is this a repair or write-off?
is this a repair or write-off?
Author
Discussion

AlVal

Original Poster:

1,891 posts

293 months

Saturday 17th May 2014
quotequote all
Kid in a corsa slammed into the back of me while I was stationary in a queue of traffic. Waiting for repair shop to contact me to take the car in, but curious what you experienced folks think - will it be repaired or written off?



wiliferus

4,214 posts

227 months

Saturday 17th May 2014
quotequote all
I'm guessing there's a picture coming?

Eta - as if by magic it appears!

I'm not too familiar with the construction of your car, but looks mainly like plastic panel damage. Doesn't mean it'll be cheap to repair though! I'm guessing they'll repair that.

Edited by wiliferus on Saturday 17th May 07:20

Deerfoot

5,240 posts

213 months

Saturday 17th May 2014
quotequote all
That will be repaired.

Ozzie Osmond

21,189 posts

275 months

Saturday 17th May 2014
quotequote all
Who was driving the Corsa,

Joker?
Riddler?
Penguin?
Mad Hatter?
Two-face?

STW2010

5,918 posts

191 months

Saturday 17th May 2014
quotequote all
I think that would be repaired, as the age of your car probably means that it's still worth a decent amount. Looks like the boot floor will be creased though, so it won't be a cheap fix for the insurance company.

If it is written off I reckon that would be no worse than cat-d.

Crafty_

14,084 posts

229 months

Saturday 17th May 2014
quotequote all
Does the boot open and close ok ? pull up the carpet and look for floorpan damage in the boot.

If there is floor damage cost will be higher, but even then it would have to be quite bad to be written off.

Leptons

5,493 posts

205 months

Saturday 17th May 2014
quotequote all
IQ? The boot floor is about 3 inches long so you that's probably the entire crumple zone.

Glassman

24,943 posts

244 months

Saturday 17th May 2014
quotequote all
Did the shunt pop the rear door open?

HairyMaclary

3,775 posts

224 months

Saturday 17th May 2014
quotequote all
Bad luck! I'd guess at a write off.

Random question... Why do people de-wiper their cars? Surely a its kind of a useful feature?

rb5er

11,657 posts

201 months

Saturday 17th May 2014
quotequote all
More to the point....is that a Batman badge on the back?

HertsBiker

6,443 posts

300 months

Saturday 17th May 2014
quotequote all
Holy smoke! That looks like repair to me.

p4cks

7,488 posts

228 months

Saturday 17th May 2014
quotequote all

framerateuk

2,941 posts

213 months

Saturday 17th May 2014
quotequote all
Depends. If the crumple zone behind the boot is damaged, it might not be worthwhile to fix that and the other parts. If it's just the bumper, then they'll probably repair it.

Someone took out the passenger door and rear quarter of my Megane last year. Ended up being repaired as it was all just panel damage. So long as it's nothing structural, then there's a good chance they'll repair it.

kiethton

14,639 posts

209 months

Saturday 17th May 2014
quotequote all
Value of your car - £6k?

In 2007 my 3.5 year old pug 206 worth about £4.5k was rear ended, twice in 6 months.

On both occasions it had a new hatch, boot floor, rear slam panel (welded), bumper, well everything rear of the back axle, including shocks and rear wing repairs where they creased with the impact (44 tonne lorry then a grand Cherokee).

It was repaired both times. I sold it shortly after no. 2

kiethton

14,639 posts

209 months

Saturday 17th May 2014
quotequote all
To add, the boot wouldn't work in either case, well it opened with some persuasion but had to be stuck back with gaffer tape

kiethton

14,639 posts

209 months

Saturday 17th May 2014
quotequote all
To add, the boot wouldn't work in either case, well it opened with some persuasion but had to be stuck back with gaffer tape

AlVal

Original Poster:

1,891 posts

293 months

Saturday 17th May 2014
quotequote all
kiethton said:
Value of your car - £6k?

In 2007 my 3.5 year old pug 206 worth about £4.5k was rear ended, twice in 6 months.

On both occasions it had a new hatch, boot floor, rear slam panel (welded), bumper, well everything rear of the back axle, including shocks and rear wing repairs where they creased with the impact (44 tonne lorry then a grand Cherokee).

It was repaired both times. I sold it shortly after no. 2
jeez - must be a fair jolt when getting shunted by a 44 tonne lorry - This was just a corsa yet it's left me really sore.

Insurance seems really on the ball - I'm with AXA, they very quickly got the job through to local bodyshop, estimater already looked this morning at it, and now the corsa's insurer churchill is very keen to take on the case directly, which I guess makes sense as it means less administration.

If I ring my insurance company axa and tell them to forget about it, the other guy's insurer will deal directly with me in getting it sorted, I'm thinking that would be better for me, as I could presumably then when taking out future insurance still say that I've never made a claim? whereas if I go through my insurance and they claim it back from churchill, then I suppose I do have to answer yes, I made a claim? (because they always ask that question "regardless of fault", don't they?)

Edited by AlVal on Saturday 17th May 12:33

dowahdiddyman

965 posts

240 months

Saturday 17th May 2014
quotequote all
I once owner a Rover 400 which when it was 4 yrs old got rear ended, boot, bumper, driver side rear, lights etc. Was praying they would write it off but they had it repaired.

wiliferus

4,214 posts

227 months

Saturday 17th May 2014
quotequote all
AlVal said:
jeez - must be a fair jolt when getting shunted by a 44 tonne lorry - This was just a corsa yet it's left me really sore.

Insurance seems really on the ball - I'm with AXA, they very quickly got the job through to local bodyshop, estimater already looked this morning at it, and now the corsa's insurer churchill is very keen to take on the case directly, which I guess makes sense as it means less administration.

If I ring my insurance company axa and tell them to forget about it, the other guy's insurer will deal directly with me in getting it sorted, I'm thinking that would be better for me, as I could presumably then when taking out future insurance still say that I've never made a claim? whereas if I go through my insurance and they claim it back from churchill, then I suppose I do have to answer yes, I made a claim? (because they always ask that question "regardless of fault", don't they?)

Edited by AlVal on Saturday 17th May 12:33
Too late - you've declared it now. When you apply for insurance it'll say something to the effect of 'Have you had any accidents or claims in the last 5 years'. Whether your insurance company paid out is irrelevant.

aspirated

2,540 posts

175 months

Saturday 17th May 2014
quotequote all
p4cks said:
Genuine LOL rofl