Best speed camera detector...?
Best speed camera detector...?
Author
Discussion

E65Ross

Original Poster:

36,729 posts

241 months

Sunday 11th May 2014
quotequote all
Hi chaps,

After being caught the other I day I'm considering purchasing a speed camera detector. There are quite a few at varying prices online (will probably order via amazon) and wanted one which not only has static but obviously one which has a good mobile database as well as specs and is easy to update and so on.

My dad had a pogo alert which seemed very good, but a high annual subscription (I don't mind paying if I KNOW it's a good database with regular updates). It also showed your average speed as well as current speed through specs and so on, and had a nice clear display of the speed limit (as well as your current speed) but I've seen there are others such as road angel, snooper, talex etc.

Snooper 3zero seems quite good? But the Road Angel Gem+ Has a rechargeable battery which is quite a nice feature.... smile

Any thoughts on which is "best"?


Edited by E65Ross on Sunday 11th May 09:11

lesstatt

4,318 posts

219 months

Sunday 11th May 2014
quotequote all
I have a road angel with live updates, quite happy with it, subscription is around £50 a year, shows your speed, what the limit on the road you are on is and turns red if you are over it

Johnnytheboy

24,499 posts

215 months

Sunday 11th May 2014
quotequote all
Ditto, it's OK, the laser detector doesn't work.

How many posts before a know it all suggests mark one eyeball, and someone else just tells you to obey speed limits?

simonej

5,382 posts

209 months

Sunday 11th May 2014
quotequote all
Do they still do the radar detecting ones? Or are they rendered useless these days because once it detects the radar it's already too late?

richs2891

906 posts

282 months

Sunday 11th May 2014
quotequote all
It depends on what you have been caught on ?
2 years ago I was caught speed by S Yorks police who still use the old LTI (I think) laser to detect your speed.
There is not much against these, laser jammers / auto garage doors openers yes, although v little alert times and probably been clocked by the laser before the detector can alert you.

If it was a static camera there a few more options, Pogo as you have mentioned, road angel is one I have used in the past. Just make sure it has active subscription, and updated frequently.
Mine is old now about 6 years old and not used anymore, the latest ones have a live subscription which auto updates it self I believe which is clever so it know more about mobile speed traps.
If I start doing more mileage I will reconsider one, but the mapping technology with camera locations on smartphones is getting much better - almost making the Pogo / road angel obsolete in my eyes


Andehh

7,593 posts

235 months

Sunday 11th May 2014
quotequote all
Also interested in this!

E65Ross

Original Poster:

36,729 posts

241 months

Sunday 11th May 2014
quotequote all
richs2891 said:
It depends on what you have been caught on ?
2 years ago I was caught speed by S Yorks police who still use the old LTI (I think) laser to detect your speed.
There is not much against these, laser jammers / auto garage doors openers yes, although v little alert times and probably been clocked by the laser before the detector can alert you.

If it was a static camera there a few more options, Pogo as you have mentioned, road angel is one I have used in the past. Just make sure it has active subscription, and updated frequently.
Mine is old now about 6 years old and not used anymore, the latest ones have a live subscription which auto updates it self I believe which is clever so it know more about mobile speed traps.
If I start doing more mileage I will reconsider one, but the mapping technology with camera locations on smartphones is getting much better - almost making the Pogo / road angel obsolete in my eyes

This is what I was wondering, there are smartphone apps (I'm on android) but I wasn't sure whether the databases would be anywhere near as reliable as a "proper" unit, as it were. I'm downloaded CamSam plus (it was 99p!) but says the whole database has less than 500 mobile speed trap sites, and there are none within 50km of me, which is not true as I've seen a few near here....so hardly confidence inspiring.

Road angel seems to get pretty good reviews but just curious as to HOW good the database is. I was caught with a mobile gun. I'm not fussed about radar detection, but if the location is on the database then it should alert me prior to that, making it worthwhile.

Many thanks for further input guys smile

RenaultK4J

109 posts

205 months

Sunday 11th May 2014
quotequote all
Do the mobile cameras and the mobile laser ones have to be in designated places? I always thought they could just pitch up where they wanted to?

richs2891

906 posts

282 months

Sunday 11th May 2014
quotequote all
IF you have Nav Free installed on your phone, the camera add on is £2.99, compare that against yours ?

Gixer

4,463 posts

277 months

Sunday 11th May 2014
quotequote all
I have a Pogo for my Vettes and use a cordless Roadangel in my daily. Unfortunately Road Angel bought Pogo a couple of years back frown so the data base would now be the same.

Although the data base was better on the Pogo, (according to Road Angel, there's a camera van every half a mile down the road), the road angel is a 'connected' one so updates in real time so can warn of live camera vans if another uses has already been through and set the location active. Also, I'm not the best at getting in and plugging in the device to a pc to update the database every night or so. For that reason I would always go for a 'connected' one that updates as you drive.

As for laser traps from camera vans or plod, the only thing that will reliably work from them is going to be a jammer - and that could land you in trouble.

E65Ross

Original Poster:

36,729 posts

241 months

Sunday 11th May 2014
quotequote all
Gixer said:
I have a Pogo for my Vettes and use a cordless Roadangel in my daily. Unfortunately Road Angel bought Pogo a couple of years back frown so the data base would now be the same.

Although the data base was better on the Pogo, (according to Road Angel, there's a camera van every half a mile down the road), the road angel is a 'connected' one so updates in real time so can warn of live camera vans if another uses has already been through and set the location active. Also, I'm not the best at getting in and plugging in the device to a pc to update the database every night or so. For that reason I would always go for a 'connected' one that updates as you drive.

As for laser traps from camera vans or plod, the only thing that will reliably work from them is going to be a jammer - and that could land you in trouble.
Which do you prefer, the Pogo or Road Angel?

I've noticed there is "CamerAlert" app on android which uses the database from PocketGPSWorld which I used to use on my old Garmin Nuvi which seemed quite good, may be pretty good to try out?

Geekman

2,907 posts

175 months

Sunday 11th May 2014
quotequote all
E65Ross said:
Which do you prefer, the Pogo or Road Angel?

I've noticed there is "CamerAlert" app on android which uses the database from PocketGPSWorld which I used to use on my old Garmin Nuvi which seemed quite good, may be pretty good to try out?
I've found the alerts on my Garmin very, very good. It seems to err on the side of caution with regards to camera vans and speed traps, which I like - it's often popping up and telling me a particular road is a possible speed trap location even when it's not a regular spot for them.

Gixer

4,463 posts

277 months

Sunday 11th May 2014
quotequote all
E65Ross said:
Which do you prefer, the Pogo or Road Angel?

I've noticed there is "CamerAlert" app on android which uses the database from PocketGPSWorld which I used to use on my old Garmin Nuvi which seemed quite good, may be pretty good to try out?
Road angel is always up to date as it updates as you drive over the mobile network.

Pogo build quality is miles ahead and it did have a better database and was the only one to do the average speed through the roadworks. However, since the Road Angel take over, the data bases are joined, the road angel now does the average speed thing as well so it's just the build quality difference. But to be fair the road angle is used in my daily and I do 40k or so a year and its lasted a few years and is still going. Its always suffered from the dodgy on/off button but ive learnt to live with it and hopefully the new models are a bit better.I had to take it apart and replace the battery a while back but that was simple and its just a run of the mill battery easily found on the net.

As far a as I know TomTom uses the same database, so you could get a TomTom live sat nav and go that route as well.

DaveCWK

2,391 posts

203 months

Sunday 11th May 2014
quotequote all
I used to use the pocketgpsworld.com speed camera database on my TomTom. As a passive warnings system I believe it was/still is the best/most accurate system. You could customise the distance from the camera site the audible warning would go off, and it covered both fixed and mobile sites.

There was a large community behind it keeping it updated, but I couldn't get it to work on my newer tomTom so stopeed using it.

Riley Blue

23,205 posts

255 months

Sunday 11th May 2014
quotequote all
The most reliable database by far is the one from PocketGPSWorld. I wouldn't depend on the TomTom one and deleted it from my satnav as soon as I realised how poor it was.