Audi B6 S4 4.2 V8
Author
Discussion

Tea Pot One

Original Poster:

1,870 posts

259 months

Tuesday 6th May 2014
quotequote all
Looking at a 2004 convertible with 50K on it for £9K full ASH.

Any comments on them ?

I am currently in a new Fiesta ST2 which I am not getting on with (seating position and 3 pedals as opposed to the 2 I am used to). I am considering a massive change from a new hot hatch which everyone other than me seems to love .... to a 10 year old S4 - am I mad ?

The Fiesta was a big change for me coming from a TVR, Z4M, S2000 and a few other 3 series Beemers. It was an attempt at fun and being sensible at the same time. There is zero wrong with it - in fact the build is great ... I just can't get on with the driving position.

Comments on the S4 / performance / issues, etc welcome.


lewis328

508 posts

229 months

Wednesday 7th May 2014
quotequote all
I had one for 2 years and only sold it as 1st child was due. I personally thought it was a great car, did most things well, tyres are expensive, likes oil, and you won't get more than 14mpg. But roof down and v8 is a superb combo. Interior was solid, I had the manual, never tried the auto. 9k should get u a b7 I would have thought.

caiss4

1,947 posts

228 months

Wednesday 7th May 2014
quotequote all
Mine's a 10 year old manual saloon with similar miles. Issues for the type are auxiliary radiators (if it has a full ASH then see if they've been replaced); mine's been through 3 in 10 years. Timing chain rattle on start up - expensive fix but, once again, mine's never exhibited this problem and that's on long-life servicing.

Oil consumption has never been an issue for me with modest top ups between servicing after about 10k miles.

Clutch and DMF costs about £2K to replace. Mine was changed at 38k! If you're looking at the auto model then that's one problem you won't see plus owing to the longer gearing economy on the cruise is better in an auto.

Tyres aren't too bad....reckon on 10-12k for the front and up to 17k for the rears.

Lifetime economy for mine (according to the on board computer) is 21.7mpg. My driving is mainly A and B road. You can see 28mpg if you drive carefully but around town expect that to be mid-teens at best. Oh! and they like 97 RON too but you do get better economy from it.

Generally I'd say fairly bullet-proof if it's been looked after.

Edited by caiss4 on Wednesday 7th May 12:44

TTwiggy

11,884 posts

235 months

Wednesday 7th May 2014
quotequote all
I had an avant for a couple of years. As an all-round proposition (assuming you can live with the mpg) they are hard to beat, but it's worth pointing out that they are not sportscars and neither are they really quick enough in a straight line to be considered 'bahnstormers'.

I'd be wary of spending too much on one as moving it on will be difficult (the market for old V8s is limited!). At your budget I'd look for a B7, purely to be as up to date as possible. Personally, I prefer the smaller grill of the B6, but it does date them.

Tea Pot One

Original Poster:

1,870 posts

259 months

Wednesday 7th May 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for all the info smile

I drove it but it is not for me. The engine was nice and made a nice noise ... and I could see me going up and down the UK in it but it was too soft for fun. More Jaguar'ish than I expected and not as quick as I thought it would be with funny throttle control where it went from laid back to mad in seemingly 2mm of pedal travel !

It had a number of things that would have needed sorting and is actually an import from Australia albeit with a V5 and service history + only one owner in total.

Oddly it also had an RS4 tacho as opposed to S4 ... but was def an S4 !

TTwiggy

11,884 posts

235 months

Wednesday 7th May 2014
quotequote all
Tea Pot One said:
I drove it but it is not for me. The engine was nice and made a nice noise ... and I could see me going up and down the UK in it but it was too soft for fun. More Jaguar'ish than I expected and not as quick as I thought it would be with funny throttle control where it went from laid back to mad in seemingly 2mm of pedal travel !
Very much it's strength and weakness in one. It can do many things very well (it's practical, quick, makes a nice noise, has (proper) 4 wheel drive etc) but it doesn't excel at any of them.



p1tse

1,412 posts

223 months

Wednesday 7th May 2014
quotequote all
caiss4 said:
Mine's a 10 year old manual saloon with similar miles. Issues for the type are auxiliary radiators (if it has a full ASH then see if they've been replaced); mine's been through 3 in 10 years. Timing chain rattle on start up - expensive fix but, once again, mine's never exhibited this problem and that's on long-life servicing.

Oil consumption has never been an issue for me with modest top ups between servicing after about 10k miles.

Clutch and DMF costs about £2K to replace. Mine was changed at 38k! If you're looking at the auto model then that's one problem you won't see plus owing to the longer gearing economy on the cruise is better in an auto.

Tyres aren't too bad....reckon on 10-12k for the front and up to 17k for the rears.

Lifetime economy for mine (according to the on board computer) is 21.7mpg. My driving is mainly A and B road. You can see 28mpg if you drive carefully but around town expect that to be mid-teens at best. Oh! and they like 97 RON too but you do get better economy from it.

Generally I'd say fairly bullet-proof if it's been looked after.

Edited by caiss4 on Wednesday 7th May 12:44
No rattle at all?

Tea Pot One

Original Poster:

1,870 posts

259 months

Thursday 8th May 2014
quotequote all
The one I test drove didn't rattle at all - started inside from 'cold' and was super smooth.

One thing it did have was wheel judder at all speeds really ... the steering felt soft but was juddery under any acceleration - anyone any ideas re this ?

At normal wheel balance issue speeds of 75mph it was fine - just juddered particularly noticeably when accelerating from say 20-50 mph. Wear on the tyres was even and wheel balance it wasn't otherwise I would not expect it at low speeds and not higher.