Early Gallardo eGear vs F430 F1?
Early Gallardo eGear vs F430 F1?
Author
Discussion

Mario149

Original Poster:

7,789 posts

209 months

Wednesday 28th May 2014
quotequote all
How do the systems compare? I'm curious as hypothetically if I sold my 550 in the next year or so it would likely be a Gallardo or F430 I'd replace it with. While paddles aren't my thing ideally, I have it in my head that the Ferrari system is okay but the Lambo one is rather pants for some reason....

70proof

6,158 posts

186 months

Wednesday 28th May 2014
quotequote all
the gallardo system is not lightning fast... but it makes parking a supercar dead easy
it is also not as bad as everyone harps on, i've just bought another e gear car....
key is when upchanging, to just lift a bit, lift yor toe so to speak....
gets better as the model years go on, even for pre-facelift, due to software reprogramming

EpsomJames

790 posts

277 months

Wednesday 28th May 2014
quotequote all
They both use Graziano automated manual single clutch transmissions (also used by Aston Martin in Sportshift cars, Maserati in some cars and of course Audi in the R-tronic R8).

There may be slight differences due to the layout of the gearbox and in the software (which can be re-programmed), but esentially they are the same.

jeremyc

28,404 posts

315 months

Wednesday 28th May 2014
quotequote all
Or, the alternative solution ... biggrin


Craigwww

853 posts

200 months

Thursday 29th May 2014
quotequote all
jeremyc said:
Or, the alternative solution ... biggrin

What's that metal ball on the end of the stick thing?


andrew

10,368 posts

223 months

Thursday 29th May 2014
quotequote all
EpsomJames said:
They both use Graziano automated manual single clutch transmissions (also used by Aston Martin in Sportshift cars, Maserati in some cars and of course Audi in the R-tronic R8).

There may be slight differences due to the layout of the gearbox and in the software (which can be re-programmed), but esentially they are the same.
i do wish that people would stop quoting facts like this : it really messes-up the which is best debates !

good point re the s/w upgrades ( which i've had to ask for ), system also recalibrated at the same time

EpsomJames

790 posts

277 months

Thursday 29th May 2014
quotequote all
andrew said:
EpsomJames said:
They both use Graziano automated manual single clutch transmissions (also used by Aston Martin in Sportshift cars, Maserati in some cars and of course Audi in the R-tronic R8).

There may be slight differences due to the layout of the gearbox and in the software (which can be re-programmed), but esentially they are the same.
i do wish that people would stop quoting facts like this : it really messes-up the which is best debates !

good point re the s/w upgrades ( which i've had to ask for ), system also recalibrated at the same time
The Lambo obviously has the best system wink

hazy

1,174 posts

299 months

Thursday 29th May 2014
quotequote all
Simple answer.

Pull the up paddle in the F430 and it changes gear

Pull the up paddle in the Lambo and it changes gear whilst simutaneously smashing you in the spine and making the whole drivetrain sudder.

Mario149

Original Poster:

7,789 posts

209 months

Thursday 29th May 2014
quotequote all
hazy said:
Simple answer.

Pull the up paddle in the F430 and it changes gear

Pull the up paddle in the Lambo and it changes gear whilst simutaneously smashing you in the spine and making the whole drivetrain sudder.
hehe

Only paddleshift I've owned was a 2003 Maser 4200 (i.e. updated Cambiocorsa system) and as much as I liked the car, the gearshift was dire. Any one driven one of them and an eGear? If so, how do they compare to each other?

EpsomJames

790 posts

277 months

Thursday 29th May 2014
quotequote all
hazy said:
Simple answer.

Pull the up paddle in the F430 and it changes gear

Pull the up paddle in the Lambo and it changes gear whilst simutaneously smashing you in the spine and making the whole drivetrain sudder.
A software difference.

The Lambo's change is perfectly smooth if you learn how to drive it. wink

hazy

1,174 posts

299 months

Thursday 29th May 2014
quotequote all
EpsomJames said:
A software difference.

The Lambo's change is perfectly smooth if you learn how to drive it. wink
Oh I can drive em fine, lift off just a touch and they change as sweet as you like, Lambo lacks the racing pedigee and therefore knowledge to be able to make their cars change gear properly under full throttle, thats all.

GRBF430F1

4,843 posts

201 months

Thursday 29th May 2014
quotequote all
My e-gear is as smooth as a baby's bum and the faster you drive it the better the gear change gets. Having had both F1 and E-gear I would say the 2012 E-gear is better than my 2009 F1 but maybe I'm just a good driver

ZeusF

377 posts

154 months

Thursday 29th May 2014
quotequote all
egear is astonishing, much better than manual.
as for which is better, hard to say.
Ive always been a ferrari fan but my 560 is faster than my f430.

ZeusF

377 posts

154 months

Thursday 29th May 2014
quotequote all
egear is astonishing, much better than manual.
as for which is better, hard to say.
Ive always been a ferrari fan but my 560 is faster than my f430.

Sarnie

8,379 posts

240 months

Friday 30th May 2014
quotequote all
Feels like 2006 again......just need a thread on clutches now... smile

andrew

10,368 posts

223 months

Friday 30th May 2014
quotequote all
biggrin

Russell996

494 posts

160 months

Friday 30th May 2014
quotequote all
Do Lamborghini publish figures for gear change speeds and the differences between modes, never seen anything for the Gallardo eGear.

70proof

6,158 posts

186 months

Friday 30th May 2014
quotequote all
ZeusF said:
egear is astonishing, much better than manual.
as for which is better, hard to say.
Ive always been a ferrari fan but my 560 is faster than my f430.
Zeus - dont you re-programme the software?

hazy

1,174 posts

299 months

Friday 30th May 2014
quotequote all
GRBF430F1 said:
My e-gear is as smooth as a baby's bum and the faster you drive it the better the gear change gets. Having had both F1 and E-gear I would say the 2012 E-gear is better than my 2009 F1 but maybe I'm just a good driver
PMSL, they smash there way through the gears on full bore changes, all of them. You have never noticed coz you have never got the throttle pedal all the way to the bottom to touch the R8 carpet. biggrinbiggrinbiggrin