help me choose, which one?

[no effort]

I want a new watch but I can't decide which one to get.

The first watch is a Tag Monaco limited edition.

http://www.tagheuer.co.uk/int-en/luxury-watches/mo...

I've always liked the Monaco and i really like the dial colours of this limited edition especially as it looses the "tag" naming. Not to keen on a leather strap but it doesn't look right with a steel bracelet.


The second watch is a Rolex milgauss.

http://www.rolex.com/watches/milgauss/m116400gv-00...

I don't why I'm drawn to this watch but I just am. It only came on my radar a week ago although I'm not keen on the lighting bolt second hand.

Which one would you choose?

[BHC]

Have you ever tried on a Monaco? A lot of people (including me) find that they just don't fit very well. If you fall into that category, it should make the decision easier.

[no effort]

No I haven't.

[Codswallop]

I'd get the Milgauss and then take it somewhere to get a normal second hand fitted.

[BHC]

Then I recommend that first you try a Monaco!

[gbbird]

Codswallop said:

I'd get the Milgauss and then take it somewhere to get a normal second hand fitted.

Me too. The second hand is horrendous

[mikeveal]

The watch was designed for power plant workers. It's anti-magnetic, supposedly to deal with the large electromagnetic fields in a power plant. Which is why the second hand is shaped like a bolt of lightening.

[Skipppy]

Milgauss for me.

[ed335d]

They're poles apart in terms of styling and functionality. I've never really 'got' the Monaco, so it would be the Rolex for me (it's also likely to have a better residual value if that's a concern).

Plenty out there that's a bit different from the norm at that price point. Might be worth a 'what could I buy for £x' type post for a few more suggestions, just to see if there's anything else grabs you.

Or just buy both!

[R6VED]

My personal choice would definitely be the Rolex. I am biased as I own a Rolex Explorer 214270 but I think the Rolex would suit many more occasions than the Tag.

Within the world of WIS there seems to be a lot of ill feeling towards Tag, in fairness opinion is pretty split on Rolex too :-)

[Maxf]

Milgauss for me - just dont get the green glass one - its the emperor's new (old) clothes IMO and the normal black dialed one is much nicer.

[silverback mike]

I'm a bit of a Rolex fanboy, and prefer the look of the Milgaus, I don't mind the second hand either

[no effort]

Maxf said:

Milgauss for me - just dont get the green glass one - its the emperor's new (old) clothes IMO and the normal black dialed one is much nicer.

I like the green.

There's a couple of other watches I quite like but regardless of branding I still find the Tag striking to look at.

[avinalarf]

I have tried on the Tag recently and very much liked it.
A very attractive watch,solid feel,of course you'll never go wrong with the Rolex either so difficult decision.
If you are concerned about depreciation get the Rolex.

[marcosgt]

I've always quite fancied a Monaco, but not that one (or the Gulf ones so many seem to work themselves into a frenzy over...), so it'd be the Milgauss for me (one of the few Rolexes I like).

If it was a white on black faced Chrono Monaco, I'd probably reverse my decision.

M

[avinalarf]

marcosgt said:

I've always quite fancied a Monaco, but not that one (or the Gulf ones so many seem to work themselves into a frenzy over...), so it'd be the Milgauss for me (one of the few Rolexes I like).

If it was a white on black faced Chrono Monaco, I'd probably reverse my decision.

M

I quite understand where you are coming from in your comment but venture to disagree ,( in a pleasant manner ).
On the basis that the Tag ,although respected,will depreciate a lot ,the Monaco Calibre 11 is a highly distinctive and individual bit of kit.
Your choice is,albeit classic and arguably "smarter" ,does not have quite the same unique appeal.
On the basis of the above I would probably go for the timeless appeal of the Rolex which has the kudos of the brand.

Edited by avinalarf on Wednesday 18th June 12:52

[Cotty]

no effort said:

Maxf said:

Milgauss for me - just dont get the green glass one - its the emperor's new (old) clothes IMO and the normal black dialed one is much nicer.

I like the green.

So do I, it the one I would go for.

[marcosgt]

avinalarf said:

marcosgt said:

I've always quite fancied a Monaco, but not that one (or the Gulf ones so many seem to work themselves into a frenzy over...), so it'd be the Milgauss for me (one of the few Rolexes I like).

If it was a white on black faced Chrono Monaco, I'd probably reverse my decision.

M

I quite understand where you are coming from in your comment but venture to disagree ,( in a pleasant manner ).
On the basis that the Tag ,although respected,will depreciate a lot ,the Monaco Calibre 11 is a highly distinctive and individual bit of kit.
Your choice is,albeit classic and arguably "smarter" ,does not have quite the same unique appeal.
On the basis of the above I would probably go for the timeless appeal of the Rolex which has the kudos of the brand.

I don't disagree with anything you say, but if it was my money, I wouldn't buy THAT Monaco.

Buying most new watches is going to lose you money even over 10-15 years, and certainly over 2-3, so the only reason is to get something you like.

I don't like that Monaco, but I do like the standard ones, so I'd be happy spending my money on one of those (probably a used one, though)

M

[avinalarf]

marcosgt said:

I don't disagree with anything you say, but if it was my money, I wouldn't buy THAT Monaco.

Buying most new watches is going to lose you money even over 10-15 years, and certainly over 2-3, so the only reason is to get something you like.

I don't like that Monaco, but I do like the standard ones, so I'd be happy spending my money on one of those (probably a used one, though)

M

I now understand that you were commenting on a purely subjective basis and therefore it is obviously your choice.
I am new to this forum and I am learning more as I go along.
I am surprised how many of you have quite a large collection of watches.
I've basically had the same Seiko watch for 30 years with a 18ct Omega De Ville and a classic JLC both dated from the 1960's that I inherited but rarely wear.
I can however well understand the enthusiasm of you guys as it is very infectious.

Edited by avinalarf on Wednesday 18th June 14:13

[marcosgt]

avinalarf said:

I now understand that you were commenting on a purely subjective basis and therefore it is obviously your choice.
I am new to this forum and I am learning more as I go along.
I am surprised how many of you have quite a large collection of watches.
I've basically had the same Seiko watch for 30 years with a 18ct Omega De Ville and a classic JLC both dated from the 1960's that I inherited but rarely wear.
I can however well understand the enthusiasm of you guys as it is very infectious.

Leave now, whilst your sanity and bank balance are intact!

M