest of the box is fairly sturdy - I'm not aware that the clutches or other mechanical parts fail?


SnowyQuattro

Original Poster:

24 posts

151 months

Sunday 13th April 2014
quotequote all
Haha - I, too, am an old fart! lol You guys have been seriously helpful with this business - thanks v much.