A3 TDI experiences wanted
Discussion
Hi, I did a recent thread regarding my intended purchase of an A6 and received some really useful advice. Over the past week there has been a huge change in circumstances and as a result an equally huge change in budget! I now have around £5000 to spend on a reasonably comfortable diesel car and the A3 is the first to spring to mind. All I really want is comfort, economy and the only thing on the options list would be cruise control. Should I be looking at the 2.0TDI or the 1.9TDI? As I understand the 2.0 has a range of issues such as porous heads?
Thanks.
Thanks.
I'm surprised to see no responses, but if you're looking for ride comfort then avoid this generation of A3 entirely. Great to drive, but even in early SE specification, on the smallest wheels, they were extremely firm riding. The previous generation and the A4 are much better. Haven't tried the latest generation A3.
The S-line is worse, and traders I know won't buy them because people are put off by the ride when they drive them. Look great though. Finally there's a sport version which I haven't tried - I guess it rides somewhere between SE and S-line.
Hope this helps, just my experience backed up with the opinions of others I've heard.
1.9 tdi and 2.0 both great engines. If you're not looking for speed the 1.9 is plenty, and a simpler engine too. 1.9 cars will be a lower specification though.
The S-line is worse, and traders I know won't buy them because people are put off by the ride when they drive them. Look great though. Finally there's a sport version which I haven't tried - I guess it rides somewhere between SE and S-line.
Hope this helps, just my experience backed up with the opinions of others I've heard.
1.9 tdi and 2.0 both great engines. If you're not looking for speed the 1.9 is plenty, and a simpler engine too. 1.9 cars will be a lower specification though.
Bad habits of the engines you are looking at:
BJB / BKC / BXE / BLS 1.9PD TDI - One of these (BXE I think), has a habit of conrod failure, requiring new engine.
BKD- 2.0PD TDI 140ps - Early ones had porous cylinder heads, most have a turbo replacement needed during their life. Other problems could include EGR cooler leaking coolant.
BMN - 2.0PD 170ps - Injector recall, quite a few injector recalls resulted in rough running problems that required enormous amounts of investigation and re-visits to the dealer.
BMM - 2.0 PD 140ps 8valve - I think this is the one with the DPF, which wasn't really suited to the PD engine.
Don't let the above scare you, the internet only brings out people who have problems with things. For each car that has had problems there could be 100 that didn't.
I have the BKD engine listed above in a 2004 A3, various sources tell me it came from the same build batch that has the porous head issues, mine hasn't had them and shows no signs of either at 118k. It did have a new turbo at the start of this year, but I've put that down to the previous owner (who I know), driving it everywhere gently, therefore fully actuating the turbo vanes fully and allowing them to clog up. It is also on it's original clutch and flywheel with no real signs of problems ahead there either. The only none consumable item's it has wanted for (bar the turbo) are an EGR valve and a set of Radiator fans, neither of which cost the earth.
Hope this helps
BJB / BKC / BXE / BLS 1.9PD TDI - One of these (BXE I think), has a habit of conrod failure, requiring new engine.
BKD- 2.0PD TDI 140ps - Early ones had porous cylinder heads, most have a turbo replacement needed during their life. Other problems could include EGR cooler leaking coolant.
BMN - 2.0PD 170ps - Injector recall, quite a few injector recalls resulted in rough running problems that required enormous amounts of investigation and re-visits to the dealer.
BMM - 2.0 PD 140ps 8valve - I think this is the one with the DPF, which wasn't really suited to the PD engine.
Don't let the above scare you, the internet only brings out people who have problems with things. For each car that has had problems there could be 100 that didn't.
I have the BKD engine listed above in a 2004 A3, various sources tell me it came from the same build batch that has the porous head issues, mine hasn't had them and shows no signs of either at 118k. It did have a new turbo at the start of this year, but I've put that down to the previous owner (who I know), driving it everywhere gently, therefore fully actuating the turbo vanes fully and allowing them to clog up. It is also on it's original clutch and flywheel with no real signs of problems ahead there either. The only none consumable item's it has wanted for (bar the turbo) are an EGR valve and a set of Radiator fans, neither of which cost the earth.
Hope this helps
Oh and as DR G said, if you can get into a Common Rail diesel engine then do so, be it in an Exeo or something else from the VAG group. They are well behaved and much more refined to drive.
They may feel as though they are missing the slug of torque you get from a PD, but it is only because the power is more progressive and spread more evenly across the rev range.
They may feel as though they are missing the slug of torque you get from a PD, but it is only because the power is more progressive and spread more evenly across the rev range.
Thats really useful information, thanyou. I'm really now looking for more focussed on reliability than driver focus so I'm looking more toward the 1.9 but there are a few seat Exeos that are cropping up and the praise the common rail engine gets does make me start to consider one of those. Are they more economical too?
Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


