So I fancy a diesel A4
Author
Discussion

EddyP

Original Poster:

882 posts

251 months

Saturday 26th April 2014
quotequote all
Hi All,

I fancy a diesel A4 avant, but have concerns with the engine choices:


2.0 TDI - Dodgy oil pumps/balancer shafts potentially meaning a very expensive repair bill
2.5TDI - Dodgy water pumps, chocolate camshafts, dodgy fuel pumps
1.9TDI - Read quite a few issues about cold starting problems, and no one being able to fix them after replacing all sorts of bits from injectors to seals etc…


However if I went for an Octavia apparently the 2.0LTDI is OK as it didn't have the balancer shaft complications.

It will be used for daily driving, but also towing a caravan, which made me think the V6 torque might be a bonus, but I will want reasonable fuel economy when not towing (at least 45).
Also if it was an auto it would be a bonus, but then I've read to avoid the multitronic gearboxes as they're crap, and others like the tip can have DMF problems.

Just seems to be a minefield of faults that make it impossible to find something that'll be reliable.

Any advice of what's best to go for? Were any of the 2.0LTDI engines in the A4 ok?

Thanks smile

Kell

1,708 posts

239 months

Saturday 26th April 2014
quotequote all
3.0TDi?

The only problems are
1) getting 45mpg+ I can get 44 out of my A6 on a long motorway run, but it sits at about 33 overall.
2) Finding one.

It would be a much better towing vehicle however, and a much better engine than the 2.7.


blueg33

46,972 posts

255 months

Saturday 26th April 2014
quotequote all
Kell said:
3.0TDi?

The only problems are
1) getting 45mpg+ I can get 44 out of my A6 on a long motorway run, but it sits at about 33 overall.
2) Finding one.

It would be a much better towing vehicle however, and a much better engine than the 2.7.
This

3.0tdi is a no brainer

Mr Gearchange

5,892 posts

237 months

Saturday 26th April 2014
quotequote all
+1 on the 3.0Tdi I have one in my A8 and it really is a lovely unit - it even makes a decent noise.

But they very rarely went into A4's.

SmithyAG

300 posts

159 months

Saturday 26th April 2014
quotequote all
The octavia is based on the Golf/A3 and not the A4. This is why there's no 2.0tdi oil pump problems.

Engines in the golf/a3/octavia were BKD/BMM/BMN I think.
A4 had BLB amongst others, which caused the issues.

The 2.0tdi in the octavia will be 140PD with weak turbos and potentially porous cylinder heads or 170 with an injector recall. Obviously not all are affected with either problem, but all are far cheaper than the oil pump problems in the A4.