Smart roadster vs Japanese kei cars
Discussion
Weight, body style, size, displacement and power all similar.
Which to own?
I can't help finding myself looking at them all. Cheap to tax, fuel, insure and run. I've posted before wanting a smart roadster but can't quite pull the trigger so to speak.
Honda beat is seriously scrating my itch, 3 cyl, with inline throttle bodies, 5spd manual box 8,100rpm limit, returning circa 58mpg.
The thought of general repairs (chip in windscreen, etc) is off putting on the jap cars. The smart roadster isnt cheap in its own right either.
Thoughts?
Which to own?
I can't help finding myself looking at them all. Cheap to tax, fuel, insure and run. I've posted before wanting a smart roadster but can't quite pull the trigger so to speak.
Honda beat is seriously scrating my itch, 3 cyl, with inline throttle bodies, 5spd manual box 8,100rpm limit, returning circa 58mpg.
The thought of general repairs (chip in windscreen, etc) is off putting on the jap cars. The smart roadster isnt cheap in its own right either.
Thoughts?
Mastodon2 said:
I can think of a multitude of reasons I'd never own a Smart Roadster.
And I can think of a multitude of reasons why I'd never sell mine. 
The gearbox can be a problem, but if you have the car chipped it can even out the odd gearchange to an extent. Also, you just have to adjust your gear selection style slightly to make it work for you. It's not hard to do and it makes a world of difference.
I've posted about this before so I'm not going to go on about it again here. But for very inexpensive, fun driving the Roadster is great. There are some very knowledgeable people working on them, too, so you should be able to find someone to look after it for you if you don't want to do it yourself. I take mine to Rob at S2Smarts in Watford, what he doesn't know about these cars isn't worth knowing.
Don't know anything about the Kei cars though, sorry, so I can't give you a comparison. But I certainly wouldn't rule out the Roadster because they're brilliant fun to drive if you get them chipped.
The gearbox is the only thing that puts me off actually owing a Smart Roadster, but my wife is strongly considering one to replace her Hyundai Coupe and I'm encouraging her (on the basis that I get to use it occasionally).
The Smart has some significant advantages of the Beat, Cappuccino etc. in terms of parts availability and non rotting bodyshells. Probably a fair bit safer as well.
The Smart has some significant advantages of the Beat, Cappuccino etc. in terms of parts availability and non rotting bodyshells. Probably a fair bit safer as well.
Mastodon2 said:
I can think of a multitude of reasons I'd never own a Smart Roadster, but with these rare and unusual kei cars, if something goes wrong, who is going to fix it? The Honda Beat is a cool car, but if you take it to a UK Honda dealer they probably won't have a f
king clue.
Who'd take ANY 20yo car to a main dealer...?
king clue.leaks, gear change, servicing isnt cheap for what it is and often doesnt get done propperly ie plugs dont get changed in the roadster NO storage space really least the coupe has the glass house on the back they dont like speed bumps especially the brabus ones. they are slow above like 50
good points mpg the look funky especially the brabus with monoblocks quite chuckable
good points mpg the look funky especially the brabus with monoblocks quite chuckable
Trustmeimadoctor said:
leaks, gear change, servicing isnt cheap for what it is and often doesnt get done propperly ie plugs dont get changed in the roadster NO storage space really least the coupe has the glass house on the back they dont like speed bumps especially the brabus ones. they are slow above like 50
good points mpg the look funky especially the brabus with monoblocks quite chuckable
Leaks - they don't all leak. Mine never has, and I haven't changed anything about the roof or windows. They're all factory standard.good points mpg the look funky especially the brabus with monoblocks quite chuckable
Gear change - I'll give you that! But as I said above, chipping the car can even out the gearchange and you just have to work with it rather than expect it to behave like a manual car.
Servicing - depends where you go. My servicing is always done properly and rarely costs over £200.
No storage space - well, you're not going to be transporting washing machines in there, but you can certainly get a week's worth of family shopping in one.
Speed bumps - true, they don't much like speed bumps. But then again, show me a car that does! I ended up having to sell my Volvo 850 because speed bumps were shaking it to bits. At least the Roadster fits between speed cushions, which is quite handy!
"Slow above like 50" - I honestly can't remember what mine was like before I had it chipped (I only had it a week before it was chipped, and I've had it for 7 years), but it certainly isn't slow now. It's not Lamborghini-quick, but it doesn't need to be. It's plenty fast enough to have fun in and I use mine on motorways without holding up anyone - in all three lanes. (Though I do get out of the way of the people travelling massively in excess of the speed limit, because I don't want to die and I'd also like to hold onto my licence.)
Chuckable - oh yes! It's great fun to drive.

Have you ever owned or even driven one, or are you basing your views on what you've read?
I guess that just shows how 'marmite' the Roadster is - you'll know it's not for you within minutes of driving it. There are plenty of those that can work around the gearbox and learn how to drive it to get the best from it without getting frustrated.
There are plenty of similar cars that will go much faster than the Smart, but most of them won't feel as fast - it's completely possible to have an absolute blast in the Roady and never break the speed limit, the feeling you get of taking corners at what feels like silly speeds and the car never missing a beat is what makes driving fun.
I think the OP should at least test drive one just to see which side of the fence they sit on...
There are plenty of similar cars that will go much faster than the Smart, but most of them won't feel as fast - it's completely possible to have an absolute blast in the Roady and never break the speed limit, the feeling you get of taking corners at what feels like silly speeds and the car never missing a beat is what makes driving fun.
I think the OP should at least test drive one just to see which side of the fence they sit on...
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




