123d Vs MK6 GTI / S3
Author
Discussion

mikeyscott

Original Poster:

1,200 posts

239 months

Friday 25th April 2014
quotequote all
Anyone had a 123d and made a move to or from a MK6 GTi / S3

I have been on the lookout for 130i M Sport, 335i touring etc. but with the age/spec/price mix I'm moving away from that idea. Leaning back towards the VAG stable.

I know the S3 and MK6 GTi are prob quite different. S3 is prob coming less of a prospect due to pricing etc. and I'd prob wish a sport back.

Therefore leaving the S3 idea and thinking GTi MK6. Did mull R32, but older and I suppose I'm not wanting to go older that a 58 plate.

I suspect if I did end up with a VAG, it'd end up at JKM for Revo and poss resonated milltek

The alternative is I sit on the fence for 6 months and do nothing, my 59 plate 123d now has 51k on it. I got it July last year with 31k. Currently doing 500 miles a week and soon to be doing 30, so also looking at Boardman and Specialized bikes. Add a £5k pay rise, things looking ok.

Basil Hume

1,389 posts

283 months

Friday 25th April 2014
quotequote all
Your 123d sounds nice and, as they say, the cheapest car is the one you already own.

I've had a 2.0T quattro A3 (same chassis and engine as Mk5 GTI), 8P S3 and now a Mk5 R32 - all in 5-door flavour. They're all great cars. See my "Garage" reviews for each.

As to your question, it really depends on what you want. An S3 and R32 (or 4WD A3 2.0T) will feel more secure on the road than the 123d, but you won't notice it until you get back into another 2WD car. The S3 will be quicker against the stopwatch and the R32 marginally so (but probably only balls out and / or from a standing start) - while only the S3 will feel quicker. The GTI will be a nice all-round package, but more like a lateral move with different qualities and downsides to the 123d.

I presume you chose the 123d for a combination of good reasons. Check that these have changed before you go for any of the above cars.

But - if you are missing some "soul" from your motoring, then only the R32 will do from that list. Allowing for the minimal depreciation on these cars, you might find that overall costs are the lowest of the lot (even if fuel and tax sting at the time).


mikeyscott

Original Poster:

1,200 posts

239 months

Friday 25th April 2014
quotequote all
I got the 123d due to my mileage as I was running a 2.5T Volvo S40 T5, great cruiser, but boy it liked fuel. Same engine as the Focus ST

Reason for looking at the market, I just prefer petrol. I think the real test could come tomorrow when I back to back my 123d with a MK6 GTi.

Certainly see you're point re costs. Which is also heavily on my mind re the 123d, paid £16k, offered £9k-£11k

chrisemersons

143 posts

174 months

Wednesday 14th May 2014
quotequote all
I had a new 123d coupe, had nothing but trouble with it from new - new engine at 20k miles, cam chain at 60k miles plus various other annoying things like rattles that the dealer never managed to sort in 4 years. BMW dealers in my experience are shocking. I thought the car was reasonably fun to drive and not too juicy on fuel, my only gripe was the poor ride quality initially on bridgstones, but that was nothing compared to what the ride became on dunlops - totally unacceptable, i hated driving it on anything but silk smooth roads.
So, had a demo in a Mk7 GTI, loved it so i bought one, i have to say i absolutely love it, it made the 123d seem agricultural in comparison, its drinks more fuel but i don't care its head and shoulders nicer to drive and better spec'd for about the same money as the equivalent BMW.
Sorry i cant comment on the mk6 GTI but my son has a Mk5 and thats a great bit of kit.

Andy OH

1,961 posts

281 months

Wednesday 14th May 2014
quotequote all
I've had a MK6 Golf GTi with DSG box for two months now. It is a good all rounder and a very pleasant place to be in on long journeys. I bought mine from a VW main dealer and they were excellent with a couple of issue the car had when I bought it (scratches to paint work, which were sorted out and rear discs which were both replaced with no quibble).

I have thought about a remap but due to it having a warranty and on a service plan I have decided to not get it remapped, however I know a remap would transform the car. It is a fun car to drive albeit not lightly quick, it is deceptively quick and can cover ground fairly quickly with no problems.

Let us know what yo've decided to do.

83TEP

155 posts

184 months

Wednesday 14th May 2014
quotequote all
Bought the wife a mk6 gti dsg recently. It's a great car for what it costs, I paid £13k for 59 plate with top spec, 45k on clock. I also have a 335d which is quicker but lot less fun to drive. Golf makes great noise when changes gears on half throttle or more. Golf also does better mpg than the bmw!!

the-photographer

5,209 posts

207 months

Thursday 15th May 2014
quotequote all
Be careful with early MK6 GTI cars, see;

http://www.golfgtiforum.co.uk/index.php?topic=2627...

Either, get official warranty, one with a new engine, or one that's been upgraded.

nick s

1,372 posts

248 months

Thursday 29th May 2014
quotequote all
Ecurie Ecosse said:
Have you remapped the 123d? Really big gains. You won't want to sell it then.
I have to disagree with this somewhat. Just sold my remapped 123d, was pushing 264bhp. Was done by the reputable Jason at BW Chiptune. I was completely underwhelmed by the performance of the car. People put too much emphasis on the headline power figures that these achieve when remapped. The truth is, is that it's so linear and boring to drive, that it doesn't feel fun or fast. It just changes the car into a diesel that can effortlessly overtake and doesn't require much gearwork. It is by no means a "rapid" car once remapped. I've now got a remapped mk2 TT running less power that the 123d, but it's by far the quicker car. I made the mistake of buying the 123d to try and save money, AND have a quick car! It really doesn't perform how the power figures would suggest. (used to get completely trounced by my brothers standard 265bhp Z4 3.0si) Therefore i don't think it's in any way comparable with a mk6 GTI or S3!

nick s

1,372 posts

248 months

Friday 30th May 2014
quotequote all
Ecurie Ecosse said:
nick s said:
Ecurie Ecosse said:
Have you remapped the 123d? Really big gains. You won't want to sell it then.
I have to disagree with this somewhat. Just sold my remapped 123d, was pushing 264bhp. Was done by the reputable Jason at BW Chiptune. I was completely underwhelmed by the performance of the car. People put too much emphasis on the headline power figures that these achieve when remapped. The truth is, is that it's so linear and boring to drive, that it doesn't feel fun or fast. It just changes the car into a diesel that can effortlessly overtake and doesn't require much gearwork. It is by no means a "rapid" car once remapped. I've now got a remapped mk2 TT running less power that the 123d, but it's by far the quicker car. I made the mistake of buying the 123d to try and save money, AND have a quick car! It really doesn't perform how the power figures would suggest. (used to get completely trounced by my brothers standard 265bhp Z4 3.0si) Therefore i don't think it's in any way comparable with a mk6 GTI or S3!
Are you sure it actually was remapped and/or you were driving it properly?

I've had a few nippy cars and my 123d compared well against them. I did find the standard car a bit slow against my 147 GTA at the time, but this was rectified with the remap. Funnily enough I chose it over a new S3 when I got it.
Yes definitely! I drove the car there, watched it get mapped and drove it home with a significant performance increase. It just still wasn't a rapid car. I don't know what i was expecting though really. Don't get me wrong, it was still pretty fast. Just not in the same league as a 250bhp+ petrol car. No way. Just so linear and uninspiring that it bored me to tears! I also never got my average MPG above 37, so seemend pointless to me as it wasn't saving me any money at all! I think maybe my expectations were just a bit high. Don't get me wrong, i did love the car. I kept it for 18 months! Was just missing everything about a quick petrol engine.

Edited by nick s on Friday 30th May 08:43