Problems with Golf R's on leases
Problems with Golf R's on leases
Author
Discussion

Phil117

Original Poster:

1,538 posts

170 months

Friday 20th June 2014
quotequote all
Guys, just an update as some people have been getting calls from their dealers saying they can't offer contract hire.

If you don't want to read the whole thing, this basically sums it up: Don't panic. Nothing is confirmed, just some internal politics at Volkswagen going on. I will let you know for definite once I know myself.



All,

I would just reply to other thread but got banned from posting in there as I told some one an offer in the thread so PH have rightly said I can't advertise - apologies PH - just trying to help some fellow PHers out!

As of 4pm & later at 5:30pm this afternoon, all Volkswagen dealers have been advised the below points.

Before I explain the details, let me just sum up the details of these leases.

In the past, Volkswagen has only offered leases to business. They would much prefer you to take out their "PCP" product because it makes them more money; and secondly, it is meant to increase customer retention as a lot of people think they have to PCP with the same manufacturer. In Q2 2014, Volkswagen have introduced a separate finance product called "Personal Contract Hire". This is only currently available on certain models in the range such as Touaregs and Passats. The reason they have gone down this route is more and more people are taking out what are precised as "personal" leases, and this is the way the car buying market is going so they are trying to move with it.


Because of the lack of this PCH route, in the past and current, many Volkswagen dealers, myself included, have still provided private individuals leases. They have always been proposed as a "Sole Trader". Anyone with these agreements will have the agreement in the name of Mr John Smith T/A.

Because a Sole Trader isn't a separate entity like a Limited Company, all the finance checks are done on the personal individual's finance, not the companies. The finance is still in the individuals name, however Volkswagen give you better rates as they believe you are a business. All the prices for sole traders quotes also include VAT to reflect this as many sole traders aren't vat registered, so can't claim the money, just like us private individuals.

Hopefully that sums up what these lease deals are, and why there is the confusion between if it's actual personal or a business lease.

It's also worth nothing, every other car manufacture's fleet department work in the same way.



So back to this announcement from Volkswagen UK. Because of a HUGE influx of Golf R orders and open publicity (mainly on online forums), people are getting dirt cheap quotes. A lot of customers have then gone into a Volkswagen retailer to test drive a Golf R, they have often showed them a quote they had from online which is roughly £200-£300 a month less than what they as a retailer were offering.

Because of so many people doing this, the retail departments have caused a massive uproar because they are loosing business to fleet departments because of such a huge difference in monthly cost. Due to all this uproar, Volkswagen have released this statement today. (It's worth noting, Volkswagen are FULLY aware about these business leases for private individuals, 70% of sole trader proposals are for private individuals).

Because of tons of Golf R orders through fleet at the moment any Golf R (again, worth nothing only Golf R's in question here; you could still get a GTI/GTD/Scircco/Touareg etc. without a problem) put through as a sole trader will not be accepted without proof of them being a sole trader to try make these customers go back to retail. This was announced at 4pm today.

However, as many people have commented, a lot of these Golf R customers would not conventionally be considering a Volkswagen, let alone a Golf R. Volkswagen believe customers who were interested in these dirt cheap Golf R's are going to go back to retail and pay £300 a month for them. I think not.

So, at 5:30 another later statement was released from Volkswagen UK because in the space of an hour, they had lost roughly 500+ orders on Golf R's which are for private individuals. Because the senior management of Volkswagen couldn't care less how you fund your vehicle and just want a Volkswagen unit sale to make them look better, they have taken a slight U turn.

They have given us dealer the following ultimatum.

1) Provide a VAT number for the sole trader, or a business bank account statement (many real sole trader who are new to being a S/T will actually loose out on this as they probably don't have either as it'll be through a personal bank account).

Or 2) If it is actually a private individual, then Volkswagen UK area sales managers who look after the targets for 10 or so dealerships will contact us retailers to discuss our options further. All this will be is Volkswagen UK covering their own back, advising us dealers that strictly speaking these deals are for business users, and if us retailers ignore this message (which I'm sure we won't be advised to do wink ), we can still offer leases the same way we have done for the last 3 years.


I think this has all just snowballed, and as Volkswagen UK don't work weekends, the outcome is unclear, and we won't know until Monday what's happening.

My honest opinion will be this is just to show the retail departments that they are clamping down on us fleet departments. In truth, it's probably just to be seen like they're doing the right thing. I would hope that nothing will change, so don't panic or agree to go PCP over the weekend until it's all fully clarified.

What's most important to Volkswagen is registrations. Lots and lots of registration.



Hope that answered some of your questions.

Sorry it's rather long, but it's a little complicated. Mainly just down to internal politics BS.



Edited by Phil117 on Friday 20th June 20:59

DUMBO100

1,878 posts

215 months

Friday 20th June 2014
quotequote all
Good info, cheers for sharing

Juicetin1

647 posts

221 months

Friday 20th June 2014
quotequote all
Phil are you going to post that up on the R Forum? Might be worth doing.

Update...noticed you already have.

Edited by Juicetin1 on Friday 20th June 21:29

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Friday 20th June 2014
quotequote all
Useful info thanks for posting. Explains why I've had problems in the past when I've gone into Audi, SEAT and VW with cheap lease quotes from online and they haven't been able to match them. Guess this is the first time it's happened on such a large scale. Still find it a bit weird that they seem to be dumping so many of these on the market. Will reduce the residual values and water down the exclusivity of the R brand. The Mk6 R was quite a rare car but looks like the Mk7 will be as common as the GTI.

rhysmoreton

223 posts

170 months

Friday 20th June 2014
quotequote all
va1o said:
Useful info thanks for posting. Explains why I've had problems in the past when I've gone into Audi, SEAT and VW with cheap lease quotes from online and they haven't been able to match them. Guess this is the first time it's happened on such a large scale. Still find it a bit weird that they seem to be dumping so many of these on the market. Will reduce the residual values and water down the exclusivity of the R brand. The Mk6 R was quite a rare car but looks like the Mk7 will be as common as the GTI.
There's been several hundred orders, and I believe 300ish or more first time round of deals, that's probably much less than the rest of the golf fleet. I've yet to see one in Wales!

Phil117

Original Poster:

1,538 posts

170 months

Friday 20th June 2014
quotequote all
va1o said:
Useful info thanks for posting. Explains why I've had problems in the past when I've gone into Audi, SEAT and VW with cheap lease quotes from online and they haven't been able to match them. Guess this is the first time it's happened on such a large scale. Still find it a bit weird that they seem to be dumping so many of these on the market. Will reduce the residual values and water down the exclusivity of the R brand. The Mk6 R was quite a rare car but looks like the Mk7 will be as common as the GTI.
I see three every day.

The one on the drive, the one on the drive at my brothers house, and the second demo at the dealership.

Ha.

When I'm driving around at the moment, I've been pointed at a lot recently. It tends to be couples, and the man is pointing out the car to the other half. Probably one of us sad gits looking at these offers saying to her "that's the car I was telling you we can get for £200 a month"...

If you the are couple doing that today outside of Zurich reading this, hello!

n4aat

471 posts

243 months

Saturday 21st June 2014
quotequote all
Phil117 said:
Guys, just an update as some people have been getting calls from their dealers saying they can't offer contract hire.

If you don't want to read the whole thing, this basically sums it up: Don't panic. Nothing is confirmed, just some internal politics at Volkswagen going on. I will let you know for definite once I know myself.



All,

I would just reply to other thread but got banned from posting in there as I told some one an offer in the thread so PH have rightly said I can't advertise - apologies PH - just trying to help some fellow PHers out!

As of 4pm & later at 5:30pm this afternoon, all Volkswagen dealers have been advised the below points.

Before I explain the details, let me just sum up the details of these leases.

In the past, Volkswagen has only offered leases to business. They would much prefer you to take out their "PCP" product because it makes them more money; and secondly, it is meant to increase customer retention as a lot of people think they have to PCP with the same manufacturer. In Q2 2014, Volkswagen have introduced a separate finance product called "Personal Contract Hire". This is only currently available on certain models in the range such as Touaregs and Passats. The reason they have gone down this route is more and more people are taking out what are precised as "personal" leases, and this is the way the car buying market is going so they are trying to move with it.


Because of the lack of this PCH route, in the past and current, many Volkswagen dealers, myself included, have still provided private individuals leases. They have always been proposed as a "Sole Trader". Anyone with these agreements will have the agreement in the name of Mr John Smith T/A.

Because a Sole Trader isn't a separate entity like a Limited Company, all the finance checks are done on the personal individual's finance, not the companies. The finance is still in the individuals name, however Volkswagen give you better rates as they believe you are a business. All the prices for sole traders quotes also include VAT to reflect this as many sole traders aren't vat registered, so can't claim the money, just like us private individuals.

Hopefully that sums up what these lease deals are, and why there is the confusion between if it's actual personal or a business lease.

It's also worth nothing, every other car manufacture's fleet department work in the same way.



So back to this announcement from Volkswagen UK. Because of a HUGE influx of Golf R orders and open publicity (mainly on online forums), people are getting dirt cheap quotes. A lot of customers have then gone into a Volkswagen retailer to test drive a Golf R, they have often showed them a quote they had from online which is roughly £200-£300 a month less than what they as a retailer were offering.

Because of so many people doing this, the retail departments have caused a massive uproar because they are loosing business to fleet departments because of such a huge difference in monthly cost. Due to all this uproar, Volkswagen have released this statement today. (It's worth noting, Volkswagen are FULLY aware about these business leases for private individuals, 70% of sole trader proposals are for private individuals).

Because of tons of Golf R orders through fleet at the moment any Golf R (again, worth nothing only Golf R's in question here; you could still get a GTI/GTD/Scircco/Touareg etc. without a problem) put through as a sole trader will not be accepted without proof of them being a sole trader to try make these customers go back to retail. This was announced at 4pm today.

However, as many people have commented, a lot of these Golf R customers would not conventionally be considering a Volkswagen, let alone a Golf R. Volkswagen believe customers who were interested in these dirt cheap Golf R's are going to go back to retail and pay £300 a month for them. I think not.

So, at 5:30 another later statement was released from Volkswagen UK because in the space of an hour, they had lost roughly 500+ orders on Golf R's which are for private individuals. Because the senior management of Volkswagen couldn't care less how you fund your vehicle and just want a Volkswagen unit sale to make them look better, they have taken a slight U turn.

They have given us dealer the following ultimatum.

1) Provide a VAT number for the sole trader, or a business bank account statement (many real sole trader who are new to being a S/T will actually loose out on this as they probably don't have either as it'll be through a personal bank account).

Or 2) If it is actually a private individual, then Volkswagen UK area sales managers who look after the targets for 10 or so dealerships will contact us retailers to discuss our options further. All this will be is Volkswagen UK covering their own back, advising us dealers that strictly speaking these deals are for business users, and if us retailers ignore this message (which I'm sure we won't be advised to do wink ), we can still offer leases the same way we have done for the last 3 years.


I think this has all just snowballed, and as Volkswagen UK don't work weekends, the outcome is unclear, and we won't know until Monday what's happening.

My honest opinion will be this is just to show the retail departments that they are clamping down on us fleet departments. In truth, it's probably just to be seen like they're doing the right thing. I would hope that nothing will change, so don't panic or agree to go PCP over the weekend until it's all fully clarified.

What's most important to Volkswagen is registrations. Lots and lots of registration.



Hope that answered some of your questions.

Sorry it's rather long, but it's a little complicated. Mainly just down to internal politics BS.



Edited by Phil117 on Friday 20th June 20:59
Thanks for the info Phil.

I have one on order and currently a soletrader. But only for a couple more weeks. Plus I am not VAT registered and I use my personal account for business purposes. Do you think VW would accept self-assessment tax returns proving status instead?

Many thanks,
Nat

Phil117

Original Poster:

1,538 posts

170 months

Saturday 21st June 2014
quotequote all
n4aat said:
Thanks for the info Phil.

I have one on order and currently a soletrader. But only for a couple more weeks. Plus I am not VAT registered and I use my personal account for business purposes. Do you think VW would accept self-assessment tax returns proving status instead?

Many thanks,
Nat
Funny enough we were discussing this over on the R forum in some detail. Exactly what you said, many s/t's like yourself don't have a business account or are Vat registered.

If you are genuinely a sole trader, 100% you will get through. Some proof will be enough. It's just Volkswagen wanting to cover their own back.

One idea I came up with, for those who aren't actually sole traders, is to just go the B&Q and Wickes and buy some tiny bits, and obviously a McDonalds drive through; and give them your bank statement saying your a tiny builder so not VAT registered and use your personal bank account and that's all you have.

But yes, don't worry.If you a s/t it will be fine.

TimmD

278 posts

237 months

Saturday 21st June 2014
quotequote all
Hi,
Just to add to your comments, I am only looking at a Golf R because of the deal. I would never get one on a traditional retail route.

Thanks

Tim

n4aat

471 posts

243 months

Saturday 21st June 2014
quotequote all
Phil117 said:
Funny enough we were discussing this over on the R forum in some detail. Exactly what you said, many s/t's like yourself don't have a business account or are Vat registered.

If you are genuinely a sole trader, 100% you will get through. Some proof will be enough. It's just Volkswagen wanting to cover their own back.

One idea I came up with, for those who aren't actually sole traders, is to just go the B&Q and Wickes and buy some tiny bits, and obviously a McDonalds drive through; and give them your bank statement saying your a tiny builder so not VAT registered and use your personal bank account and that's all you have.

But yes, don't worry.If you a s/t it will be fine.
Thanks for the response.