330D vs MK5 Gti Ed30
Author
Discussion

stugolf

Original Poster:

483 posts

234 months

Wednesday 30th April 2014
quotequote all
Hi Guys,

In a quandary, I need a reliable but quick car and I'm torn between an E90 330D pre LCI and a Golf Gti Ed30/Pirelli? I know they are very different cars but cost approximately the same and are the same age and similar performance tuned or not.

I'm unsure what to do!

At the moment I drive short ish journeys so the petrol would suit my requirements but I do need to do long journeys a few times a month, and that's where the diesel shines.

Can anyone offer me some advice on owning one or the other or both?

Thanks

Dr G

16,007 posts

273 months

Wednesday 30th April 2014
quotequote all
The 330D is a competent all rounder with a good turn off pace.

The MKV GTI is great fun when you're in the mood and also a fantastic all rounder.

If squishing along Mways is your priority the BM probably just pips it but the Veedub for everything else.

chrisb92

1,051 posts

155 months

Wednesday 30th April 2014
quotequote all
You can get a much nicer ED30 for the same price as a 330d!

I'm stuck as to whether to get an ED30 or MKVI GTI.. have you considered a mkvi? will get better MPG

stugolf

Original Poster:

483 posts

234 months

Wednesday 30th April 2014
quotequote all
My budget is around £8500-10000 are MK6 GTI's available in that bracket?

I've seen quite a few 330d's for sale for this value, they look ok as do the ED30's

Faz123

347 posts

169 months

Wednesday 30th April 2014
quotequote all
Is there a reason you've not considered the 330i? It's just that I feel your choice isn't being driven by economy as an edition 30 would possibly get around 35-45% less mpg then a 330D.

You may well even get a better 330i then you would a 330d for your cash.

Something like this http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/b...

Cheers
Faz.

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Wednesday 30th April 2014
quotequote all
If you could squeeze into a Mk6 GTI I'd probably say go for that. The E90 330d is a nice car though and will match a GTI for performance, just lacks a sense of occasion and the engine is a bit rough around town.

As another alternative how about a B8 Audi A4 2.0 TFSI? Nice blend between the two with GTI levels of fun and 330d comfort whilst being a bit more up to date since its still a production model. E.g. http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2014... for an S-Line or a newer SE http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2014...

stugolf

Original Poster:

483 posts

234 months

Wednesday 30th April 2014
quotequote all
The Audi is a very nice car but very bland and you see far too many of them on the road, although you do see a fair few E90s as well!

I currently own an E46 330i so a move to the E90 would feel the same really, and I'm not overally keen on the MPG of a straight 6 either, I know the Golf wouldn't be much better, but it would if you were on a long run

p1tse

1,412 posts

223 months

Thursday 1st May 2014
quotequote all
i'm not a fan of the saloon so default Ed30 LOL

Would you consider e92 coupe?

stugolf

Original Poster:

483 posts

234 months

Thursday 1st May 2014
quotequote all
I'm the opposite do really like the saloon but don't really like the coupe

Faz123

347 posts

169 months

Thursday 1st May 2014
quotequote all
I say you get the Golf. You even have it in your name biggrin

stugolf

Original Poster:

483 posts

234 months

Thursday 1st May 2014
quotequote all
Ha ha, and I've posted on the VW section of PH, In theory yes, but do still really like the BM, think I need to drive them both

cerb4.5lee

45,292 posts

211 months

Friday 2nd May 2014
quotequote all
Owned a E90 330d and currently have a E90 330i they are both fantastic all rounders in my opinion but you do see millions of E90 3 series on the road which for me is the only downside, choosing which is best between the 330d/330i is more difficult.

I think I would say the 330d is the better car...just, as the 330i hasn't got much mid range punch but it is nice to enjoy the higher revs of the 330i though and it does sound nice at high revs if a little muted but the overtaking punch of the 330d is great fun and both engines are lovely and smooth.

I am only doing around 12k miles a year at the moment so I chose the 330i but if I was doing any more then the 330d would easily get my vote, from inside the car the 330d actually sounds more characterful and more gutsy than the 330i for me too.

stugolf

Original Poster:

483 posts

234 months

Friday 2nd May 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for all the help on this guys

a4cabrio

933 posts

190 months

Friday 2nd May 2014
quotequote all
va1o said:
If you could squeeze into a Mk6 GTI I'd probably say go for that. The E90 330d is a nice car though and will match a GTI for performance, just lacks a sense of occasion and the engine is a bit rough around town/
Can you explain what "a bit rough around town means"??

I've had a mk5 GTi and an e90 330d and actually prefer the engine sound of the 330d, the TFSi engine sounds very rough on idle. If you were saying a 320d engine sounds rough around town I could understand it.

a4cabrio

933 posts

190 months

Friday 2nd May 2014
quotequote all
cerb4.5lee said:
Owned a E90 330d and currently have a E90 330i they are both fantastic all rounders in my opinion but you do see millions of E90 3 series on the road which for me is the only downside, choosing which is best between the 330d/330i is more difficult.

I think I would say the 330d is the better car...just, as the 330i hasn't got much mid range punch but it is nice to enjoy the higher revs of the 330i though and it does sound nice at high revs if a little muted but the overtaking punch of the 330d is great fun and both engines are lovely and smooth.

I am only doing around 12k miles a year at the moment so I chose the 330i but if I was doing any more then the 330d would easily get my vote, from inside the car the 330d actually sounds more characterful and more gutsy than the 330i for me too.
I've also made the move from a e90 330d to an e93 330i and agree with your post totally, 2 very good engines, both have plus and minus points, sometimes I miss the "d" and then other times I'm glad I have the "i", especially when I've got the roof down smile

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Friday 2nd May 2014
quotequote all
a4cabrio said:
Can you explain what "a bit rough around town means"??

I've had a mk5 GTi and an e90 330d and actually prefer the engine sound of the 330d, the TFSi engine sounds very rough on idle. If you were saying a 320d engine sounds rough around town I could understand it.
I just find it a bit noisy and tractor like compared to the Golf, not as smooth until going quicker . This is an E93 330d though

a4cabrio

933 posts

190 months

Friday 2nd May 2014
quotequote all
va1o said:
I just find it a bit noisy and tractor like compared to the Golf, not as smooth until going quicker . This is an E93 330d though
Fair play, i can see where your coming from there, I had an Audi a4 3.0 tdi cabriolet and never got used to the diesel sound with the roof down, which was why when I was looking for a 3 series convertible it had to be petrol, went for a 330i

cerb4.5lee

45,292 posts

211 months

Saturday 3rd May 2014
quotequote all
a4cabrio said:
cerb4.5lee said:
Owned a E90 330d and currently have a E90 330i they are both fantastic all rounders in my opinion but you do see millions of E90 3 series on the road which for me is the only downside, choosing which is best between the 330d/330i is more difficult.

I think I would say the 330d is the better car...just, as the 330i hasn't got much mid range punch but it is nice to enjoy the higher revs of the 330i though and it does sound nice at high revs if a little muted but the overtaking punch of the 330d is great fun and both engines are lovely and smooth.

I am only doing around 12k miles a year at the moment so I chose the 330i but if I was doing any more then the 330d would easily get my vote, from inside the car the 330d actually sounds more characterful and more gutsy than the 330i for me too.
I've also made the move from a e90 330d to an e93 330i and agree with your post totally, 2 very good engines, both have plus and minus points, sometimes I miss the "d" and then other times I'm glad I have the "i", especially when I've got the roof down smile
I feel exactly the same as you and sometimes miss the "d" but same again glad I have the "i" sometimes too! with you having the E93 I bet the "i" sounds really nice with the roof off smile

I actually test drove a E93 330d back in 2012 when we were looking at swapping the E90 330d but the roof off experience suits a petrol for me far more.