Golf R versus GTi
Author
Discussion

CAH706

Original Poster:

2,221 posts

195 months

Tuesday 13th May 2014
quotequote all
Was all set to get the Golf R but having second thoughts. Now considering the GTi with the performance pack.

The R is quicker but.....

I prefer the look of the GTI and would have liked the carbon black
Boot space is better on the GTi
GTi is better on fuel
GTi doesn't need super fuel

The R is

4wd which is helpful
And did I say Quicker!


Cost wise (via company car scheme) there is £40 difference between the 2 so no great difference

Standard spec looks similar

Any thoughts on what I should get?


Actus Reus

4,312 posts

186 months

Tuesday 13th May 2014
quotequote all
CAH706 said:
Was all set to get the Golf R but having second thoughts. Now considering the GTi with the performance pack.

The R is quicker but.....

I prefer the look of the GTI and would have liked the carbon black
Boot space is better on the GTi
GTi is better on fuel
GTi doesn't need super fuel

The R is

4wd which is helpful
And did I say Quicker!
GTi is better looking in my view too - I like the red slash across the front. However, the R is still handsome enough. Colour choice isn't great though, I must admit. I don't really 'love' any of the colours - I too would have had carbon black.

Boot space, you can take the spare out and make up the difference - and it's not much of a difference to be honest.

GTi is better on fuel, but you can run the 'R' on 95 octane if you wish.

The R is that much quicker, and for me was only £5 a month more on the lease deals I looked at. Overall it depends on the use - will you really deploy the power and 4WD that often? If so - get the R. If it's mainly commuting, then get the GTi I guess, though in your shoes I know I'd wish I'd got the 'R'...

CAH706

Original Poster:

2,221 posts

195 months

Tuesday 13th May 2014
quotequote all
I think your last sentence sums up my thoughts......whilst it's my company car my wife will use it mainly. I think I'm swayed by the 4wd and the extra performance.

Thanks for the comments

Gio G

2,995 posts

240 months

Tuesday 13th May 2014
quotequote all
Actus Reus said:
Boot space, you can take the spare out and make up the difference - and it's not much of a difference to be honest.
This is starting to worry me a bit. What are the options if you take the spare out to create more room?

Thanks G

Actus Reus

4,312 posts

186 months

Tuesday 13th May 2014
quotequote all
It'd be a can of tyre sealant or a call to roadside assistance I suppose. It's only a 40l saving though, so not sure it's really worth it most of the time.

stabilio

621 posts

202 months

Tuesday 13th May 2014
quotequote all
Can the R definitely be run on regular 95 petrol?

Actus Reus

4,312 posts

186 months

Tuesday 13th May 2014
quotequote all
Yes, 110% - it just retards the ignition a bit so drops max power.

stabilio

621 posts

202 months

Tuesday 13th May 2014
quotequote all
Actus Reus said:
Yes, 110% - it just retards the ignition a bit so drops max power.
Thats good to know as will save me travelling 6 miles just to get fuel.
Out of interest how much power would it lose when filling with 95 and would filling with BP Ultimate (97) help more?

Actus Reus

4,312 posts

186 months

Tuesday 13th May 2014
quotequote all
Dunno what you'd lose - 10 or 20hp at very rough, uneducated guess. 97 should improve it somewhat, but the ignition will still be retarded somewhat. Depends on the software I should think - no doubt someone more educated than I will know more.

Iklwa

283 posts

160 months

Tuesday 13th May 2014
quotequote all
Actus Reus said:
Yes, 110% - it just retards the ignition a bit so drops max power.
So it becomes about as quick as a GTi with performance pack? Seems a bit counterproductive, if you are buying the R for it's performance, then I wouldn't want to retard it to try and reduce the running costs, rather get a GTi in that case.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 13th May 2014
quotequote all
Does anyone know what the power-to-weight difference is between a GTI PP and an R?

Legacywr

15,874 posts

219 months

Tuesday 13th May 2014
quotequote all
I haven't seen the R in the flesh yet, but, it would seem that the GTI is the better looking car, just as it was with the Mk5 and Mk6!

Patch1875

5,063 posts

163 months

Tuesday 13th May 2014
quotequote all
Currently got a mk6 gti just ordered today a mk7 gti

Not sure of the looks of the mk7 r yet especially the exhaust pipes still look much better mk6

Love the gti that's why I've gone for another one has everything I need in a car.


Legacywr

15,874 posts

219 months

Tuesday 13th May 2014
quotequote all
CAH706 said:
Was all set to get the Golf R but having second thoughts. Now considering the GTi with the performance pack.

The R is quicker but.....

I prefer the look of the GTI and would have liked the carbon black
Boot space is better on the GTi
GTi is better on fuel
GTi doesn't need super fuel

The R is

4wd which is helpful
And did I say Quicker!


Cost wise (via company car scheme) there is £40 difference between the 2 so no great difference

Standard spec looks similar

Any thoughts on what I should get?
Shirley, the £40 a week is a deal breaker? That's 40% more!!

And, just out of interest, did the company car rates change during the last budget?

CAH706

Original Poster:

2,221 posts

195 months

Tuesday 13th May 2014
quotequote all
£40 per month (tax inclusive) ... So not much difference. 40 per week and yes it would be a deal breaker.

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 13th May 2014
quotequote all
Patch1875 said:
Currently got a mk6 gti just ordered today a mk7 gti

Not sure of the looks of the mk7 r yet especially the exhaust pipes still look much better mk6

Love the gti that's why I've gone for another one has everything I need in a car.
I think the R certainly lacks the heritage the GTI has. It also has a far more developed visual language, the R looks rather bland, whereas the GTI is a really classy machine.

Legacywr

15,874 posts

219 months

Tuesday 13th May 2014
quotequote all
CAH706 said:
£40 per month (tax inclusive) ... So not much difference. 40 per week and yes it would be a deal breaker.
How are you getting to that figure?

I'm looking at a much bigger margin than that! That is with fuel though, and I do pay tax at 40%!

Actus Reus

4,312 posts

186 months

Tuesday 13th May 2014
quotequote all
andrewparker said:
I think the R certainly lacks the heritage the GTI has. It also has a far more developed visual language, the R looks rather bland, whereas the GTI is a really classy machine.
I agree to a point, but I don't think the differences are quite so substantial. The GTi has a much more established design language, whereas the R is still finding its way a bit there - give it 40 years though...

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 13th May 2014
quotequote all
Actus Reus said:
andrewparker said:
I think the R certainly lacks the heritage the GTI has. It also has a far more developed visual language, the R looks rather bland, whereas the GTI is a really classy machine.
I agree to a point, but I don't think the differences are quite so substantial. The GTi has a much more established design language, whereas the R is still finding its way a bit there - give it 40 years though...
I'm just not sure they're trying hard enough though. What has carried through from the R32 to the MK6 R to the latest car? Just the signature colour and the R logo to my eyes...

The differences might not appear substantial, but the subtleties of the GTI all add up to create a really coherent look.

zeduffman

4,331 posts

182 months

Tuesday 13th May 2014
quotequote all
Iklwa said:
So it becomes about as quick as a GTi with performance pack? Seems a bit counterproductive, if you are buying the R for it's performance, then I wouldn't want to retard it to try and reduce the running costs, rather get a GTi in that case.
Would it really drop 25% power? You still get the 4wd as well.

Ultimately they are quite different cars, hence why they both exist and they aren't too different price-wise.

Another option is the Cupra 280. Power to weight to match the R, plus the tricky diff from the GTI. Just no Haldex option. I don't know where it stands on running costs though.

Edited by zeduffman on Tuesday 13th May 22:36