Bootliners - anyone tried these

[Roscopeko]

Looking for a bootliner and narrowed it down to these 3 products has anyone anyone any experience?

UK custom covers

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/BMW-3-SERIES-E91-TOURING...

http://www.hatchbag.co.uk/page.php?xPage=bootliner...

http://www.roofbox.co.uk/scripts/rbvehsel4_tab.php...

Its for an E91 BMW 3 series touring with 2 dogs to transport and occasional tip runs ...

Cheers
Ross.

[Escort3500]

+ 1 for the Hatchbag. Tough and well made. Haven't had a problem with the Velcro on mine though. It's also worth getting the flap that goes over the bumper.

[Roscopeko]

Thanks Terry appreciated.

Yeah id not fancy putting self tappers into boot ...its spanking new - to me anyways :-)

The 320 has underfloor storage in boot (where spare would normally be)would you say the liner you have would render this space unuseable?

Lovely woofers BTW

[Roscopeko]

Thanks Escort also

[fizzwheel]

As an alternateive to what you are looking at.

We've got one of these in our A6 and had one in our Focus CMAX as well.

http://boot-buddy.com/BootBuddy/High-SidedBootBudd...

We tried one similar to the ones you are looking at but it wouldnt stay in place. Whereas the boot buddy IMHO is a better solution as it stays in place and is more sturdy. Also its a two minute job to take it out if you want to. Although storing it is a bit of a PIA, but to be honest we just leave ours in the car all the time.

[Roscopeko]

fizzwheel said:

As an alternateive to what you are looking at.

We've got one of these in our A6 and had one in our Focus CMAX as well.

http://boot-buddy.com/BootBuddy/High-SidedBootBudd...

We tried one similar to the ones you are looking at but it wouldnt stay in place. Whereas the boot buddy IMHO is a better solution as it stays in place and is more sturdy. Also its a two minute job to take it out if you want to. Although storing it is a bit of a PIA, but to be honest we just leave ours in the car all the time.

They look great Terry the dog guard is well priced and interesting too - thank you :-)

Paddy & Murphy - eeerr sincere apologies - no idea #embarrassed

[the_lone_wolf]

fizzwheel said:

As an alternateive to what you are looking at.

Hi Dave?

[rscott]

Another vote for Hatchbag - our fourth one arrived yesterday! (Change of cars not worn out hatchbags)
Had them in both my Saabs, the other half's Mini and now her Focus and all have suffered no damage at all despite the cars transporting dogs, bikes, mowers and everything you can think of for a horse (saddles, feed, wheelbarrows, etc).
Definitely worth getting the bumper flap and probably door cover too.