Cam Belt Failure - Audi A3 2.0TDI
Discussion
I wonder if anyone can offer any advice? I had my cam belt changed at a local Halfords Autocentre back in December and was happily driving home on Sunday and it failed. Called the AA etc etc and had car dropped back at the garage.
Basically they are saying it's parts failure, and I'm sure the parts supplier will say workmanship but I am getting nowhere.
No replacement car and I'm having to constantly chase Halfords to which I now feel I'm being ignored. The parts have apparently been sent away to be x-rayed? and they have also sent away the water pump which wasn't changed when they did replaced cam belt?
Are they going to try and use the water pump as a get out? The initial prognosis from the Autocentre manager was a tensioning bolt snapping?
Thanks in advance guys/girls
Basically they are saying it's parts failure, and I'm sure the parts supplier will say workmanship but I am getting nowhere.
No replacement car and I'm having to constantly chase Halfords to which I now feel I'm being ignored. The parts have apparently been sent away to be x-rayed? and they have also sent away the water pump which wasn't changed when they did replaced cam belt?
Are they going to try and use the water pump as a get out? The initial prognosis from the Autocentre manager was a tensioning bolt snapping?
Thanks in advance guys/girls
That's the only thing I'm concerned about Matty, I did ask them at the time if they would be changing that too but they said only if it needed it? Still not sure about his original comment of a tension bolt snapping though and how this is connected to water pump failure. Then again I'm no expert!
It is no doubt the tensioner stud that has snapped. It is a common failure with these engines, usually not long after a cambelt change. The bolt on the stud should be tightened to 25Nm plus 45 degrees, fine for a brand new stud, possibly too much the second time. VW didn't used to include a new stud with their kit, apparently they now do. Gates have supplied one for ages.
http://www.audi.co.uk/owners-area/servicing-mainte...
Audi dealer fixed price cam belts for cars over 3 years old and 2.0L or less, inc 2.0TDI
Free MOT for life if we do your belt
2 Years parts warranty.
£449
That tensioner stud (not bolt) can cause the tensioner to go slack if it fails.
Damage varies from none at all, new parts on time up and all is well, to needing a rebuilt cyclinderhead.
Hope they find a part failure and you get it all fixed for free.
If the stud has failed and they didnt replace it, and they suggest its not their doing because they didnt replace that part, you need to imply they overtightened the nut and caused the stud to fail.
Damage varies from none at all, new parts on time up and all is well, to needing a rebuilt cyclinderhead.
Hope they find a part failure and you get it all fixed for free.
If the stud has failed and they didnt replace it, and they suggest its not their doing because they didnt replace that part, you need to imply they overtightened the nut and caused the stud to fail.
simondr said:
Thanks for all your comments guys....helpful or otherwise!
Have now heard back and I'm apparently getting new engine at no cost to me! Guessing it's a re-manufactured one but it'll be one I won't be paying for :-)
thanks again!
They are fairly well known for paying out when they mess up. I wouldn't dream of having work done there, but it is an advantage of a large corporate that it's not a big deal to them to put it right.Have now heard back and I'm apparently getting new engine at no cost to me! Guessing it's a re-manufactured one but it'll be one I won't be paying for :-)
thanks again!
Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




