Liable for wind blowing door into another car
Liable for wind blowing door into another car
Author
Discussion

ToothbrushMan

Original Poster:

1,772 posts

156 months

Sunday 3rd August 2014
quotequote all
Whilst hunting around inside my car today the wind gusted and blew the door into my neighbours car door causing paint scuffing down to the primer. Both cars are parked on a private residents car park. I SORN'ed my car last month as i am not using it and so it has no insurance.
I informed the owner who was quite laid back about it as its a company car no skin off his nose but he has to tell his boss. Where do i stand?

DocJock

8,722 posts

271 months

Sunday 3rd August 2014
quotequote all
Waiting with chequebook...

ToothbrushMan

Original Poster:

1,772 posts

156 months

Sunday 3rd August 2014
quotequote all
To add....even if i was insured or was legally required to have insurance on private property would i still be liable for the wind blowing the door? I wasnt negligent unless one says not holding onto the door at all times could be so construed.

Mr Gear

9,416 posts

221 months

Sunday 3rd August 2014
quotequote all
If he can claim for repair without it costing him anything, then you are lucky. If not, prepare to pay up out of your pocket.

huwp

833 posts

206 months

Sunday 3rd August 2014
quotequote all
Liable? Probably.

Indemnified? Probably not.

Mr Gear

9,416 posts

221 months

Sunday 3rd August 2014
quotequote all
ToothbrushMan said:
To add....even if i was insured or was legally required to have insurance on private property would i still be liable for the wind blowing the door? I wasnt negligent unless one says not holding onto the door at all times could be so construed.
It is negligent to have things blowing about untethered. Doesn't matter if it's a plank of wood or a car door.

ToothbrushMan

Original Poster:

1,772 posts

156 months

Sunday 3rd August 2014
quotequote all
Ok.thanks doc. Sounds cut and dried then.

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

229 months

Sunday 3rd August 2014
quotequote all
Something from your property has damaged something of his - yep you will be paying.


What you have to hope for is that when its in the body shop that it is a quick turnaround as you will also be paying for his hire car for the duration plus full repairs.

Nearly all company cars are 3rd party policies so they cannot simply pay the excess and you pay them, in addition they have no reason to be generous to another's position ie you.

Hopefully its a cheap repair - sadly as a co car he/she has no choice to inform of the damage else he would be facing a disciplinary.

ED209

6,032 posts

275 months

Sunday 3rd August 2014
quotequote all
I can't believe someone would try and get out of this, in the interests of common decency and neighbourhood relations you should just smile, apologise and pay up.

y2blade

56,325 posts

246 months

Sunday 3rd August 2014
quotequote all
ED209 said:
I can't believe someone would try and get out of this, in the interests of common decency and neighbourhood relations you should just smile, apologise and pay up.
+1 Amazing isn't it, sign of the times I guess....The "Not my fault" culture. frown



Welshbeef

49,633 posts

229 months

Sunday 3rd August 2014
quotequote all
ED209 said:
I can't believe someone would try and get out of this, in the interests of common decency and neighbourhood relations you should just smile, apologise and pay up.
Thing is even a scuff is going to be in the body shop what 2 days min so let's call that £100-200in rental costs for hire car alone then the repair... £500+ who knows but the point is that this slight gust of wind could end up costing OP £1k - will he reinstate his car insurance now incase something like that happens again? I'm sure some individuals might be thinking or suggesting why not reinstate the car insurance and ask the neighbour to report it x days after the fact (no difference to him) then the OP would only be liable for the excess. But OP don't do this that isn't bending the rules it is fraud.

CYMR0

3,940 posts

231 months

Sunday 3rd August 2014
quotequote all
Welshbeef said:
Something from your property has damaged something of his - yep you will be paying.
That's not why you'd be paying.

In the circumstances: company car is sitting there innocently, OP is faffing with car with an unsecured door blowing around. Which one of those is negligent, if any?

Clearly it can't be the innocent company car.

Is OP some kind of monster? No, obviously not, but unless there is no negligence whatsoever then 100% of the negligence is OP's.

Had an otherwise properly secured roof tile landed on the car, without notice, from a properly maintained roof, I'd suggest there'd be no negligence (and therefore no liability) not withstanding that something from OP's property had damaged something of the neighbour's.

Insurance doesn't make any difference to the liability position.

The obvious solution would be to arrange a smart repair to the damage in the interests of minimising disruption and keeping costs down.

Raize

1,476 posts

210 months

Sunday 3rd August 2014
quotequote all
You went wrong when you informed the owner. He has no evidence against you and that dent could have happened anywhere.

TLandCruiser

2,885 posts

229 months

Sunday 3rd August 2014
quotequote all
y2blade said:
ED209 said:
I can't believe someone would try and get out of this, in the interests of common decency and neighbourhood relations you should just smile, apologise and pay up.
+1 Amazing isn't it, sign of the times I guess....The "Not my fault" culture. frown
Yeah I agree... And to try and say it was not his fault is terrible frown

TLandCruiser

2,885 posts

229 months

Sunday 3rd August 2014
quotequote all
Raize said:
You went wrong when you informed the owner. He has no evidence against you and that dent could have happened anywhere.
If your serious, then you're a cock.

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

229 months

Sunday 3rd August 2014
quotequote all
Raize said:
You went wrong when you informed the owner. He has no evidence against you and that dent could have happened anywhere.
This is one of the things which is wrong with some people - they try to get away with something even though they are to blame, no doubt you would be furious if you came out to find your P&J scratched and dented.


If you are being serious you are a cock.

BFG TERRANO

2,172 posts

179 months

Sunday 3rd August 2014
quotequote all
Your liable for the repair costs.

Sheepshanks

41,406 posts

150 months

Sunday 3rd August 2014
quotequote all
ToothbrushMan said:
Whilst hunting around inside my car today the wind gusted and blew the door into my neighbours car door causing paint scuffing down to the primer. Both cars are parked on a private residents car park. I SORN'ed my car last month as i am not using it and so it has no insurance.
I informed the owner who was quite laid back about it as its a company car no skin off his nose but he has to tell his boss. Where do i stand?
From a practical point of view, your car should be insured. Suppose it burst into flames and destroyed several other cars, what would you do then?

You're also in a very grey area legally by not having insurance. Does the car park have gates to prevent other people entering? Do non-residents ever use it?

Welshbeef

49,633 posts

229 months

Sunday 3rd August 2014
quotequote all
OP any chance of a Picture of the damage? Have you asked permission to see if you can buff it out? Plus while you are doing so get debt master out to fix that part of the issue.

Anything to reduce the costs - provided the user of the car gives permission.




Another route is to be very honest with him saying you have no insurance on it as its SORN'd - he may out of the goodness in his heart simply claim it happened at a supermarket carpark - in return for a nice few boxes of wine. I wouldn't suggest it directly let him think through from you're comment to that end conclusion.

ToothbrushMan

Original Poster:

1,772 posts

156 months

Sunday 3rd August 2014
quotequote all
Only a cock would say nothing about a door thats been scuffed by their car thats been sat in the same space for 3 months then mysteriously been moved a few spaces away on the same day the owner is bound to have seen the damage. It wouldnt take a genius to work it out.
Far from being the ignoramous some have decided i am i have now offered to pay for a smart repair.