Golf GTi MK5 aircon (again)
Golf GTi MK5 aircon (again)
Author
Discussion

va1o

Original Poster:

16,118 posts

238 months

Saturday 3rd May 2014
quotequote all
I've been recently having some AC issues with my Golf and can't seem to get it sorted. So far the compressor has been replaced and pressure sensor/ switch. This has been done at the same time as a regas, VCDS scan and a check for leaks. Doing this has taken it from not working at all to intermittently working. This morning I couldn't get any cold air out of it and this afternoon it worked for a short period.

What would be the next thing to look at? As I say it doesn't appear to have any leaks so a bit confused. I'm planning on getting an AC specialist involved soon but as this has already cost me quite a lot would appreciate any advice thumbup

computamedic

312 posts

264 months

Sunday 4th May 2014
quotequote all
Hi. I feel your pain as I've been through similar problems. You mention that the compressor has been changed but didn't mention why. It's one of the most expensive components in the A/C system and it would be helpful to understand what was wrong with the original to prompt a replacement. The compressor is a well-known weak point in the Mk5 and usually seizes causing the drive tabs to break, allowing the drive belt to keep working.

If this is the case it is imperative that the system be flushed before a new compressor is fitted otherwise the resultant sludge and debris from the seizure will ultimately end up in the new compressor - and seize that one too. Of course, if the compressor seizes there is no chance of intermittent working.

Technically, the A/C system is pretty simple. If there is sufficient gas in the system, the compressor is working and the gas can flow there's not much that can go wrong. If you have eliminated issues with the compressor and the gas and conformed no leaks it only leaves the flow. Obstructions in the system - potentially caused by the sludge/debris mentioned before - can occur in the receiver/dryer, the condenser or the evaporator. It's often recommended that the receiver/dryer and condenser be changed when the compressor is changed and that must be the next thing to check.

The final potential problem is the evaporator. This sits behind the dashboard and is the source of the "coldness". It's very much like a radiator working in reverse and a reduction or lack of gas flow through it will result in a massive loss of function.

Getting an A/C specialist involved must be a priority - I'm surprised you haven't already. My recent problems resulted in a system flush, a new compressor, receiver/dryer, condenser and the obvious regas at a cost of £610 but it now works perfectly. Hope you get your sorted soon.

va1o

Original Poster:

16,118 posts

238 months

Sunday 4th May 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for the detailed reply. I just can't get my head round the intermittent working. The place that did the work claims to know about AC but they aren't a specialist per se, more just a general garage. Would the fact it looks like the previous owner never used it have any impact? Car is 8 years old.

computamedic

312 posts

264 months

Tuesday 6th May 2014
quotequote all
It's pretty unusual for the Mk5 A/C to not get used as it's permanently engaged - unless you have the "Econ" button pressed all the time.

From my experience of mine not working I found the occasional time when I thought it WAS working but it just turned out to be slightly cool ambient air coming through. It's only when it really IS working that you realise what COLD air really means!!

It's not in the nature of A/C systems to work intermittently - they either do or they don't.

Your location of Herts, Beds & Bucks doesn't really help tie you down but I used Kevin at Bedford Battery to sort mine out. He's mobile so he'll come to you if you can't get to him.

va1o

Original Poster:

16,118 posts

238 months

Friday 16th May 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for the recommendation, I've sent him an email. It had been working Ok for the past week or two hence the lack of reply but started playing up again today. I turned it down to the LO setting and the air coming out of the vents was warmer than it was on the 16 and 18 settings previously confused

Wondering if it's maybe similar to this http://www.briskoda.net/forums/topic/258781-climat... . Would safe having the front of the car stripped down to inspect the pipework etc

Edited by va1o on Friday 16th May 20:42

the-photographer

5,209 posts

207 months

Friday 16th May 2014
quotequote all
computamedic said:
It's pretty unusual for the Mk5 A/C to not get used as it's permanently engaged - unless you have the "Econ" button pressed all the time.
It should be running at 5% or similar all the time (regardless of the ECON button) will post again in the morning with the info source,

the-photographer

5,209 posts

207 months

Saturday 17th May 2014
quotequote all
This is the replacement unit for Golf and all variants (Skoda etc)

http://www.my-gti.com/2465/sanden-pxe16-air-condit...

Runs all the time.

the-photographer

5,209 posts

207 months

Saturday 17th May 2014
quotequote all
Random things to check;

  • Was system fully flushed when you had the new compressor, maybe there is some gunk clogging the system?
  • Were all the other potentially troublesome parts replaced? (expansion valve, condenser etc)
  • Right amount of gas in the system?

va1o

Original Poster:

16,118 posts

238 months

Saturday 17th May 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for the links. This one http://www.golfmkv.com/forums/showthread.php?t=143... sounds most similar to my situation. Just went out for a drive this morning, I reset the flaps before going (as per the Briskoda link) and it worked fine. 22 degrees outside here at the moment but the car was nice and cool inside after a few minutes set to 16 degrees - auto. Will have another look at VCDS when I get the chance but last time I tried it showed the compressor as running except when pressing ECON which turns it off.

kr15

10 posts

150 months

Sunday 18th May 2014
quotequote all
Hi. New to this but saw the probs your having and thought (snap)
Bought a Golf Mk5 gti dsg Petrol yesterday only to discover the AC would not blow out cool air. Took it to kwik fit for a re gas but was told it was leaking somewhere. Found out since this is a common fault on the mk5. Its now back at the garage i bought it from to be sorted. Hope its soon as im itching to get back in the beast.

va1o

Original Poster:

16,118 posts

238 months

Sunday 18th May 2014
quotequote all
Welcome to the forum and congratulations on your top choice in car! If does indeed seem to be a very common problem. Mines been annoyingly intermittent today, worked this morning, packed up for the afternoon then decided to come back to life this evening. Tried VCDS again but still not flagging any faults so will be of to a specialist when I get the chance frown

kr15

10 posts

150 months

Monday 26th May 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for the welcome. Well its all fixed now, new a/c pipe. Had this car a week and i love it. Ive come from an audi a4 1.8t 52 and the golf beats it in so many areas. Just being able to put my back seats down is amazing. Thinking a future project could be putting in a touch screen stereo. Love the idea of having freeview in my car. Anybody else got this and best prices please.

va1o

Original Poster:

16,118 posts

238 months

Sunday 8th June 2014
quotequote all
Mine packed up again this weekend but think its gone for good this time. Worked ok for the past 3 weeks with daily use so I was starting to think I was fine now, but seems it couldn't cope with the recent weather. Can't help but notice that most of the other Mk5s I've seen out and about in the heat have had all the windows open. Maybe people just don't bother fixing it and live without! Guess my problem is I'm used to newer cars where its always worked without issue.

the-photographer

5,209 posts

207 months

Sunday 8th June 2014
quotequote all
Time to take to a AC specialist or VW (who are specialists just because of the number of faults).

Could be expensive...


Hub

7,170 posts

229 months

Monday 9th June 2014
quotequote all
I think mine might have had it too. If the compressor isn't working, would you still get the change in revs when you turn 'econ' off at idle?

va1o

Original Poster:

16,118 posts

238 months

Monday 9th June 2014
quotequote all
Hub said:
I think mine might have had it too. If the compressor isn't working, would you still get the change in revs when you turn 'econ' off at idle?
I'm still noticing the change in revs on mine, but I've already got a new compressor and it still isn't working. Lots of different components which are all prone to failure it seems!

si_xsi

1,325 posts

226 months

Monday 9th June 2014
quotequote all
Mine is cold but i've noticed that when on, the cooling fan only comes on half speed, despite being a scortching day and driven for long periods. I'm guessing it has to be really really hot for the cooling fan to come on full speed, has anyone had theirs come on full?

On previous cars the main fan would come on full as soon as you put the a.c on.

Hope you get yours fixed op.

va1o

Original Poster:

16,118 posts

238 months

Monday 9th June 2014
quotequote all
Does sound quite similar to what I'm finding then. Yesterday it was mega hot and I used the car quite a bit and it wouldn't work at all. Saturday it worked but didn't feel that strong during a 60 mile trip. Today I just drove to the station and back (5 miles) with it back to working fine both ways blowing cold air (23.5 outside and very humid here). Will take it into a specialist at some point but I'd like to try and get a rough idea of what's likely to be causing the problem. Only other thing I've noticed is when its working and first kicks in you can hear a faint clicking noise from behind the vents for a few seconds, not quite sure what that's about.

EDIT: And again today, worked fine on my short commute. Its either long journeys or extreme weather which it can't cope with.

EDIT 2: And to confuse things further, it worked on the 5 hour return trip to Goodwood today without issue. 25 degrees outside on the way home and it cooled the car nicely. No idea what's going on now, fingers crossed it's fixed itself then...

Edited by va1o on Saturday 28th June 00:38