Thinking of swapping cayman for a BMW am I mad?
Thinking of swapping cayman for a BMW am I mad?
Author
Discussion

chrispmartha

Original Poster:

23,746 posts

160 months

Friday 9th May 2014
quotequote all
I've got a 57 Cayman S which is on 63,000 miles so it's getting on a bit, now this is my everyday car and I'm self employed so can off set sme of the cost against my tax, but I'm seriously considering selling it and taking a lease out on a new car (not a pcp a straight lease) and I found myself drawn to the BMW showroom and really liking the look of the M235i, I've got a test drive booked tomorrow so it will be interesting to compare'

Have I gone a bit mad?

Bennachie

1,091 posts

182 months

Saturday 10th May 2014
quotequote all
Yes.

No hope I'm afraid.

Section yourself now before you do harm in the community.............

esuuv

1,421 posts

236 months

Saturday 10th May 2014
quotequote all
I have a 2008 Cayman thats done 53k - recently i felt the lure of a new car, 981 hasn't really depreciated enough yet - so i went to look at BMW's

I drove a 235 and a 428 - short story, I still have my Cayman!!

Mr Ping

262 posts

167 months

Friday 16th May 2014
quotequote all
I was in a BMW showroom the other day contemplating chopping in my honda jazz 2k special and had a poke around the cars. Nice cruisers but I would never trade the 996 in for one.

In fact in order to get more room for family outings I'm only considering the following;

1) Sack off the idea of a 997 and get a 991 for the extra room in the back when they reach poverty pork levels

2) Buying a 964 and feeding the missus less






HappyBoxster

214 posts

154 months

Friday 16th May 2014
quotequote all
Mr Ping said:
I was in a BMW showroom the other day contemplating chopping in my honda jazz 2k special and had a poke around the cars. Nice cruisers but I would never trade the 996 in for one.

In fact in order to get more room for family outings I'm only considering the following;

1) Sack off the idea of a 997 and get a 991 for the extra room in the back when they reach poverty pork levels

2) Buying a 964 and feeding the missus less
3) Buying a GT3 and not feeding the missus at all

cvega

467 posts

190 months

Friday 16th May 2014
quotequote all
hmm... let us know how the test drive goes.. I'm having the same dilemma, similar cayman S smile

Akajak

887 posts

270 months

Friday 16th May 2014
quotequote all
chrispmartha said:
I've got a 57 Cayman S which is on 63,000 miles so it's getting on a bit, now this is my everyday car and I'm self employed so can off set sme of the cost against my tax, but I'm seriously considering selling it and taking a lease out on a new car (not a pcp a straight lease) and I found myself drawn to the BMW showroom and really liking the look of the M235i, I've got a test drive booked tomorrow so it will be interesting to compare'

Have I gone a bit mad?
Autocar did a recent test; obvious results; cayman (not S) is the drivers car by a mile. BMW fast, good car, more practical (obviously)